@the3els@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON@TopTierPucks I literally mentioned who I would put infront of Marino on a list and I took Rogers off the list. Did I mention any of those other names being better? And Marino had some all time greats in receivers. And yes I will agree, Marino was more talented. However, Elway used his legs.
@DustinWorkman90@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON@TopTierPucks Okay so Trent Dilfer is better than Josh Allen and Eli Manning is better than Dan Marino? That's the take we are going with?
Wins aren't a qb stat. Elway had better teams than Marino but Marino was more talented.
@HugeGato@TopTierPucks@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON Yes I said the biggest one is SB wins IMO. Didn’t say the only one. Go back and read. You are entitled to your own opinion the same way as I am. While Marino may have had the better statistical career. The rings weigh a lot in rankings. Google search QB rankings. It’s mixed.
@DustinWorkman90@TopTierPucks@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON You say there’re a lot of factors but it seems the only one to you is Super Bowl wins.
Because a QB who was getting almost 50 TDs a season while his opponents were getting literally half that doesn’t factor in at all
@the3els@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON@TopTierPucks Especially when they carry their team! Like Elway and Brees…. Not saying they didn’t have a supporting cast around them but they were THE reason their team appeared in multiple SBs.
@the3els@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON@TopTierPucks Not sure how you meant this. If you agree that Elway is better then I apologize. Disregard. But if you meant what I think you meant…. I literally just did and proved my point. 5 SB appearances and 1 win VS 1 SB appearance and 0 wins. Elway had more wins and less losses as well.
@TopTierPucks@Nicapedia@baltimorefeller@WH1TEBI7ON A lot of factors go into these rankings that you can argue about. SB wins are a big part IMO. Brees is 2nd all time passing yards and TDs with a ring. Elway appeared in 5 SB and won 2 while Marino appeared in 1 and lost. Rogers only 1. I’ll stick with Brees and Elway better.
@NixForSix@NFLonPrime Bruh… Everyone has a right to have their own opinion but don’t embarrass us… We don’t even deserve to be on this list until proven. Let alone the top of the list…
@Broncos4six I mean he’s right about that picture. Brady over Bo but he made a list of current QBs who Brady is still better than and as you can imagine, Bo was on it but he left out Drake Maye who is worse than Bo…. 🧐