Daniel Keating

555 posts

Daniel Keating banner
Daniel Keating

Daniel Keating

@keatingd

UMich Psych Developmental Area Chair & ISR Research Professor, author Born Anxious https://t.co/aywFBWvI8v

Ann Arbor, MI انضم Mart 2011
451 يتبع438 المتابعون
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
After the “Rupture”, by @keatingd open.substack.com/pub/danielkeat… With the rupture of the international "order", what are our choices? Oligarchy of billionaires, or advancing population developmental health? See my new substack; subscription is free.
English
1
0
2
22
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
@evavivalt An interesting set of findings that monetary transfers reduce hours worked. I do take issue with defining leisure as the opposite of productive time use. From a human development perspective, leisure has many potential benefits, like stress reduction, more parenting, & self-care.
English
1
0
4
284
Eva Vivalt
Eva Vivalt@evavivalt·
We are happy to release the first results of a RCT of a US program that provided $1,000/month unconditionally for 3 years to 1,000 individuals in the treatment group, with a group of 2,000 people receiving $50/month serving as the control. These are sizable transfers. 1/ 🧵
Eva Vivalt tweet media
English
168
1.2K
5.8K
2.6M
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
A brilliant and balanced overview of the teens and social media research, a must read for anyone offering opinions about it. Not to be overlooked: the clear evidence that mental health risks in development are overwhemingly from "offline" sources like childhood adversity.
English
0
0
3
220
Michael Podhorzer
Michael Podhorzer@Mike_Podhorzer·
5) When he was confirmed, Roberts famously claimed that the proper role of the court was to be “an umpire, calling balls and strikes.” But while previous justices toggled between narrow and expansive strike zones, the Roberts court declares winners and losers.
English
6
139
684
16.5K
Michael Podhorzer
Michael Podhorzer@Mike_Podhorzer·
Alito and Thomas have made clear their insurrectionist connections. So why are we debating whether Alito should recuse himself, instead of demanding Roberts dismiss Trump’s immunity appeal so the J6 trial can begin immediately? (It’s called “dismissed as improvidently granted”—when a court recognizes that they never should have taken up a case in the first place.)
English
134
2.2K
6.8K
250K
Daniel Keating أُعيد تغريده
Lyle Spencer
Lyle Spencer@Spe81558890Lyle·
Very few pitchers mastered the screwball. Fernando, who I covered as a beat writer. Carl Hubbell, who I interviewed about Fernando. Jim Brewer, who I covered as a kid beat writer in 73/74. Any others come to mind, thinking fans?
English
467
6
183
95.7K
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
No doubt the patriarchy privileges men, greatly. But boys’ uncried tears lead to men repressing their “soft” emotions, then demanding girls and women manage that pain for them. And get angry when they won’t, or can’t. Time to replace the system.
emily may@emilykmay

🧵i tweeted this a few months ago and got ✨dragged✨but the real question i was asking is: where do we hear about the pain and inner lives of men? i asked a male friend this question and he replied, "no one wants to hear about men's inner lives." /1

English
0
0
2
281
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
Not the best forum, a complex issue. But: the claim-social media causes the mental health epidemic- lacks sound evidence. An alternative hypothesis: increased stress from many sources (see eg APA surveys) has psychological and physio effects. More research on both is needed.
Schopenhauer's Poodle@ArthursPoodle

@gmiller @keatingd It genuinely baffles me to. I've tried to press a few people on it since even the nature review, for example, was so clearly insufficient to prove her point. All of the alternative factors were just as badly justified, if not worse. Yet nobody seems to mention it.

English
0
0
5
284
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
1. If the causal claim that social media cause anxiety & depression it should account for large variance in longitudinal population studies. It doesn’t. A few percent at most. 2. Trends in climate fear, school shootings, etc are evident. Their link to outcomes merit more research
English
2
0
2
635
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
I haven’t done a systematic review or meta-analysis specifically of possible sex or gender moderation, and haven’t seen one. But overall effects from careful longitudinal studies of population data are small to none, so they wouldn’t have much to work with, I suspect.
Jeff Lees (@leesplez.bsky.social)@Leesplez

Couldn't agree more! And it's not just structural issues beyond phones/social media that are downplayed, it's structural issues *about phones/social media* that are ignored... e.g., Haidt himself cites data on gender effects, why do you think girls have worse experiences online?

English
0
0
1
235
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
Being open to evidence is crucial, especially on causal claims. Could be cumulative or not, and other validity claims need investigation. But Haidt’s assertion is that we have the causal evidence to enact policy. We don’t, as @candice_odgers notes. Much evidence to the contrary.
Robert Kubinec@rmkubinec

I'm also open-minded on this. Part of it is due to limitations in current experimental methods, which are *not* designed to track a small effect that accumulates over time. For example, see the revised conclusion that small amts of alcohol can have long-term health risks. (1/2)

English
0
2
4
441
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
Good points. The social media moral panic is not harmless. Some parents will severely restrict use, denying social connections for kids who have few options. Big picture: it diverts attention from real stressors harming mental health- climate, gun violence, inequality, racism etc
Jeff Lees (@leesplez.bsky.social)@Leesplez

If Haidt's book were titled "phones/social media are bad sometimes" then this would be good evidence, but it's not. He's making grand claims about "rewiring" of kids brains, then large causal claims about societal shifts, then calling for significant government intervention...

English
34
14
30
31.5K
Daniel Keating أُعيد تغريده
Isabela Granic
Isabela Granic@PlayNiceInst·
As one of the most respected scientists in this field almost says: the book will make a boatload of money praying on parents’ worst fears & none of it is supported by data. We’re distracting the public w/ headlines, and not dealing w/ real causes. nature.com/articles/d4158…
English
1
3
11
1.9K
Daniel Keating أُعيد تغريده
Dr. Brie M Reid
Dr. Brie M Reid@briemreid·
I want to send this review by @candice_odgers to every parent and caregiver I know who are worried about teen mental health and social media/tech use
Mental Health in the Digital Age@MentalHealthOII

@Candice_Odgers shares an excellent review of a controversial book that gets things wrong on an important topic. If you study or care about youth and adolescent health in the digital age, please give this one a read. #digitalwellbeing #youthmentalhealth nature.com/articles/d4158…

English
1
1
16
2.5K
Daniel Keating
Daniel Keating@keatingd·
Thank you @candice_odgers for excellent analysis. Folks hope banning a single villain, smartphones, would reverse the adolescent mental health crisis. This ignores the pervasive social stressors at fault: climate, gun violence, racism etc, inequality, and threats to democracy.
Mental Health in the Digital Age@MentalHealthOII

@Candice_Odgers shares an excellent review of a controversial book that gets things wrong on an important topic. If you study or care about youth and adolescent health in the digital age, please give this one a read. #digitalwellbeing #youthmentalhealth nature.com/articles/d4158…

English
0
0
9
506

اكتشف

@evavivalt @Mike_Podhorzer @mlamont6 @elonmusk @BarackObama @taylorswift13 @cristiano @BillGates