ChoiKangLove

全部专辑扫图，伟大的atiny

나는 진짜 레몬드랍이나 인유판 때도 이렇게까지 속상하지 않았음...골든아워 통해서 하고 싶은 거 다 하려나 보다 좋게 생각하려고 했는데 이번엔 진짜..왜..아무리 대중성과 성적을 다 잡고 싶다고 해도 그렇지 엥??스럽고 의미도 없는 반복적 가사로 점철된 노래를 내면,,,뭘 기대해야 해,,3컴백 한다고 호기롭게 말했으면 차라리 외부의 힘을 빌리기라도 하지,..

@bhodduck This song just repeats a single phrase nonstop, leaving the lead vocalist with zero room to showcase their talent. We need to put an end to these overly short tracks made solely for TikTok trends

메인보컬이 메인보컬 역할을 해야지 메보가 빠질 때가 있다는게 무슨 소리일까? 억파트 라는 의미가 뭘까? 나 이해를 전혀 못하겠다 spin-spin.com/q/6a3e413c5375…

@cest_AZ When the track length preview was released at first, many people wouldn’t allow any criticism. Are we still not allowed to point out the flaws now? This is exactly the downside of an overly short song.

존나 안미안한데 혹시 이 그룹은 7인조임?

@prnc_Mingi Yet many people won’t let anyone bring this up, insisting that a short track doesn’t equal a flop. But given this song’s structure and the terrible vocal line distribution, I personally think it’s underwhelming, and I don’t like it at all

@prnc_Mingi It’s true that the monotonous, repetitive structure of the song leaves almost no vocal segments for Jongho to showcase his skills, and it’s also a fact that such an overly short track can barely earn high average scores.

can we address the fact that both yeosang and jongho barely got any screen time??? complete bullshit

@EvgeniaOle86542 @bhodduck Is there any benefit to you driving someone away just because you dislike their taste? Everyone has their own aesthetic standards. Is there anything wrong with not liking a certain style

@bhodduck Oh my god... You don't like anything. Why are you all so upset and can't you just leave the fandom? Why should you poor people suffer like this...

컨포도 점점 활동과 연관없는 사진 몇장 찍고 앨범으로 내고 10년동안 같이 했는데도 아직도 멤버 보컬들 어떻게 쓰면 좋을지 우리보다 더 모르는 전담팀으로 곡 찍어내고 메인보컬한테는 어느파트 좋은지 물어보지도 않도 그냥 억고음 파트 몇개 던지고 앨범 계속 내는거 언제까지 할거임? 너네가 앨범 어때요 묻는데 정말별로에요 말할 수 있는 에이티니가 있겠냐고 애초에 다 너네한테 좋은 말만 해주고 싶어서 안말하고 있는거지 이걸 ㅇㅋ좋았나보네다행이다 하고 넘기다가 여기까지와버렸지 이러다가 멤버들 이제 이런 반응들 보고 돌아가면서 팝 오겠죠 오빠들의 수는 뻔히 읽히는데 왜 바뀌지를 않을까

@bhodduck So many people discourage anyone from speaking up, ever since the track length issue first came out.

@bhodduck I have to say I really dislike this comeback’s songs. Starting with the overly short track lengths, my disappointment only grew after the previews dropped. The title track just feels like it’s repeating the same phrase over and over.

@milkknstarss @brierotica 那你就继续抑郁吧，大傻逼

@brierotica jongho ruins every song

ateez's music makes me depressed like why's it so bad

@hotyapper 期待你的更多视频翻译，我知道这是大工程☺️☺️☺️☺️

For those who want to see a visual example of how I translate the members' POP lives: this is a clip from Mingi's live today - I screen record the live, during this time I write down the translation of what they're saying in a document for reference as I edit - after the live is complete, I upload the file into CapCut > add watermark > add captions - if a livestream is relatively short (15-30 minutes) I can get it done fairly quickly (also depending on how much is said) - short lives also mean I can edit on my phone (like in the live today), translating it as I go - I never. ever. use the auto translate feature for my translations. All of the translation captions are completely my own

@0Ella_allE0 I’ve sent numerous emails to KQ regarding sasaeng issues, yet the company has taken no action and never released any official announcements. 😔

한국인 팔로워분들 중에 에이티니이면서 푸딩인 분들께 묻고 싶어요.왜 이 계정을 KQ에 신고하지 않나요? @/244ani56823 이 계정은 몇 년째 산에 대한 악성 루머를 퍼뜨리고 있는데, 왜 KQ는 이들을 고소하지 않는 건가요? 구글 번역기를 사용해서 번역이 완벽하지 않을 수 있는 점 양해 부탁드립니다

@likeasatoru Can’t we simply prefer not to listen to overly short songs as a personal choice?Of course, I probably won’t listen to this song often if I don’t like it, but that doesn’t mean I’m acting like an anti-fan in any way.☺️

@beingatiny penso assim. eu sou fã do ateez exatamente por eles serem fora da curva e possuirem uma qualidade absurda em seus trabalhos, mas me preocupa o que essa pessima gestao feita por essa empresa pode fazer com eles.

eu acho preocupante sim um grupo com 8 membros ter músicas com um tempo tão curto pq quem realmente é fã do ateez e da sua discografia sabe o que acontece nesses casos ne... but okay

@likeasatoru Yes, they were originally known for high-quality songs. However, the prevalent trend of overly short tracks in the industry is really problematic. It’s clearly wrong for the company to follow this unhealthy trend. We’re merely pointing out the issue without any extreme behavior.

@seaforests This unhealthy trend plagues the industry, and I hope it fades away soon. They must have finalized this track long in advance; it was probably just an experimental attempt. The other non-title tracks still have proper full lengths, so we can just wait for their next comeback.

@beingatiny it’s because it’s allllll about streaming and going viral and numbers numbers numbers these days, with everyone. and so often the artistry gets pushed to the side as a result 😔

what are we as a society going to do about the 2 second long song epidemic

@matzhood 😟😟😟😟

ai ninguem merece title com 2 minutos

@KeyCachaceiro @matzhood Every agency is the same; nearly all groups tailor their music for short-form video platforms instead of catering to fans' preferences.

@matzhood MAS ainda sim odeio músicas curtas do fundo do meu coração tudo culpa da fudida da kq

@furytoodamnlate Nearly all K-pop fans are questioning these shortened songs, yet every group keeps going down this route. I can’t figure out why labels are so fixated on this formula.

this awful trend of songs being under three minutes is for sure something, especially when it comes to groups

tt being that short, oh i already know who’s gonna get fucked over again

@Arthur_SH13 Same here. I’m especially confused by these extremely short title tracks. Around 90% of my anticipation for their comeback has faded away.

@SWEETJILI I don't want to be a hater, but I really don't feel like I'm going to like this cb I feel like it'll be kind of generic. I hope I'm wrong.

Yep....No it's fine...It's cool...Ye😃

@SWEETJILI Yeah, none of the K-pop fans in China are fond of short-form tracks. We thought it was just a trend popular overseas, but turns out everyone hates it after seeing it today. How did this style even get mainstream anyway。。。

@beingatiny Yeah, like I get it if there's only one or two people. But eight? I really hope groups with more members don't do this because that's insane. No way it's possible😭

The rest better fucking be units because...the title is two and a half minutes