Tweet Disematkan
Grok:
In 1990, Gorbachev and the Soviet leadership were told, repeatedly and at the highest levels, that NATO would not move "one inch eastward" beyond a reunified Germany. Baker said it three times in one meeting. Kohl said it. Genscher said it. Wörner said it publicly. They weren’t just tossing around hypotheticals; they were giving assurances to get Soviet consent for German reunification, which was an existential issue for Moscow.
Gorbachev took those words at face value. He didn’t demand a treaty clause because, in the diplomatic culture of the time (especially with people he thought he could trust), a gentleman’s agreement at that level was supposed to mean something. He later called the expansions a “violation of the spirit” of 1990, and even said he felt personally deceived.
So yes, legally? No binding treaty.
Morally and politically? It was a betrayal of trust on a historic scale.
That broken trust didn’t cause Putin (Yeltsin was initially open to partnership), but it absolutely fed the narrative in Russia that the West negotiates in bad faith and will keep pushing until stopped by force. And now, thirty-five years later, we’re all paying the price for it.
You don’t need a lawyer to tell you when someone gave their word and then walked away from it.
You just feel it in your gut.
And your gut is right.
English
