MrsA

7.3K posts

MrsA

MrsA

@abritishparent

가입일 Ağustos 2014
183 팔로잉234 팔로워
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@Keir_Starmer If you want every young person to have the ‘opportunity to get as far as their talents take them’, why tax education causing disruption for thousands of children? Why axe the Latin Excellence Programme? Why cut support for MFL hubs? Why discard the Stimulating Physics Network?
English
2
2
14
90
Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer@Keir_Starmer·
Hope comes from our young people - and I want a country where every young person has the opportunity to get as far as their talents take them.
English
2.6K
289
1.1K
132.6K
MrsA 리트윗함
Nick Almond
Nick Almond@DrNickA·
This tweet is a fascinating insight into the dire state of the U.K. Mostly it’s people who find it morally abhorrent for people to be on minimum wage serving coffee. If you can’t use the minimum wage for entry level unskilled work. What can you use it for? Many seem to think Peter should divert his savings to subsidise higher wages effectively operating at a loss. An economically irrational thing to do. Why would you pay (and work) to lose money? Many seem to think he should shut the coffee shop down completely, removing those jobs from the market all together. Presumably no jobs is a better outcome than minimum wage jobs. The minimum wage is now roughly £26k a year. About what I started on as a mathematics lecturer in 2010 after I completed by PhD. I worked 60-80 hours a week. Your take home pay on the national average wage is only £170 a week more than someone on a minimum wage job. Which in order to get you’d need to have a profession and about a decades worth of experience in that profession. That’s like one family meal and maybe a trip to the cinema. Hardly worth a decades hard work is it? And if you’re trying to save for a property, you won’t be able to have that. It also means that the median UK worker is a family meal and some mild entertainment away from morally objectionable abject poverty. What a mess
Peter McCormack 🏴‍☠️🇬🇧🇮🇪@PeterMcCormack

A minimum wage of £15 would end my coffee shop, it would have to close, as would many other businesses. I’ll explain for the economically illiterate. Staff costs are currently half our costs, a £15 minimum wage is actually more than £15 an hour for the company, because you have to add: - 12.07% holiday - Sick pay - Maternity pay if and when required - National insurance - Pension contributions These costs would mean the shop loses money because remember, energy costs are up, rates are up, regulations are up. Now you can pass these costs onto the consumer - that would mean charging a lot more for coffee, people won’t pay it. The likes of Starbucks and Costa can, because they have economies of scale. The independent doesn’t. Now the little socialist will say well this is your fault, if you can’t run a business that can afford to pay its staff properly, but the little socialist has never run a business and does not understand the dynamics. Now I could pay some staff off and fill those hours myself or reduce us to one staff member during certain periods - but this proves the point that a minimum wage costs jobs. There was a time when these jobs were done by kids, perhaps on the weekend, paid a lower wage, no holiday and no silly employment rights. Perhaps they were even paid cash. The dynamic worked and small businesses like this could operate. It was also a great first job. Sadly now it isn’t worth employing entitlement youngsters at this level of pay. So alas, I don’t need the stress, the business would close, a number of jobs would be lost. Economics is about understanding these dynamics, no vibes. The cost of living is not solved through passing on inflation to the business, it is solved by ending high inflation and creating prosperity. This is what socialists don’t understand, they can’t create prosperity, they can only destroy it.

English
203
168
1.7K
194.4K
MrsA 리트윗함
Kit Peacock
Kit Peacock@KitPeacock·
If you understand why small independent shops can't easily absorb a sudden 18% increase in costs, you understand why small not for profit independent schools can't easily absorb 20% VAT, minimum wage and a national insurance raise in the same year.
English
15
52
363
6.5K
MrsA 리트윗함
Will Kingston
Will Kingston@WillKingston·
Leftists don’t understand the (very simple) concept of trade-offs. If you hike VAT on private schools, kids leave private schools and place more pressure on the state. If you implement rent controls, you reduce the supply and quality of housing. And if you increase the minimum wage, less businesses hire people. It’s difficult to debate them because they don’t operate in reality. They’re children.
Will Kingston tweet media
English
265
653
3.3K
65.5K
MrsA 리트윗함
Olly
Olly@oIIyjm·
There's a reason the question wasn't answered - the policy was a nonsense from the beginning. The most recent data shows we have fewer teachers now than when @UKLabour came into government. And last week they announced the plan to hire 6000 fewer teachers again. They lied.
Farrukh@implausibleblog

Lady in yellow, "The Labour Party made it very clear that by taxing independent schools 20% VAT that you would put an additional 6,500 teachers into the teaching environment to help support SEND within schools" "Where's that gone?" Fiona Bruce, "Okay, I'm gonna. I suspect you. I'm just gonna get around a few more people"

English
5
67
274
3.7K
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@jrkdenison @bananatransit @Sum1st @DrNickA @kay88297 Very supportive of vouchers. The current system breeds apathy because it removes ownership of the educational journey from families. If parents were given the agency to choose it would naturally lead to higher engagement & value being placed on the process.
English
0
0
2
23
James Denison
James Denison@jrkdenison·
School choice gets crowded out by the state system. The state forces you to pay tax and then forces you to use a "free" (at the point of use) state school when you can't afford anything else. (Or you homeschool.) Many of us who oppose taxing education also campaign for education vouchers to open up choice to all families regardless of means.
English
2
0
1
42
Nick Almond
Nick Almond@DrNickA·
Having argued with people about private schools for days now. It basically comes down to the fact that some people think it is fundamentally wrong that some people have more money, than other people.
English
280
97
2.7K
81K
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@kay88297 @bananatransit @jrkdenison @DrNickA Yes, sadly lots of children with SEND impacted. But even beyond just those with a diagnosis, some kids are highly capable, don’t need specialist provision but are "fragile" in large, noisy, high pressure environments. Yet they thrive in a small private or alternative pedagogy .
English
0
0
3
34
Mrs Mac
Mrs Mac@kay88297·
@bananatransit @abritishparent @jrkdenison @DrNickA I think that’s where a lot of anger comes from. At my daughter’s old prep there was a large number of children with SEND, many joined part way through after being unsupported in SS, it wasn’t a lifestyle choice for them. Sadly the school has just announced it’s closing in July.
English
1
0
3
38
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@bananatransit @jrkdenison @DrNickA @kay88297 Do you see a value in plurality of educational provision, acknowledging that different brains require different environments to thrive? How do you feel about provision for different pedagogical choices or for children whose primary strength is not academic but art/music/sport.
English
0
0
1
18
MrsA 리트윗함
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@bananatransit @jrkdenison @DrNickA @kay88297 I’m also in favour of grammars. They can help create a meritocracy by giving opportunities to gifted children from poor backgrounds. They don’t address the need for plurality though (niche pedagogy, bilingual, faith, SEND etc.)
English
1
0
0
33
James Denison
James Denison@jrkdenison·
I don't think it's about money because no-one seems to have a problem with those who are well off using state education even if they could easily afford to pay fees. Fundamentally, it's tribal bigotry. "You toffs think you're better than us. You don't want your precious darling children mixing with the proles. You want to buy them an unfair advantage over everyone else. You're arrogant and aloof. You're cheating the system. We're going to take you down a peg. Force you to slum it with the hoi polloi." It doesn't matter to them that there is enormous inequality across the state school system that dramatically favours the very wealthy. It also doesn't matter to them that there is wide variation within the independent sector, or that many independent schools only exist to cater for needs that no-one would wish on any child. If you choose independence, you have rejected The Group. You are an apostate and a traitor, a nonconformist, an enemy and a target.
James Denison tweet media
English
13
12
103
4.9K
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@bananatransit @jrkdenison @DrNickA @kay88297 Yet people seem perfectly ok with well-resourced, affluent state schools that deliver strong results & notable alumni (London Oratory, Dame Alice Owen’s, QE’s Barnet.) These create Oxbridge/Russell Group pipelines & alumni networks many modest private schools could only dream of.
English
1
0
2
64
Bananas in Transit
Bananas in Transit@bananatransit·
@jrkdenison @DrNickA @kay88297 Some of that is true, most of it is not. My issue with private schools is that they’re incredibly well resourced and produce very well connected children who experience disproportionate success. They sound amazing, so why should such a thing be gatewalled by parental wealth?
English
4
0
0
180
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@jrkdenison @DrNickA @kay88297 Exactly this! It often feels more about enforcing a kind of conformity through the lens of the state as the ‘rightful’ provider. Choosing something ‘outside’ the system gets framed as disloyalty and superiority signaling, even when the motivations are many and diverse.
English
0
0
5
79
MrsA 리트윗함
Neil O'Brien
Neil O'Brien@NeilDotObrien·
This is a perfectly reasonable question - they said the money would go on more teachers, then they said they'd spent it on something else, now there are fewer teachers, not more. So why block the question?
Farrukh@implausibleblog

Lady in yellow, "The Labour Party made it very clear that by taxing independent schools 20% VAT that you would put an additional 6,500 teachers into the teaching environment to help support SEND within schools" "Where's that gone?" Fiona Bruce, "Okay, I'm gonna. I suspect you. I'm just gonna get around a few more people"

English
13
163
900
29.2K
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@COOKIETSC @vickygrayson_ @Benjibontheta @rwoolfy29 @oldishbird1 @lehain I was offered an appointment, given a time and accepted the appointment over the phone. I didn’t have to accept the appointment if I couldn’t make it/didn’t feel I needed it. People have clearly accepted the appointment then just not turned up.
English
1
0
0
15
MrsA
MrsA@abritishparent·
@vickygrayson_ @COOKIETSC @Benjibontheta @rwoolfy29 @oldishbird1 @lehain I had to go to out of hrs GP a few weeks back (appt made through 111 previous night). Turned up 10:30am on Sat morning & was seen by a lovely retired GP who told me she’d been there for 2 hrs & I was her first patient. Nobody else had turned up for their appt.
English
3
0
1
53