Phillip Kirschberg

67K posts

Phillip Kirschberg banner
Phillip Kirschberg

Phillip Kirschberg

@RushmoreExt23

Smoking/tobacco harm reduction advocate. WNL co-host. ASU Alumni '97 🌹 Not humorless. Personal account. I'd prefer to make the world a better place, and you?

Birmingham Katılım Nisan 2011
1.1K Takip Edilen3.7K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Phillip Kirschberg
Phillip Kirschberg@RushmoreExt23·
It seems @FDATobacco is still unsure of how to inform middle-aged adults and seniors who smoke that switching completely to safer nicotine products like e-cigarettes can dramatically reduce their overall health risks. Perhaps this feels so unsatisfactory because recent FDA/CDC data indicates that past-30-day use of e-cigarettes among HS students is hovering around 7.1%, which represents a massive 75% total reduction since its peak in 2019. The time to address the 1,300 smoking-related deaths that occur each day in the US with a sense of urgency is now. H/T @gbentley1
Cliff Douglas@cdoug

At #SRNT2026 today, during a panel discussion featuring @FDATobacco's (CTP's) leadership team, Dr. David Ashley, former director of CTP's Office of Science, asked what the agency is doing to better educate adults who smoke about relative risk and the health benefits of switching to FDA-authorized noncombustible products. The answer unfortunately fell well short of what is desparately needed with 1,300 Americans dying DAILY from smoking. Anne Rancourt, the director of CTP's Office of Health Communication and Education, who is responsible for conducting public education, stakeholder outreach, and regulatory communication programs, said "we are looking very closely at what we can do in the adult education realm" with appropriate nuance about completely switching to FDA-authorized products. She also said "it needs to be personalized to the individual," even though that isn't how FDA communicates in this area. She also said that it should be a message that, "if heard by youth, won't encourage them to start using" these products. That was pretty much it. With due respect to these folks at FDA who are navigating challenging territory, why does this feel so unsatisfactory as we near the 17th anniversary of the Center for Tobacco Products?

English
5
17
40
4.4K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Matthew W. Johnson
Matthew W. Johnson@Drug_Researcher·
Disagree with Makary's resistance to flavored vapes, which is why he apparently quit FDA (or maybe asked to do so). Flavors are attractive to adults and make vaping a better competitor to more dangerous combustible cigarettes. Yes, do what we can to keep out of hands of kids, but don't limit adult choices that can improve their health.
reason@reason

Marty Makary's irrational resistance to flavored nicotine vapes drove his FDA resignation. He let his emotions override his avowed commitment to following the science. reason.com/2026/05/12/mar…

English
6
7
40
4.9K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
reason
reason@reason·
Marty Makary's irrational resistance to flavored nicotine vapes drove his FDA resignation. He let his emotions override his avowed commitment to following the science. reason.com/2026/05/12/mar…
English
2
16
34
8K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Gregory Conley
Gregory Conley@GregTHR·
@By_CJewett @DrMakaryFDA @davidalim No mention that FDA career scientific staff recommended the Glas flavor authorizations and Makary overruled them for months. Trust the scientists—unless the scientists say something politically inconvenient.
Gregory Conley tweet media
English
0
13
34
836
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Guy Bentley
Guy Bentley@gbentley1·
@DrMakaryFDA resigned because he was forced to listen to his own scientists, who recommended authorizing a few fruit-flavored vapes that would help smokers quit. Makary claims he couldn't agree because of the youth appeal. He's wrong.
Guy Bentley tweet media
Christina Jewett@By_CJewett

Scoop on @DrMakaryFDA resignation goes to @davidalim & co. But we add: Dr. Makary ultimately resigned over concerns about the administration’s decision to authorize fruit-flavored e-cigarettes, an action he opposed. 🎁nytimes.com/2026/05/12/us/…

English
2
16
27
925
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Vaping360
Vaping360@Vaping360·
FDA Commissioner Martin Makary has been forced to resign, following a clash with the White House over vaping regulation and numerous other issues. vaping360.com/vape-news/fda-…
Vaping360 tweet media
English
0
3
4
133
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Gregory Conley
Gregory Conley@GregTHR·
Rhode Island is not banning menthol cigarettes, as they're so dependent on cigarette tax revenue that the tax gets hiked every other year. Best of luck to those in RI. There is an email to submit testimony in the below tweet.
Lisa Ciarlone@LisaCiarlone

🚨 RHODE ISLAND CALL TO ACTION 🚨 MENTHOL VAPE BAN — SENATE BILL S2098 🏛 Senate Finance Committee Hearing 📍 Rhode Island State House Room 211 📅 Tuesday, May 12, 2026 ⏰ 4:00 PM ❌ Can’t attend the hearing? 📧 Send written testimony to: SenateFinance@rilegislature.gov ⏳ Submit before 3PM Tuesday. 🎤 Speak up for adults who deserve better options than cigarettes. Over 64,000 adult Rhode Islanders use vapor products, nearly 7% of the adult population. Why does the state keep trying to push adults back toward cigarettes? Rhode Island already has a flavor ban that has negatively impacted adults who switched away from smoking. Now Senate Bill S2098 would ban menthol vapor products too, leaving tobacco flavored products as one of the only remaining options. Meanwhile, cigarettes still kill over 8 million people globally, more than 480,000 Americans every year, and approximately 1,800 Rhode Islanders annually. 💙 Protect harm reduction 🗽 Protect adult choice!

English
1
10
24
1.2K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Arielle Selya
Arielle Selya@ArielleSelya·
Good coverage of the recent study in @NTR_Journal finding that, when analyzing e-cigs & switching in PATH, the decision to include people who didn't necessarily plan to quit with vaping shows stronger favorable results. @Clive_Bates and I are quoted within on the implications.
Clearing the Air@clearingthe_air

Same data, opposite results. 🤯 A deep dive into US vaping research shows that how a study is designed, not the data itself, dictates whether it looks like vapes help you quit. By ignoring "accidental switchers," researchers are burying thousands of success stories. 📉 Read the full breakdown here: clearingtheair.eu/post/why-some-…

English
0
17
35
3.7K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Charles A. Gardner, PhD
Charles A. Gardner, PhD@ChaunceyGardner·
I cannot overstate the importance of this fact. Nicotine vapes help people quit smoking even when they had not intention to quit. No one ever "quit by accident" with a nicotine patch or gum.
Arielle Selya@ArielleSelya

Good coverage of the recent study in @NTR_Journal finding that, when analyzing e-cigs & switching in PATH, the decision to include people who didn't necessarily plan to quit with vaping shows stronger favorable results. @Clive_Bates and I are quoted within on the implications.

English
4
22
66
2.5K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Gregory Conley
Gregory Conley@GregTHR·
Good summary by @NicholasFlorko. Most people picture President Trump vs. an embattled FDA Commissioner involving Trump overruling "the experts." To the contrary, on Glas at least, Trump and FDA scientists were actually in alignment.
Gregory Conley tweet media
The Atlantic@TheAtlantic

FDA commissioner Marty Makary has shown again and again that he’s willing to put politics first, a strategy that may have created the conditions for his own fall from power, Nicolas Florko argues: theatlantic.com/health/2026/05…

English
3
11
42
3.1K
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Kiran Sidhu
Kiran Sidhu@KiranSidhu51·
Looking to speak to vape consumers in Belgium re: vape flavour ban. Please send a DM or Kiransidhu2@btinternet.com
GIF
English
2
19
23
759
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Jim McCarthy
Jim McCarthy@JMacNYC·
Thanks for the good hand despite FTN's indifference, Phillip! Here's my analysis. FTN producers know full well that vaping was the predominant FDA factor this week. They also know the head of @CBSNews, @bariweiss, has published numerous pro-vaping articles like this one. So has @CBSEveningNews anchor @tonydokoupil. They were likely under pressure to bring it up. But the dilemma is there's no way to broach it now without conceding that even @FDATobacco has at long last formally authorized flavored vaping since it helps people quit smoking which, of course, runs contrary to years of anti-vape scaremongering and hyperventilating in the mainstream press, including CBS. It also means offending the public health establishment. So what's the easiest solution at hand? Why it's the oldest excuse in journalism, we really wanted to but just didn't have the space for it. thefp.com/p/the-kids-are…
Jim McCarthy tweet media
English
0
1
2
118
Phillip Kirschberg
Phillip Kirschberg@RushmoreExt23·
Jim McCarthy@JMacNYC

Aaand it's a push. Not important enough (despite front-page news all week). As @margbrennan said, “I want to have you back to talk about vaping one of these days.” 🙄Topics that were more pressing than the best solution to the #1 cause of preventable death included: - Tylenol - Ivermectin - Anti-depressants - FDA staff layoffs - Food safety - Makary replacement horserace

QME
0
1
4
146
Phillip Kirschberg
Phillip Kirschberg@RushmoreExt23·
"Due to time constraints", there was no discussion of vaping or tobacco harm reduction with @ScottGottliebMD on this morning's episode of @FaceTheNation. How very unfortunate.
Jim McCarthy@JMacNYC

😶‍🌫️Will @ScottGottliebMD stick up for vaping and tobacco harm reduction on @FaceTheNation tomorrow? With a bottle of Irish whiskey on the line, @jgitchell bets on yes and I've got no. (@RushmoreExt23, we are conscripting you as arbiter on the quotes if it's wishy-washy).

English
3
5
14
871
Jim McCarthy
Jim McCarthy@JMacNYC·
Aaand it's a push. Not important enough (despite front-page news all week). As @margbrennan said, “I want to have you back to talk about vaping one of these days.” 🙄Topics that were more pressing than the best solution to the #1 cause of preventable death included: - Tylenol - Ivermectin - Anti-depressants - FDA staff layoffs - Food safety - Makary replacement horserace
English
2
1
6
296
Phillip Kirschberg retweetledi
Jim McCarthy
Jim McCarthy@JMacNYC·
😶‍🌫️Will @ScottGottliebMD stick up for vaping and tobacco harm reduction on @FaceTheNation tomorrow? With a bottle of Irish whiskey on the line, @jgitchell bets on yes and I've got no. (@RushmoreExt23, we are conscripting you as arbiter on the quotes if it's wishy-washy).
Jim McCarthy tweet media
English
3
6
16
1.5K