
The scientific method is good for some things but it can't settle every disagreement. Many sources of disagreement are about what we should or shouldn't value. Science can't tell us that.
Then add on the complexity that scientists are human and have just as much bias as everyone else. Studies are corrupted by ideology ALL THE TIME. Most people don't have the resources to do original experiments to settle every question, so we end up having to decide whether to trust other biased people's claims about what science says.
The 1st amendment is primarily about freedom of belief and the sovereign right of the individual to decide truth for themselves. It removes gatekeepers and spreads power. Many people will misuse that power but the alternatives are all worse.
English























