Mukul Rana 已转推
Mukul Rana
13.6K posts


@Khushbooholic No electricity in my area due to heavy storms.
English

@scionofkalhans @grok Countering with a pre-determined mindset, especially after knowing you for a while, makes it pretty clear where this approach is coming from.
I won’t say anything harsh,but yeah, good luck with that.
English

@lyflesslessons @grok I didn't said anything without Proof
If like countering with source is a casteist mindset then it is good I think so .....
Leave it now rigid mindset cannot be flexible at any cost!!
End !!
English

@scionofkalhans @grok I will say there is no conclusive evidence of her caste, and I will not say anything more than that. Arguing with someone who has a casteist mindset is a total waste of time.
I wish I had not used this for you.
End of debate from my side.
English

@lyflesslessons @grok Then share me older book then this it was last published in 1888 AD where no commentary mentioned in main text but the actual text of writer and it is academically known she belonged to Rajput community...
Show me any counter historians opinion on this ?
English

@scionofkalhans @grok History rests on consistent primary evidence,not a single edited version.
This discussion isn’t going anywhere, so I’m ending it here....
English

@scionofkalhans @grok or expanded the text for clarity. Such additions can reflect interpretation or local tradition rather than the exact original phrasing.
So before treating that line as definitive proof, it’s important to distinguish between the original manuscript and later translated versions.
English

@scionofkalhans @grok There is no explicit mention of her caste as Rajput in the text.
Attaching caste labels without clear historical evidence only distorts the legacy of such figures. Let history speak through sources, not assumptions.
Source: chat gpt
English

@scionofkalhans @grok People keep claiming that Veer Vinod describes Panna Dai as a Rajput—but that’s simply not accurate.
In Veer Vinod, written by Shyamaldas, Panna Dai is referred to as a “dai” (nurse/foster mother) who showed extraordinary loyalty and sacrifice.
English

@scionofkalhans James Tod's claim is not authentic, and there are so many claims that I can't show you here, claiming that she was Gurjar, but I won't post those claims without knowing their authentication.
English

@lyflesslessons Panna Dhai was a Khichi Chauhan Rajput woman of the 16th century.
References: James Tod’s *Annals of Rajasthan* ("Rajpootnee of the Kheechee tribe"), Vir Vinod, Mewar records & Chittorgarh histories.
I think bhaii itna source kaafi h unki caste k liye ...




English

@Jaisal_Bagdana @scionofkalhans Where did I mention that caste does not exist in Indian society? Yes, man, it exists.
But putting a label on someone can create a rift between two communities. It will only increase the animosity among them.
English

@lyflesslessons @scionofkalhans in which country you are living?
a country where fr college admission to govt subsidies induction are based on caste;
point one field one discipline which is untouched by it.
English

@scionofkalhans And if a figure doesn’t fit into their narrative, they either get sidelined or dismissed as fictional.
History deserves better than this kind of selective ownership.
English

@scionofkalhans Nowhere in authentic historical records has Panna Dai been clearly identified as Gurjar or Rajput,that’s the real issue people ignore today.
Everyone tries to assign a caste label based on their own identity when a historical figure has made a great sacrifice.
English






