
US Constitution: Behind the Scenes: Paper-3⃣8⃣
Topic: Why the Convention's Work Deserves Trust
Key questions debated:
* Is a deliberative convention more trustworthy than a lone lawgiver?
* If critics cannot agree among themselves, how strong are their objections?
Madison contrasts the Constitutional Convention with the ancient lawgivers: Solon, Lycurgus, Romulus. Those men shaped entire legal systems alone, often through deception or violence. The Philadelphia Convention was a deliberative body of many minds. Critics now demand revisions but cannot agree among themselves on what to change. A roomful of objectors with conflicting alternatives carries less weight than a body that reached consensus through months of structured debate.
Read Here : avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/f…
✍️ Author: James Madison
📅 January 12, 1788, New York Packet, NY
#Federalist #PublicAdmin
English