Post

Eithan Haim MD
Eithan Haim MD@EithanDHaimMD·
To understand the severity of the risk posed to this agent, consider the differences between auto-vs-pedestrian (AvP) injuries and gunshot wounds (GSWs) from a trauma surgery perspective. Whenever a code 1 trauma comes in and its an AVP, I always know it's going to be a total disaster - would take GSW's any day of the week. And there is a reason for this. You can compare the two using a the Abbreviated Injury Scale (scaled between 1 to 6; 1 being minor, 6 is unsurvivable). At an average speed of 16mph, there is a 10% chance of having an AIS of 4+ (i.e. fatal or near fatal injury). This goes up to 25% at 25mph. To put this in perspective, the average GSW to the head or the torso has an average AIS of 4+. And then there is the fact that GSW's on average spend less time in the hospital than AVP's and a not insignificant number of GSW's can be discharged from the ER - one study found up to 70% (may be a little high but even in my own experience I discharged two GSW's from the ER over the last few weeks). This is all to say that AVP is serious business given the nature of the injury (big hunk of metal vs soft, squishy human).
Eithan Haim MD tweet mediaEithan Haim MD tweet media
Megan Basham@megbasham

After examining the Minneapolis ICE shooting video from multiple perspectives, it's evident that the officer's decision to use lethal force was legally sound and appropriate. Confronted by a driver who disregarded direct orders, aimed two-ton vehicle directly at him, and appeared determined to proceed, the officer responded with gunfire only following bodily impact from the car and as it pressed forward, firing into the windshield. You can debate whether the driver truly meant to weaponize the vehicle. But, in the heat of the instant, an officer is justified in interpreting defiance of stop commands as preparation to accelerate, swerve, and cause severe harm. It’s just like a driver ignoring directives to show their hands and instead grabbing a concealed firearm. You have to assume the person plans to fire it.

English
0
0
0
29K
Marginal Merit
Marginal Merit@MarginalMerit·
@EithanHaim Your two GSW discharges, were either of those wounds to the head?
English
0
0
0
18
Paylaş