What are your expectations for Andrew Painter in 2026?

@TheGoodPhight 4.30 ERA, looks good in spurts, has some rocky starts as any rookie will

@TheGoodPhight Better than Taijian Walker

@TheGoodPhight I expect them to rename the Cy Young after him.

@TheGoodPhight anything under a 4 ERA would be great

@TheGoodPhight 25 Starts, 125 INGs, 135Ks, 3.95 era. Why not?

@TheGoodPhight I’d be happy with 25 starts and an ERA under 4

@TheGoodPhight ERA between 5.50 & 7.00, sent down to AAA before the trade deadline to “figure it out” after we make an early trade & overpay for a pitcher we could have signed in the offseason

@TheGoodPhight Flashes of greatness, but some inconsistency. Depends if his arm slot is back to pre-surgery.

@TheGoodPhight 14/10

@TheGoodPhight Let’s get through the year with a sub 4.5 era and 5+ innings average per start

@TheGoodPhight Stay healthy young man. Personally, I'd like to see 26 starts, an ERA of 3.80 or under. It will be his first season at the majors, but why not finally see his potential. 2nd half better than the first half.

@TheGoodPhight Not to suck

@TheGoodPhight If he gives the Phils 20 to 25 starts with an ERA below 4 and over 100 K's, I'd consider that a strong contribution.

@TheGoodPhight 120 innings max, 8 wins, 110 k’s. Gonna see a lot of Taijuan in Painter outings.

@TheGoodPhight I need 12 wins MINIMUM to justify this wait

@TheGoodPhight To be a competent major league pitcher.

@TheGoodPhight 25 starts 375 era k per 9

@TheGoodPhight 320ip, 26-4, 360Ks, 2.16 ERA .328/.414/.605 49 Hrs, 130 RBIs, 58 SBs

@TheGoodPhight I have no expectations just stay healthy

@TheGoodPhight Basically Ranger Suarez.

@TheGoodPhight I don’t have any. He’ll probably be ok but not great. Who cares? This team is no different than the last two years.

@TheGoodPhight 9-6 3.95 ERA 140 innings 125 K’s 50 BB

@TheGoodPhight I expect him to struggle a bit early, and for this account and those who follow it to lose their fucking minds. He will improve throughout the season, and end his season with an ERA around 4.

@TheGoodPhight very low

@TheGoodPhight Being realistic is best option. Even Hamels has some serious ups and down in his rookie season. If he can pitch to below a 4.5 and stay healthy I consider it a win

@TheGoodPhight Truthfully if they get 130 innings out of him thats a win regardless. I think the biggest statistics for him are going to be K/9 or his whiff rate, if he can show hes healthy and still can miss bats, I trust their player development to turn him into an ace.

@TheGoodPhight Well I don’t think he’s gonna to step in and be the Ace we all expected before TJ.. probably gonna be rocky here n there.. era in the 4s.. but overall statistically, he should be a 4 or 5 SP this year. Hopefully he gets stronger after ASB

@TheGoodPhight Top 4 cy young convo. A few rocky starts in late summer throw him out of contention. Baller in the postseason.

@TheGoodPhight A serviceable 4

@TheGoodPhight 155 IP 3.8 ERA

@TheGoodPhight 140+ innings and sub 4.5 era. Want relatively low expectations

@TheGoodPhight Nothing with numbers Just health

@TheGoodPhight Hear me out… make him a long reliever. Innings 4-8 when in a pinch. Low risk, high reward.

@TheGoodPhight 26/27 starts, roughly 140 innings ish, 3.95 ERA (yes im sneaking it just under 4)

@TheGoodPhight I'd be happy if he could actually stay healthy this season.

@TheGoodPhight 8-9 wins. ERA mid to high 4's if lucky.