@eoncleen @SreseShiny @SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy Db fans are npcs😭
What does this have to do with what i asked? I asked what about these designs are particularly ugly. Specifically the gorosei, enel, Big mom, and kaido
GIF
English
Number 9
4.1K posts
English
Notice how DB fans never talk about writing.
Animelover@BhdAnkur
One Piece fans shouldn't be talking about Character Designs 😭
English
@mahito211520 The way his paneling has gotten better since wano
English
this dudes paneling has been so shit since wano
Borsalino D Corn🦅@CorneliusG14926
He writes bs like this instead
English
@UsernameTBD10 Its so confusing bcuz dbz has undeniably goofy character designs and one piece has plenty of cool ones
GIF
English
“Your design looks silly, mine doesn’t, so therefore it is better and yours is bad” isn’t a criticism
Animelover@BhdAnkur
One Piece fans shouldn't be talking about Character Designs 😭
English
@omenbluez @Unariel_ @Denjitaka Jirens design as far as db designs go is pretty meh but again thats not the point im making specifically, most toriyama villain designs are good, but most oda villain designs are also good. People just go out of their way to cherrypick the goofy ones and pretend thats it..
English
GIF
GIF
GIF
GIF
English
This your main guy man…
Animelover@BhdAnkur
One Piece fans got a above average design after years & forget how to act
English
@eoncleen @SreseShiny @SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy I meant the designs on display specifically. I too can also cherrypick goofy looking designs from dragon ball. Babidi is a literal nutsack
English
English
@SebastinPortals @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy But he didnt tho....
Cell is a mix of other tropes of scifi, horror, and timetravel.
His design is a bugman has existed befor (the fly)
English
@Number9ineeee @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy Nothing is 100% original, Cell isn't either. But there’s a difference between mixing human tropes (like Doffy) and creating a unique biological anomaly.
English
@SebastinPortals @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy Thats literally what writing is....
Nothing is 100 percent original and the same applies to db. Cell himself is combination of timetraveling cyborg(terminator) mixed with monster movie villain mixed with ultimate kars....
English
@Number9ineeee @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy Mixing tropes is just a remix, not a new concept. Doflamingo is a collection of human clichés mobster/noble.
Cell is a biological anomaly that breaks human archetypes. Combining old tropes doesn't make a design original, it just makes it a well dressed remix...
English
@SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy His human form is based off ghandi. And his hybrid form is not cluttered. You can clearly tell where the samura part and the centaurs parts start and end. Plus the skeleton centaur samurai is a unique blend of tropes. Nothing about this design is hard to register dawg...
English
@Number9ineeee @CJDLuffy His human form is a boring cliché, but his hybrid form is the definition of visual clutter. Skeletal horse legs, smoke, and a robe don't create a clean silhouette they create a mess.
English
@Num2MephilesFan @SebastinPortals @feivlol @CJDLuffy This guy seemingly doesn't cuz he keeps bringing up tropes like their existence in a character diminishes them...
English
@Number9ineeee @SebastinPortals @feivlol @CJDLuffy WE know that
the other guy doesnt and think everything oda writes is original
English
@SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy Manga being a visual medium doesn't mean u neglect character writing dawg. What are we talking about....
You're writing a story so those same rules apply. This is the standard applied to literally EVERY single manga.
GIF
English
@Number9ineeee @CJDLuffy You're treating Manga like a novel. In a visual medium, anatomy is really important. Cell’s motivations and dynamics are built into his biology (DNA)
If you need 20 chapters of dialogue to explain a character, your visual storytelling failed. Design is the foundation.
English
@SebastinPortals @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy Like dragon is tropy itself, it had a ton of tournament arcs which was common back then (kinnikumon/ring ni kakero).
Cell is straight up a moster movie villian. Ssj is literally a chosen one trope, etc...
These all work bcuz of how toriyama executed them. Same goes for oda
English
@Number9ineeee @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy You're missing the point. I didn't say any mobster, I said a cliché one.
The flamboyant, fallen noble turned criminal is a trope as old as literature Lucifer/Dracula.
Doffy's story is just 'Nature vs Nurture' Joker/Magneto.
English
@SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy Clutter how exactly. Hes only wearing a robe...
Aside from that. Old swordsman being a trope doesn't mean implementing it into his design is bad. All stories have tropes..
Lastly he has a very clean silhouette. Literally no other character looks like this.
English
@Number9ineeee @CJDLuffy Nusjuro's design feels a bit cluttered.
The Old Swordsman trope is very common in anime, and his skeletal horse form is just overdesigned clutter with no clean silhouette.
It lacks the clean, iconic look that makes a villain truly memorable. But this is my opinion....
English
@sonngoku22 @muginokaizoku Go show someone who aint hardcore db fans a pic of goku jr and i promise they are gonna say that nigga is goku....
GIF
English
Ain’t no way we are genuinely comparing One Piece character designs to fckn Dragon Ball!!😭
Animelover@BhdAnkur
One Piece fans shouldn't be talking about Character Designs 😭
English
GIF
English
@Number9ineeee @SebastinPortals @feivlol @CJDLuffy cell is more than a robot but if you just call him a robot i will be just as disingenuous
English
@SebastinPortals @CJDLuffy No design is design. Character writing is an entirely area of expertise. Motivation, dialog, character dynamics, all of this factor into writing. The design is just a part of a character, not the whole thing.
What you are essentially saying is Cell is good in concept
English
@Number9ineeee @CJDLuffy You're wrong. In elite storytelling, design is writing.
Cells body, DNA, and 'Perfect' goal are his narrative.
A character's nature and evolution are written into their anatomy. If you need 20 chapters of talking to explain a character, your visual storytelling is weak.
English
@SebastinPortals @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy Doffys char is that he was corrupted by treble, had he got raised by better people he would have turned out like law maybe. And the story reinforces this idea through char like shanks who has a similar situation to doffy. Theres more to his character than "mobster"
English
@SebastinPortals @feivlol @Num2MephilesFan @CJDLuffy I read the thread and it was the most 1 sided meat munching of toriyamas writing ive seen in a while. Doffy is morethan just a fallen elite turned mobster. Hes meant to represent the wgs control as a whole but also meant to show how you arent born evil. A big part of...
English
