FroGame

Hi @TeamYouTube My appeal was rejected in less than a day. I showed my full creation process: I design games, draw characters in Scratch, and do manual editing in Premiere. This is 100% original content. Please review my case again. Link: youtu.be/SpkRDtu9UEw?si…

You ignored my emails, ignored the evidence in my appeal, never answered my questions, and then sent me a survey asking me to rate the support. @TeamYouTube What exactly am I supposed to rate here? The lack of communication has been worse than the demonetization itself.

@chunlifanfic @TeamYouTube My content is manually created from scratch. You’re free to dislike it, but calling it “mindless” doesn’t magically make it inauthentic. Also, judging by your own profile, I don’t think you’re in a great position to decide what content adds value to YouTube.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube yes it's mindless content though. With low educational value, commentary or narrative

Hi @TeamYouTube You keep ignoring both me and the evidence I’ve provided. My appeal publicly shows the full manual creation process behind my content, yet all I receive are template responses. Please stop ignoring the evidence and review my case properly!

@chunlifanfic @TeamYouTube So now only educational content deserves monetization? Gaming channels, animators, storytellers, comedians and entertainers would probably be surprised to hear that.

@DaveLEllisLLC @TeamYouTube Many creators aren’t getting clear answers. We need transparency, specific feedback, and real communication instead of generic responses.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube They are ignoring all of us bc they are Unprofessional and Childish Liars that can't explain what's being done...

@Johanna476747 @TeamYouTube I’m sorry you’re dealing with this too. It seems many creators are providing evidence and detailed explanations but are only receiving generic responses or being ignored. I hope both of our cases receive a real human review.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube Amigo, me pasa lo mismo yo tambien les escribí y les envíe pruebas sobre mi canal y llevan más de 1 semana ignorandome

@ShaquanVir32740 @TeamYouTube The biggest issue is the lack of transparency. I showed my entire manual creation process, game design, animation, editing, and character creation, yet I still received generic responses and no clear explanation of what was supposedly wrong. Creators deserve real reviews.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube @TeamYouTube THIS A DECELERATION!!!! WE WILL MASS EXIT YOUTUBE AND YALL WILL BE FORCEED TO DEAL WITH THIS!!! SO CHOOSE, FIX THE ISSUE NOW OR LOSE FUCKING MONEY!!!! WE'LL GO TO PATREON SO KEEP TESTING US

@Tyvan_TV @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators I completely understand. I’m dealing with the same issue. My appeal showed my entire manual workflow, yet I was still labeled as “inauthentic content.” Honest creators deserve clear explanations and real human reviews, not generic responses.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube It’s now been 37 days. Please get a real human being to review this. Put my channel back, and help us understand how we can comply better so this nightmare does not happen to any honest creator again. I remain committed to the YouTube Community Guidelines. @YouTubeCreators

@MadeInHistYT @TeamYouTube Yes. The strange part is that I contacted support multiple times when my views suddenly dropped to almost zero. They told me my channel was compliant with YouTube policies. A few days later, I was demonetized anyway. That’s what makes this situation so difficult to understand.

When did they demonetize you? Because I'm betting they withheld previous month's revenue plus the current month you were demonetized. I was demonetized 3 days before payout so that's already 47 days plus the 90 day wait. Every level of what they've done is subhuman and they are just destroying everything with no consequences.

@chunlifanfic @TeamYouTube If you think they’re the same video, you clearly didn’t watch them. Different mechanics, different characters, different outcomes, different gameplay. Everything is created manually and my full workflow is publicly available.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube 3rd one describes your shorts

But every video is still created with different characters, stories, interactions, game mechanics, layouts, and outcomes. How can content created entirely through a manual creative process be classified as “inauthentic”?

Hi @TeamYouTube Support still hasn’t responded to my emails. The only replies I receive are generic template message. I was later told on X that my channel had undergone another manual review, but nobody ever received any update that my case was being sent for one.

My appeal is public and shows my full manual workflow. I create my own games, draw characters, animate, edit, and build every video myself. I also regularly ask my community what content they want to see next

What on earth is going on here, @TeamYouTube?! This is an absolute joke. You claimed that a "real human" reviewed my appeal video and rejected it for "Inauthentic Content," claiming it looks mass-produced or repetitive. But look at this! Your very own AI Assistant integrated inside YouTube Studio (Ask Studio) evaluated my exact appeal video and gave a completely opposite verdict! Your own system states that my appeal video is "EXCELLENT," transparent, and clearly proves our manual production pipeline (Scriptwriting, 3D Modeling, Texturing, On-location filming, and complex Rigging). It literally says our work is the "OPPOSITE of mass-produced content" and transforms our channel into a professional "VFX Studio". So who am I supposed to believe? Why does your integrated Studio AI recognize the hours of human labor, handcrafted 3D models, and real-world effort of my 15-person team, while your "human" reviewers just blindly hit the reject button without ? Does @TeamYouTube just personally hate my channel? Why give us AI tools that validate our hard work, only for your review team to completely ignore the evidence and ghost our emails? I need a REAL HUMAN with actual logical thinking from @TeamYouTube to look at this clear contradiction, reply to my Gmail messages, and give my channel a fair, manual re-review! #YouTube #FixYouTube #VFX #Animation @TeamYouTube

@TeamYouTube Nobody informed me that my channel was actually sent for another manual review until after you already rejected it. My full appeal is public, and my channel also contains videos showing the entire manual creation process behind my content. What exactly is being reviewed here?

We've already forwarded your channel for another review and it was confirmed that some content doesn't align with our monetization policies. More info here: goo.gle/4eY4fcI Right now, we recommend making some necessary changes to your content and then you can re-apply on the date shown in Studio. You can read through this article for more tips on how to make your application stronger: goo.gle/4ftX8J1

Hi @TeamYouTube You instantly replied that my channel “failed manual review,” even though nobody ever informed me my case was being sent for another review in the first place. There was no notice, no update - just another generic rejection while both email support and X

@VelvexVancreed @TeamYouTube Using AI tools as part of a workflow isn’t the same as uploading random prompts. I design games, draw characters, and build every video manually. AI is just one tool in the pipeline - not the creator. Low-effort stolen-face spam should be banned. Original creators shouldn’t.

@FroGame_YT @TeamYouTube ah yes. another AI channel uploader that uploads nothing but AI prompt videos not understanding that they don't get to be paid like a real artist by simply putting some words into a chat prompt and then uploading the result

Nobody ever confirmed my case was escalated for review, but suddenly I’m told a “manual review” happened. Meanwhile, my email case is being ignored.

Hi @TeamYouTube I was never told my channel was sent for another manual review. I only got another generic “mass-produced content” reply after showing my full manual workflow. I create games, draw, animate, and edit. Please review my case instead of sending template replies.

Now YouTube suddenly pushed my videos again and my recent uploads are getting millions of views. Yet support keeps sending copy-paste replies instead of addressing my actual case.

A few days before demonetization, support told me multiple times that my channel was fine and eligible for monetization. Then my views suddenly dropped to almost zero.