Dustin Siddoway

771 posts

Dustin Siddoway

Dustin Siddoway

@dtsidd

Trying to live intentionally "Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today." - James Dean

Taylor Lane Beigetreten Mayıs 2009
283 Folgt56 Follower
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich We could go back and forth all day about this. I have a lot of respect for the Catholic church and all the good they have done.
English
1
0
0
13
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich The real question is: where is the evidence that anyone after the apostles exercised the same prophetic authority as Peter, John, or Paul—not merely that they believed they inherited it?
English
1
0
0
15
Cernovich
Cernovich@Cernovich·
Every Mormon I know considers themself Christian. TBH I find these debates boring.
English
417
39
1.8K
168.4K
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich The Church Fathers may have been sincere and preserved much truth, but being disciples of the apostles is not the same thing as being apostles. The question is not whether they were good men, but whether Christ's authority and ongoing revelation remained with them
English
1
0
0
10
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich We wouldn't claim there was an immediate collapse the day the last apostle died. The LDS claim is that the apostles repeatedly warned of a coming apostasy and that after their deaths the Church no longer had the same apostolic authority and revelatory leadership.
English
1
0
0
11
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich Our church believes that though the authority was given to Peter, that the line of authority was lost after the original apostles were all killed. We believe that an apostacy took place and therefore a restoration of the church was needed - which came thru Joseph Smith.
English
1
0
0
15
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@BroMichael87 @UtahSandersTwo @Cernovich Muslims respect Jesus as a prophet but reject His divinity, atonement, and role as Savior. Latter-day Saints affirm all of those. So the better question is: Who gets to define Christianity—Jesus and the New Testament, or later creeds and theological traditions?
English
0
0
0
4
Michael
Michael@BroMichael87·
@dtsidd @UtahSandersTwo @Cernovich So is Biblically Historical Christianity and Mormonism the same or not? The belief of who God is vastly different between both religions. Logically the beliefs are incoherent. Muslims believe in Jesus too. Are they Christians as well?
English
2
0
0
11
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@BroMichael87 @UtahSandersTwo @Cernovich No, they're obviously not the same. Catholics, Orthodox, Protestants, and Latter-day Saints all differ significantly. The question isn't whether they're the same, but whether "Christian" requires complete doctrinal agreement or simply faith in and discipleship to Jesus Christ.
English
0
0
0
5
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@oberg_o83356 @Cernovich Saying "the Trinity is biblical" assumes the very point under debate. Why should those who worship Christ, accept His divinity, atonement, and resurrection be excluded from Christianity simply because they understand the Godhead differently?
English
0
0
0
3
Dapper-Otter
Dapper-Otter@oberg_o83356·
@dtsidd @Cernovich Well, I'm an Orthodox Christian, so I can see and understand how the doctrine of the Trinity displayed within the Scripture is sound and correct. Those who see otherwise are dangerously close to Gnosticism which is not Christian.
English
2
0
0
12
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@oberg_o83356 @Cernovich If the Trinity is so clearly taught in Scripture, why did Christians spend centuries debating and defining it? The issue isn't whether the doctrine is true, but whether agreement with a particular interpretation of God's nature is the test for being Christian.
English
0
0
0
3
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich You can argue Mormon theology is wrong, but "wrong about God's nature" and "not Christian" are different claims. What biblical passage says a follower of Christ ceases to be Christian for disagreeing with Nicene Trinitarianism?
English
1
0
0
19
NielL
NielL@NielL92840577·
@dtsidd @Cernovich I don't think any other denomination disagrees about the trinity - God's very essence - to the extent that Mormons do.
English
2
0
0
25
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich Christianity existed for centuries before the Nicene Creed. Where did Jesus or the apostles teach that agreement with a specific definition of the Trinity is required to be considered a Christian?
English
0
0
0
8
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@NielL92840577 @Cernovich My point is how does a different view on the trinity determine one's ability to claim Christendom? Where is the rule that you must agree with the Trinitarian view to be a follower of Christ?
English
1
0
0
23
NielL
NielL@NielL92840577·
@dtsidd @Cernovich This author is saying Mormons believe in a different God from Christianity
English
1
0
0
18
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@BroMichael87 @UtahSandersTwo @Cernovich But they are both stock. They are both tech. They are both American. You don’t have to be the same to share something in common. Both Mormons and Creedal Christians believe in Christ of the New Testament and are Christian.
English
1
0
0
11
Michael
Michael@BroMichael87·
@UtahSandersTwo @Cernovich If you had knowledge of Historically Bible believing Christian doctrine and LDS Church doctrine, you would realize that it is not logical and intellectually dishonest to say that they are both Christian. It's like saying that Apple stock and Google stock are the same.
English
1
0
1
80
Dustin Siddoway
Dustin Siddoway@dtsidd·
@rexturbinado67 @Cernovich What are you talking about? Mormons believe in the New Testament, that thru the grace of Christ we are saved and that Jesus was resurrected and lives and reigns. Muslims don’t believe any of that.
English
0
0
0
7
Beaux Regawd
Beaux Regawd@rexturbinado67·
@Cernovich Perhaps. But then Muslims are just as Christian as Mormons. Muslims’ view of Jesus is closer to Catholic/Orthodox/Protestant than Mormons’. Being nice and productive does not automatically make you Christian
English
2
0
2
235
Ace the black GoldenDoodle
Ace the black GoldenDoodle@GoldendoodleAce·
@Cernovich No debate needed. If you put your faith in the blood Jesus (God in human flesh) shed at the cross for the forgiveness of your sins then you are a Christian. If you believe Jesus is a created being and lucifer is his brother, you’re not a Christian.
English
1
0
0
114