
usablejam🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
4.5K posts









how do people actually believe in a literal resurrection without lobotomizing themselves? like the universe is causally closed and follows the laws of physics always except for that one time with very poor documentation and all the incentive in the world to fabricate?



The PROTECTOR of South India !! ✊️🔥




i assume at least some of the kneejerk insistence that machines can't be conscious is about fending off a line of reasoning people are afraid will lead to a nihilistic apocalypse that line of reasoning being something like: fully accepting the scientific materialist reductionist story about what a human being is - ultimately a very complex kind of machine made out of cells and stuff - seems to, for a lot of people, be a threat to human dignity. in terms of the person vs. thing distinction from below, it seems to be saying that people are secretly things and have secretly been things this whole time, which potentially undermines any moral claim we have to be treated differently from things. if people are just very complex biological machines, and we've been raised to believe we can do whatever we want to machines, then...? if this possibility feels unacceptable then you defend against it by believing, deep down inside, that in addition to all the cells and stuff there is some other non-physical essence, a soul or soul substitute, that makes a human being a human person and is responsible for endowing us with human dignity, moral patienthood, worth in the eyes of god, etc. (personally i actually agree! i just think the soul is software running on human hardware so i don't see this as an obstacle to machines having souls) insofar as something like this is part of what's going on, debate in the usual sense is going to be worse than useless because anything that seems like a plausible argument that machines could be conscious also seems like a plausible argument that humans are things, which gets treated as an attack on moral goodness and so has to be defended against even more harshly. truly unfortunate

































