Tweet Disematkan
Josh St. Marie
1.3K posts
Josh St. Marie
@UTStreamer
John 3:30 | Fan of Red Sox, Pats, Avs, Nuggets | Bruins, Celtics too | Not Rockies | NOT Broncos | Professional Data Analyst
Colorado Springs, CO Bergabung Temmuz 2017
525 Mengikuti619 Pengikut
Josh St. Marie me-retweet
the justin herbert vote is fine
josh allen getting 2 is a catastrophe
English
Josh St. Marie me-retweet
There’s at least the Herbert logic
What was the logic from the 2 Allen voters? It can’t just be the WRs because Maye’s WRs aren’t world beaters either
Didn’t win division, worse in stats, great OL and run game.
Genuinely how does one vote for Allen over Maye/Staff this year?
Sam Monson@SamMonsonNFL
I was the Justin Herbert vote. The guy had the worst offensive line in the NFL all season and despite that he was working miracles in almost every single game. Stafford's OL became 2/5ths as bad as Herbert's for 5 minutes and he became a turnover howitzer. He embodied 'value'.
English
Idk who needs to hear this (wait yes I do - Red Sox fans), but the real player the Red Sox traded Devers to make room for is locked up until 2034, had a 140 wRC+, and was a gold glove caliber fielder. His name is Roman Anthony and the revisionist history needs to stop.
English
@chrisfallica @Ivan_Maisel You got to lay to rest the ND hate. There is a very good chance the author himself canceled the event. Why would he want to go to an event on a campus that people believe he was part of a conspiracy against them? Let’s be reasonable here. The event couldn’t happen
English
Apparently incredible pettiness by the ND bookstore. “Please don’t come and promote a book about Notre Dame and an all-time great coach because you were on the committee and left us out.” CFB fans, go buy @Ivan_Maisel book because he’s a fantastic writer and even better human.
Gene Wojciechowski@Geno_Woj
Just called @HammesNotreDame bookstore to get info on @Ivan_Maisel appearance Friday for his terrific Frank Leahy book. They said event postponed “bc of series of events.” C’mon ND, you’re better than that. Don’t penalize an author (of an ND book) for being on CFP committee. 1/2
English
@AndyStaples A conspiracy is simply “a secret plan by a group to do something harmful.” Describes what the committee did to ND perfectly
English
I filed a column about this but I believe they’re holding until the morning.
Not a conspiracy. Just a bad idea. Which is why I don’t begrudge Notre Dame for saying “We’re not going to be your bowl ratings draw when you just made us your plot twist for your dumb TV show.”
Brandon Kochkodin@b_kochkodin
@AndyStaples Does creating drama for a TV soap opera fall into conspiracy territory?
English
@AndyStaples There very obviously was a conspiracy. There really is no denying that. What exactly motivated the conspiracy can be debated, but there’s no doubt the committee curated a fraudulent final ranking that defies any explanation.
English
Ha.
You think there’s a shadowy conspiracy to protect a league that already has an expiration date?
Stick to your YouTube rabbit holes.
Aintropy 🔰@Aintropy
@AndyStaples You are extremely naive. They made the change because they couldn't have the ACC go 0 for 17. If Virginia won, they wouldn't have flipped them.
English
@AmericaRus2024 @AriWasserman They should have been selected. They don’t have to prove that to anyone, and they definitely don’t need to prove it enough to pump up ESPNs ratings even more after they used and abused them all year
English
@UTStreamer @AriWasserman Pride. For the players. For the love of the game. To prove a point that they should have been selected. If they were in a conference, they would get money, but they don’t want that.
English
I understand why Notre Dame fans are pissed. The Committee mis-ranked them from the beginning — which is why I (and others) freaked out every week — and created a false hope that just was never necessary. The process is flawed in that regard. I'd be pissed, too.
But the destination is correct on3.com/news/the-colle…
English
@AmericaRus2024 @AriWasserman The most generous read of the committee is that they rigged the rankings all year for TV ratings. That’s the most generous possible explanation. Why would Notre Dame agree to continue to put money in ESPN’s pockets by playing in a meaningless bowl game?
English
@UTStreamer @AriWasserman Weak schedule, lost two big games, and not in a conference. Now they’re being crybabies and not playing a bowl game. Further highlights why they don’t deserve a playoff slot.
English
@UTStreamer Cry and I’m not even a Miami fan win against the best teams on your schedule
English
If you don’t recognize what the committee just did as corrupt and far worse than not honoring head to head, then you are not a serious person. If your initial reaction is that “Notre Dame should join a conference”, and not “the committee is corrupt”, you are not a serious person.
English
@dannykanell Very key to his and all Miami fans’ argument is that Miami and Notre Dame are identical metrically. In fact, Notre Dame has unanimous support from the metrics. As such, if you go with head to head over literally all, you might as well be claiming SMU should be ranked over Miami
English
The argument for Miami over Notre Dame is singular - Miami won the head to head.
Every single other relevant data point - every single one - favors ND.
If you rank Miami ahead of ND b/c of h2h, and only h2h, you also have to rank SMU and Louisville over Miami.
Which is dumb.
Kay Hard@KevTimHard
Well that’s weird, I sought out every ranking system I could find and Miami wasn’t ahead of ND in a single one…. 🧐 @bruce_straughan @J5_Sports1 @dougiesant @RiseNDraft
English
@AlexDonno The only common opponent Miami had a better game against is NC St.
It makes sense why people want h2h to matter above all else. But ND beats Miami in everything included in “all else”. If h2h is > 50% of consideration, then Miami should be ranked above. Otherwise, ND should be
English
These are the hoops the committee are willing to jump through in order to ignore head to head and common opponents.
Alex Donno@AlexDonno
"The way Notre Dame has been able to take care of business in first quarters and first halves, essentially covering spreads better than Miami has against lesser opponents, that's what's keeping Notre Dame ahead."
English
@JoshPateCFB Notre Dame’s resume is unequivocally better than Miami’s. You can’t find a single holistic metric or ratings system that says Miami is better. Its unanimous. That is unequivocal. It’s not the majority of. It’s not the vast majority of. It’s every single. It’s a blowout.
English
@MikeLupica If you take out the game, Notre Dame’s rank improves, Miami’s gets worse. The game counted.
English
If Miami's victory over Notre Dame isn't really supposed to count because the game was played over three months ago -- maybe the committee can tell me at what point in the season games do start to count.
English
@AriWasserman Agreed. The committee made up their mind. They aren’t saying so b/c they need to drum up max ratings for the show next week. It’s very obvious they won’t flip them when Yurachek is saying SOS could change and only Boise State plays from one of their schedules this weekend
English
There’s no trap door. They could have just made the just decision the last 4 weeks and chose not to. They don’t need to create some elaborate scheme to just do what they could have already been done.
Dan Wolken@DanWolken
Notre Dame’s weak résumé always deserved more scrutiny than it got from the College Football Playoff committee. Now it seems they’ve set a trap door for the Irish to fall out of the bracket and get replaced by Miami. My column for @YahooSports sports.yahoo.com/college-footba…
English
If two good teams played 100 times, the worse one still wins 40 games.
Miami is by every metric we know to be predictive the worse team. It is fair to say Miami, despite winning h2h, is still the worse team as the rest of the season indicates. Is Louisville better than Miami? No
English
Miami deserves to make the playoffs, and there are arguments for them to be ranked over Notre Dame. But there are rational arguments for Notre Dame to be ahead of Miami as well. Pretending Notre Dame doesn’t have a case against Miami is ridiculous. Head to head is not everything
English
Notre Dame rates higher than Miami in
- every relevant power rating system
- game control
- average win probability
and has outscored their opponents by 6 more points a game despite having the same strength of schedule and Notre Dame going to their backups more often.
English