AsiAndy
23 posts


The “ordinary but not simple” principle I’ve discussed in Protestant ethics applies to Reformed worship too.
In his new book, “Believe,” Douthat categorizes Protestantism generally (and Reformed Protestantism in particular) as a religious system fundamentally concerned with morality and ethics as opposed to spiritual experience or liturgy.
While that might be true of more liberal strains of American Protestantism, it’s a failure, ultimately, to appreciate what the Reformed believe is happening in worship.
Reformed worship is ordinary—there ain’t any “smells and bells” I suppose—but it’s not “simple.” Something profoundly spiritual is happening; something sublime; something that would be near ineffable if not for the holy words of Scripture.
Probably the best trend in my recent memory is Reformed Protestants committed to explaining the awesome things that happen when we worship and correcting the opinions of folks like Douthat.
English

@L_MMorales Interesting take. Why does Rendtorff think it's just the first two elements, which is sometimes expanded to include divine presence, but your take is that it's all three?
English

“Israel’s worship in the Mosaic period was virtually silent.” I’d never thought about this, or the impact of David’s musical innovations, until reading @PLeithart:

English

@PLeithart This is helpful. Thank you. Could you expand on 'we offer ourselves in praise and thanks'. Does this mean we are offering ourselves (in Christ's offering). And that the means of offering ourselves is through praise and thanks?
English

According to Protestant Eucharistic theology, the Eucharistic offering is a sacrifice of praise and thanks.
True. But that cannot mean that we sacrifice “outside” of Christ. We offer ourselves in praise and thanks as members of His body.
And if the church offers herself in Christ and by the Spirit, then the Eucharistic sacrifice of praise is a mode of Christ’s own self-offering.
English

@FredFredSanders Also, perhaps related to Vanhoozer's Big Orange Pumpkin? The verbal equivalent of the dramaturge needing to interpret and improvise the gospel in a context
English

@FredFredSanders Developing such a reading the gospel entails, of course, the development (or annexation) of conceptual vocabularies and forms of argument whose range and sophistication may seem distant from the more immediate, urgent idioms of Scripture.
John Webster. Holiness
English

@FredFredSanders (The gospel is the norm of Christian praise)...dogmatics seeks simply to produce a set of flexible accounts of the essential content of the gospel as it is found in Holy Scripture, with the aim of informing, guiding and correcting the Church's reading.
John Webster. Holiness
English

@FredFredSanders Agree or disagree? AI is heavily weighted towards truth a coherence with minimal abilities to root that in truth as correspondence.
English

@merelyjwright @NeilShenvi @TGC Did you even read the article? It explicitly speaks against splitting the middled
English


My article on third-wayism at @TGC:
If someone asks, "Will I have to surrender my political affiliation if I become a Christian?" our answer should be, "Ah, it’s worse than you think! You’ll have to surrender everything if you become a Christian."
thegospelcoalition.org/article/funera…
English

@williamwolfe @MikeCosper Why do your respond like a college sophomore?
English

Gee whiz, if only anyone had seen this coming...
GIF
Megan Basham@megbasham
This needs to be ended. Now. No one who voted for this administration wants this.
English

When we have a week like the week we've just had - inevitably - @jt_english or I - will send this video to the other.
And it always (always) encourages us.
Maybe it will encourage you too?
English

@DZRishmawy Chapter 1 - the Law and the Law of Love is what the Spirit used to convict me of sin and need of Jesus, when I thought I was a 'good person.' So thankful for that book and that chapter, especially
English

Book actually changed the trajectory of my life.
Kevin Vanhoozer@VanhoozerKevin
Just realized that this year marks the 20th anniversary of the Great Pumpkin!
English

@PLeithart Interesting, but I don't the preposition 'with' is used, is it? Isn't it just "land flowing milk and honey"? I get the idea that it's oozing out its so fruitful. If it was just milk, the point would be stronger
English

@momof8japan @samueld_james Or, if that is too harsh for you, do Takin' Cara Babies. Same ideas but slightly gentler, but still definitely training. It is not gentle parenting nonsense. There is much wisdom in helping your little one learn to sleep. After 8 crazy months, we have had 4 years of good sleep
English

@samueld_james Solve your child, sleep problems by Dr. Richard Ferber.
English

@daneortlund Work is an externalization of being made in the image of God
English

Penn State needs to:
1. Run more north-south
2. Figure out how to deal with the blitz
3. Cover Boise State's Tight End
4. And keep shutting down Jeanty
#PennState #BoiseState #FiestaBowl
English

Add some wisdom to your library with this brand-new Numbers Commentary from Michael Morales. @gptseminary #gptsblackfriday kingsumo.com/g/m55zy8m/blac…
English





