Brett The Revelator ۞ 🌌@Brettlds
Some additional nuance to consider. I think Matthew did a great job laying this out - if our personal revelation contradicts scripture it is evidence that it might not be from God.
However, without a little more nuance, this may seem to be essentially the same footing the Protestants argue against the restoration: “You can ignore your personal revelation because it contradicts with our interpretation of the scriptures.”
I agree with him and Elder Renlund that we should study it out in the scriptures as well as seek a confirmation from the Spirit, but we also need to be open to the fact that our understanding of the scriptures might not be correct and that true personal revelation can shed light on our incorrect interpretations (not saying this situations is one of those).
We also need to be reasonably suspicious of even our church leaders - they are equally subject to deception - we know of many such examples where leaders have led people astray.
So what should we do if we find ourselves in this kind of situation where we feel we are receiving revelation from God that seems to contradict our understanding of the scriptures?
Perhaps an easier answer to this predicament is available: Double-down on personal revelation and priesthood power by asking a priesthood holder to come and give you a blessing and don’t tell them the reason. If their personal revelation contradicts your personal revelation, then perhaps it’s time to re-evaluate how in-tune with the spirit you have been. Now you have two witnesses against you: The scriptures, and a priesthood blessing.
The hard truth is that we are all susceptible to deception, and this becomes especially true as we become more in tune with the spiritual realm.
That being said, we can’t sacrifice belief either because of the possibility of deception. But also we can’t take for granted that our spiritual confirmations are 100% correct either - which is I think the point of Matthew’s post, and I agree with that for sure.
It’s not an easy situation to wade through. But the only way to the other side in my opinion is to have a little reasonable skepticism of personal impressions and don’t follow them into extreme conditions such as out of the church and covenants, but try to follow them whenever you can especially when the risk of spiritual harm is not too great. By following those promptings wherever they lead, you will start to become more aware of the promptings that lead you astray, and you will become more familiar with which promptings are true and learn to recognize the voice of the Lord that leads you. This is why it is so important to take the Holy Spirit for our guide and ensure our lamps are full and we are in-tune with the Holy Ghost, and have the true spiritual gift of discernment through our experience with the good and evil influences that can lead us.
Maybe the last caution would be to be very careful also of assuming we know the validity of someone else’s personal revelation. I have been guilty of this in the past. We don’t have stewardship over their personal revelation, and it’s never good to condemn or mock their spiritual experiences no matter how obvious you might think the answer is (Not saying Matthew is doing that).
Thanks for bringing light to this subject!