Celluloid Echoes

The final number in Gold Diggers of 1933, Remember My Forgotten Man, completely took me by surprise. After a film filled with humour, romance, and dazzling choreography, it suddenly shifts into something much darker and more haunting. What makes it so powerful is how directly it speaks to the realities of the Great Depression, but somehow the message still feels uncomfortably relevant today. It’s not just a finale; it’s a quiet but devastating act of remembrance: #HollywoodMusical

@SteveSm41425283 I always concentrate on his effortless dancing, but yes, he could sing, too 🙂

@CelluloidEchoes I love Fred's singing voice. He was real self conscious about it but it seems to perfectly match the songs he sings.

After the raw, haunting "Remember My Forgotten Man", let's float into something lighter and more romantic. Fred Astaire & Ginger Rogers in their breakthrough film The Gay Divorcee (1934) - dancing to Cole Porter's "Night and Day". The chemistry, the grace, the way they make it look like they're barely touching the floor... In a world of quick cuts and CGI, watching real bodies move like this still feels magical in 2026. Don't you think? #HollywoodMusical

@cmntcakefirst Your "riddle in motion" image captures it perfectly. Astaire made incredibly complex choreography look every movement spontaneous. And the fact that the editing never chopped it up meant you could actually appreciate how Ginger matched him step for step.

@CelluloidEchoes Watching Astaire navigate a set is like watching someone solve a riddle in motion. Pure kinetic intelligence. Editing served the movement, not the other way around.

@maus_ignatz Absolutely! What I love is how it starts light and then ends on such a powerful note.

@CelluloidEchoes I forgot to say so, but Gold Diggers of 1933 absolutely rocks. One of the best of the pre-code films.

The final number in Gold Diggers of 1933, Remember My Forgotten Man, completely took me by surprise. After a film filled with humour, romance, and dazzling choreography, it suddenly shifts into something much darker and more haunting. What makes it so powerful is how directly it speaks to the realities of the Great Depression, but somehow the message still feels uncomfortably relevant today. It’s not just a finale; it’s a quiet but devastating act of remembrance: #HollywoodMusical

@jerrythom11 That's true. I also posted a video of the song "We're in the Money". Another great spectacular choreography.

@CelluloidEchoes Great movie. Never tire of seeing it but I like the weirdness of the pattern and choreography. It starts out cynical right? I mean a really fine cynicism because...they aren't really in the money.

@CultrHack Thank you, I am always looking for books like that.

For an extended discussion of this brilliant scene's meanings, production history, and the initial resistance at Warner Brothers against it, check out my book "Who's In The Money: The Great Depression Musicals and Hollywood's New Deal." Joan Blondell is so heroic here.

@DingBell5 And it's still very moving, isn't it?

@CelluloidEchoes Great call. I was moved by that when I saw it for the first time on late night TV with my dad about 50 years ago. I was 13.

@RebeccaGalenti3 She was a great performer coming from vaudeville.

@CelluloidEchoes Love Joan Blondell

@richneumeister So true. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

@CelluloidEchoes Thanks for the like. Film is so intertwined with the history of the time whether in 1933 or 1972. Songs, quick scenes, references and so on that are in films made show a snapshot of us at that time.

I can still feel its relevance, my country suffered a lot in both World Wars. Let this serve as a reminder that tragic events like World War I, World War II, the Vietnam War or any other devastating wars should never happen again; and that those still ongoing must come to an end. 🙏

It hits harder in '33 because many/most adults were vets of The Great War and were starving during the Depression. It would lack the same gut punch today because no generation around today (other than the brave who served in Viet Nam) made the same level of sacrifice.

@maus_ignatz I agree.

@CelluloidEchoes We once again live in a time of forgotten men. Actually, forgotten masculinity. This is more devastating that the Great Depression.

@SyrinxMyth Especially, early musicals were produced to cheer up audiences and comfort them during those hard times. This number must have been poignant to most people.

One of my favorite musical numbers of all time. I remember the first time I saw it, and just thinking about how HARD it must have hit the audiences watching it in 1933 if it was striking *me* like this.

Singin' in the Rain is not just a dazzling musical, it's one of the funniest films about Hollywood ever. The hilarious preview of "The Dueling Cavalier": #SinginInTheRain #HollywoodMusical

🎉🎉Happy Anniversary🎉🎉 to one of the greatest films ever made - Singin' in the Rain, premiered #OTD at Radio City Music Hall in 1952. Besides the beautifully staged dance numbers, my favourites are the scenes poking fun at the chaotic birth of talkies. Poor director, Roscoe is trying to coach the glamorous (but clueless) Lina Lamont on where the hidden microphone is during filming of "The Dueling Cavalier". Absolute comedy gold:

@akroncrackrono1 She’s 84 years old.

@CelluloidEchoes Yea her voice in '26 is gone

#OTD a star was born on Broadway! March 26, 1964: Funny Girl opened at the Winter Garden Theatre, with a young Barbra Streisand lighting up the stage as Fanny Brice. Her voice, her comedy, her unstoppable talent - the audience knew they were witnessing something legendary. December 25, 1965: her emotional final performance, where she brought the house down with “My Man”… pure magic. The greatest star? Absolutely.

@steve_saklad That’s true. She performed the number, as her farewell from the show and as a tribute to Fanny Brice.

@CelluloidEchoes My Man was not a song in the Broadway production of Funny Girl. The show’s composer Jule Styne refused to allow it in the score. It was later added to the film soundtrack.

@flinthaven I could also see her in concert. Twice. I cherish both of them as great moments of my life. Also dream came true 😉

@CelluloidEchoes Wish I could have been there. Seeing her in concert was a dream come true.

@oldmovieactress The most beautiful to have ever walked this Earth. Nobody ever matched her and nobody ever will! 🤩

Wasn't Elizabeth Taylor beautiful? ❤️