Sabitlenmiş Tweet
DogNinja’s Review of Pompeii // Utility by Earl Sweatshirts & MIKE:
Overview: When news of this collaborative tape first broke, as a longtime fan of both artists, I was beyond excited for the release. Earl Sweatshirt and MIKE have been two of the most consistent and reliable rappers in the current underground hip-hop scene, consistently delivering high-quality, introspective work that stands out from the pack.
My only initial hesitation came from learning the project would be fully produced by Surfgang. While MIKE has experimented with trap-inspired production in the past, Earl has rarely ventured into that sonic territory. However, once the singles Earth and Leadbelly dropped, my concerns eased. Earl adapted impressively well to the trap-leaning beats, proving he could thrive in this new environment.
That said, this project functions more like a double album than a traditional collaboration, there are only two tracks where both Mike and Earl appear together. The two halves, Pompeii and Utility, have a strong connective tissue and feel best experienced as a complete package rather than separate releases.
Sonics & Performances: The albums complement each other with a clear yin-and-yang dynamic. Pompeii is upbeat, triumphant, and often warm, while *Utility* is cold, melancholy, and more cerebral. MIKE’s performances on Pompeii are self-aware, braggadocious, and playfully confident, whereas Earl’s verses across both albums remain low-profile, anxious, and densely packed with intricate wordplay. Niontey and Nak have great features on Pompeii as well.
The real stars of the project are the Surfgang producers. There isn’t a single weak beat across the entire release. Even with two distinct albums, they achieve impressive sonic diversity while maintaining strong cohesion within each tracklist.
Critiques: My two main issues are relatively minor. First, a few songs feel underdeveloped and lack enough substance to reach their full potential. Tracks like Tampering on Pompeii and this2shallpass on Utility are still enjoyable, but they could have used more layers, additional verses, or production shifts, to feel like truly complete, standout songs.
Second, there could have been more variation in delivery and energy throughout. On some tracks, both artists settle into a comfortable flow that works but doesn’t push the ceiling. With slightly more dynamic performances or emotional range, those songs would have hit even harder.
Final Thoughts: Overall, this is a strong and ambitious project that successfully blends two distinct artistic voices over consistently excellent production. While it’s not flawless, the highs are very high, and the creative risks mostly pay off.
Rating: 7.5-8
Favorite songs: My Worst (rebuke), Not 4TW, The pope, Afro, Minty, F.E.A.R., Shutterisland, Back LA, Kirkland, #Free #Mike, Man of the month, :( again :), react, rectangle lens, Leadbelly, Quikk, Ew!, Earth, Chali 2na, Sisyphus, Tour de France, Chicago, AOK, Book of Eli
English
