O retweetledi
O
74K posts

O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi
O retweetledi

So what was the alternative? No deal? Pre-JCPOA, Iran faced massive secondary sanctions but was only 2-3 months from enough enriched uranium for a bomb. The JCPOA made them get rid of a lot of their enriched uranium and put them back to 3.67%, and there were a LOT of other limitations. The JCPOA lifted only the nuclear-related secondary sanctions but yes, also freed up some frozen assets + oil revenue.
Trump ripped it up and imposed massive sanctions back, but look where we're at now. That obviously didn't work because Iran's economy tanked, but they still hit 60% enrichment with breakout now in days/weeks. The regime always prioritizes proxies over its people. Terrorists will always find a way. So you say it's a bad deal, but I don't get how you think ripping up the deal was a better option.
English
O retweetledi

Zarif is nobody now ! IRGC replaced him effectively once Americans killed JCPOA
Fereshteh Sadeghi فرشته صادقی 🟩 ☫ 🟥@fresh_sadegh
Zarif is in no position to offer a proposal. In a message he’d sent to a private group just before the war, he’s said he offered to form a group of former politicians including ex-Turkish FM to prevent the war. But the foreign ministry didn’t pay attention to him or his proposal.
English
O retweetledi

@McFaul The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) data is the gold standard on this. Before the US withdrawal from the JCPOA the IAEA was on the ground with full access to Iran's uranium stockpile. The record is very clear.

English
O retweetledi

@ABC Fourth strike on a nuclear power plant. A security guard is dead. JCPOA had inspectors on the ground and Iran at 3.67% enrichment. Trump tore it up. Now we're bombing nuclear facilities, Iran is at 60% enrichment, and a pilot is missing behind enemy lines. This is the plan?
English
O retweetledi

2015 #JCPOA deal negotiated by major powers with Iran & endorsed by UN Security Council significantly limited its nuclear capacity. The deal was abandoned by 1st Trump administration: cfr.org/backgrounders/…
English
O retweetledi

I assume that a new deal could have been negotiated at the end of the JCPOA. That happened often in other treaties. (And effective treaties do not rely on trust; they rely on effective verification.). We negotiated New START with Russia in 2010, with a regime much richer and stronger than the USSR, which signed START I in 1991. But that was an assumption, not a certainty. I'm not the expert on Iran; you are. Post JCPOA with no limits would have been a disaster; on this, we agree. And now I'm leaving this debate for the historians. Really not that relevant for our current situation. (PS , you did not show me the graph for 2015, but made a new argument. But Im moving on)
English
O retweetledi
O retweetledi














