
GeoPolitical Astronomer.
5.3K posts

GeoPolitical Astronomer.
@GeoPolAstro
Temporary lurking account. Astronomer. 🇺🇲🇬🇧🇳🇱 Bhatatiya. 🇮🇳







Read this. Then pause and read again.



It goes from bad to worse Seriously @VishnuNDTV seriously? The MK1A will be second only to the Rafale in IAF service in terms of advancements If this is the logic why not apply it to the Rafale that the IAF is looking to induct well Into the 2040s now? 5th gen will not be the mainstay for any large airforce ALL airforces larger than the IAF are investing in massive 4.5+ gen fleets USAF expanded F15EX commitments to ~300 units in recent months PLAAF has a massive and growing fleet of J10 and J11s RuAF with SU30s But only in India are indigenous fighters obsolete Why? Because they are an impediment to decades more import dependency? They’ll soon shift this logic to AMCA- in fact many already are Obsolete saaar 6th gen foreign project saaaar Come on @ShivAroor I thought you were better than this, you’re meant to be an indigenous champion








🇵🇰🇮🇳 PAF “J-35AE” VS IAF “SU-57E” In future if India went ahead with SU-57E Can they even put a fight against Pakistan J-35AE??



- no LCA MK1A till F404 supply stabilizes - no LCA MK-2 & AMCA before F414 deal - no Super Sukhoi before 2030 - MIG-29 & Mirage getting obsolete - Jaguars expected to go by 2030-32 What are you left with? Rafale.



We must look at this from another angle. When @VishnuNDTV says that Tejas Mk1A/Mk2 could be “obsolete on arrival,” a few important questions naturally arise: What timeframe is he referring to? Against which specific technologies or threats is this assessment being made? Does he hold a similar view about Rafale F4 and other contemporary 4.5-generation fighters? Is this assessment based on inputs from the IAF, simulations, operational analysis, or war-gaming outcomes? We should keep the discussion respectful and focus on asking meaningful questions. That is how a healthy debate develops, where different perspectives are examined, assumptions are challenged, and everyone learns something new.




Mk2 is obsolete and Rafale is not? What kind of logic is this?








