Hugh

25.2K posts

Hugh banner
Hugh

Hugh

@HMBrough_

🩺 Physician (IM) | Liberal | Diasporan | West Coaster by Provenance | Commentary on 🇺🇸 , 🌐 | Now on my 中文 (🇹🇼) Learning Arc |

Pacific Coast Katılım Eylül 2020
2.8K Takip Edilen5.5K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Hugh
Hugh@HMBrough_·
Ok, everyone seems to be missing the point, so I'll give it to you. First, my personal info: I am 2nd-gen Indo-American physician who went to my State U for undergrad, a mid-tier private school for med school, and a community hospital for residency. I have a relative in India who committed suicide after "grind culture" didn't go his way. I personally didn't do that much rat-racing, but I wouldn't say I'm a slacker either. --- Grind culture is not a Korean thing, or even an Asian thing. It is a cultural adaptation that develops when a society grants disproportionate economic returns to exam performance. This is common in recently developed countries, because there's just a few institutions that grant a ticket to the good life for people that don't have much social capital. Recent immigrants often continue this culture, partially out of mental inertia, partially out of lacking social capital in a new country (so they cannot advance through connections). By the 2nd and 3rd generations, their kids are more into fantasy football and Netflix binging. What did you think assimilation meant? Vibes? Papers? Essays? Both sides of this debate make a mistake in attributing grind culture to racial essentialism (one side to extol Asian overperformance, the other to trash Asian immigrants and argue implicitly for a kind of Bumiputra or BEE system for Whites). My hypothesis (cultural adaptation and inertia) is simpler, and you can prove it by looking at an instance where American Whites formed grind culture in real time: medical school. --- The Asians were always around in med school, In fact, there was apparently a higher % of Asian men in mid-1990s med school classes compared to today (2nd image, N Engl J Med 2021;384:1661-1668)! So we cannot blame this trend on Asians. And yet, people started grinding for exams more and more over the 1990s-2000s. Just look at how much bigger the prep books for the first licensing exam got (3rd image)! So why did this happen? Because the financial and lifestyle return to exam performance increased dramatically over the three decades (4th Image, Income Gap Across Physicians - Health Economics - iResearchNet). --- Grind culture develops as a response to economic incentives. It's not a racial thing, and anecdotally, the most vicious grinders I knew in med school were WASPs. If you want to change the culture, you need to change the incentives. This turns out to be a very difficult thing to do.
Hugh tweet mediaHugh tweet mediaHugh tweet mediaHugh tweet media
English
27
61
364
43.5K
Hugh retweetledi
Walter Russell Mead
I’m seeing a lot of comment on this site and elsewhere about Hudson Institute’s recent conference on the RSS. From the US side, people attacked the conference as Hudson “legitimizing” the controversial organization and either capitulating to or enabling the RSS. In India, some attacked speakers at the conference for “capitulating” to the United States and the Trump administration. I have thoughts:
English
25
69
313
69K
Hugh
Hugh@HMBrough_·
The issue is that if you want to change the culture (and the wokes do), you have to go through existing franchises, because that’s all anyone consumes these days. Eg you can complain about the wokes ruining D&D, but nobody is going to play Glorantha.
Isaac Young@HariSel57511397

The interesting thing about woke culture is that’s it’s constantly stuck in the hand-off phase. Psychologically, this is akin to young writers breaking into their skills with fanfic, written or otherwise fantasied in their heads. You’ve yet to really come into your own, and you’re playing in the older generation’s sandbox to figure out how everything works. Usually this terminates around high school or college, and the talented writers then make their own original IPs. You’re not supposed to stay in the sandbox. You’re supposed to explore and grapple with the world in your art, and this is where creativity emerges. But Progressives are constantly trying to reboot everything. They refuse to leave the sandbox, and while you can say this is due to financial reasons, as a cultural experience, it’s like watching artists trying to imbibe the creative fire of past generations and failing each time. Yes, you updated the franchise with your more Progressive fanfic characters, and yes you turned the older cast into skinsuit sycophants, but each time it never sticks. Not a single woke reboot successfully passed down the torch to where we could move onto a new cultural vogue. The new discourse never takes shape. It’s like the opposite of the refusal of the call in the Hero’s Journey. A world of origin stories that terminate at the origin and go nowhere. Progressives desperately want the fire of the past—and the status it derives—but the Muses aren’t choosing them.

English
1
0
2
113
Hugh retweetledi
eburke
eburke@JamesWHankins1·
Yes - what's unusual today is that classical education is a non-elite, even anti-elite phenomenon. I believe it's the first time in the 2400-year history of classical education, going back to Isocrates. In the long run there may be a danger that the movement will be co-opted by elites and ruined.
Il Cortegiano@il__Cortegiano

@JamesWHankins1 Elite valence goes a long way with liberals; if classical education can gain the elite-intellectual high-ground they will bend the knee

English
6
7
108
6.8K
Hugh retweetledi
T. Greer
T. Greer@Scholars_Stage·
Recently turned down an invitation to attend a conference. If you are organizing conferences in Washington you must realize a few things:
English
4
17
257
100.4K
Hugh retweetledi
Milan Busk
Milan Busk@KarolusWangus·
In the golden age of the early 200s, the ony way you could be exposed to the toxic waste pit that is an Istanbul cab driver's opinions is to make the mistake of buying a ticket, boarding a plane to Istanbul, and hailing a cab. Now they just ambush you with this shit.
Furkan Gözükara@FurkanGozukara

Prominent journalist Cenk Uygur drops a massive bombshell about Ghislaine Maxwell's father. He reveals Robert Maxwell was a Mossad agent who stole America's nuclear secrets and then bought US textbook companies to brainwash children. The Zionist lobby hijacked our education.

English
4
17
333
9K
Hugh retweetledi
Dan Walden
Dan Walden@dwaldenwrites·
The transformation of “autodidact” from “person without a college degree who reads widely and talks with other people” into “person who watches hours of YouTube essays and talks about conspiracy theories on Discord” is among the great intellectual tragedies of our era.
scribe@nishanciefendi

the people that post this kind of comment are inevitably dependent on academic research and pass off what they lift from books and articles as their own “research”

English
5
399
3.3K
70.5K
Hugh retweetledi
Steven Brown
Steven Brown@AttyStevenBrown·
I think a vast majority of the responses to @SpeakSamuel show a lot. They show how much hatred people have for someone doing things the right way. They show a complete lack of understanding of our immigration law (especially AC21 and backlogs). And worst, they show a lack of human empathy for someone who is struggling predominately because of flaws of the Administrative State.
Sam Peak@SpeakSamuel

This H-1B worker has lived in the US for nearly 20 years and built a family here. His mom was dying in India. To visit her, he would need to wait months to book a consular appointment--with the soonest one available likely being scheduled one year out. He made the difficult choice of not visiting his dying mom because leaving without an appointment would mean separation from his children, job, and his other obligations. Much of the commentary around immigration focuses on how such bureaucratic burdens undermine immigrants’ ability to contribute and innovate. But we must remember that this red tape also prevents these people from being fully engaged with their own lives and meaningfully present in the lives of others. This matters too, and these seemingly non-economic problems will eventually translate into economic costs. If America is no longer a place where people feel empowered to be the best versions of themselves as they celebrate, struggle, and grieve, it ceases not just being the land of opportunity, but also the land of dignity and purpose. linkedin.com/posts/gautam-d…

English
200
87
738
68.3K
Hugh retweetledi
Mark R. Yzaguirre
Mark R. Yzaguirre@markyzaguirre·
Siri: Why are voters not overwhelmingly supporting the political left, even when they say they disapprove of Trump and the GOP?
Benny Shaevsky@brshaevsky

@UMich Professor Derek Peterson shoutouts terrorist sympathizers during this morning’s commencement. Unbelievable.

English
0
2
10
767
Hugh retweetledi
Kat🇻🇪🇦🇷🇺🇦🇸🇾🇬🇪🇵🇸🇨🇺🇲🇲🇮🇷🇸🇩🇹🇼
Bro Syria was literally Hyrule after beating Ganondorf, as soon as he was defeated the entire country got green again, rivers flowed again, animals started singing lmao
Conflict@ConflictTR

🔴 Suriye'de son bir yıldaki bitki örtüsü yoğunluğundaki fark görüntülendi. ▪2026 yılında Suriye'deki yeşil ve tarımsal alanlar, 2025 yılına kıyasla %173 oranında iyileşme gösterdi.

English
55
620
9K
374.3K
Hugh retweetledi
internet hall of fame
internet hall of fame@InternetH0F·
26 years ago today in 2000, LimeWire was launched allowing for peer-to-peer file sharing
internet hall of fame tweet mediainternet hall of fame tweet media
English
122
292
2.3K
645.6K
Hugh retweetledi
Hugh
Hugh@HMBrough_·
They’re doing trap-bar deadlifts from the rack, not conventional deadlifts from the floor. A toddler can do a trapbar from the rack and never get hurt.
Alex Imas@alexolegimas

I'm sorry for the pause but regularly scheduled programming, but notice what exercise these grannies are doing at 89/91? Yup, the deadlift. The fitness industry is full of snake oil, but one of the biggest deceptions is discouraging the basic compound movements of deadlift and squat. The number of times I've heard the deadlift isn't worth the risk/reward, how it's going to mess up your back etc. No, the deadlift is what makes your back strong as you age. The biggest change to your body is that you start losing muscle mass, your bones have less and less support, including your spine. The deadlift puts an iron rod of muscle around your spine. I've had aches and pains around my back for more than a decade---regular weekly deadlift and squat fixed all of it. I haven't had so much as a tweak since I started lifting heavy. Here is me at 41, lifting 375 at 165lbs. We saw Christopher Waller lift the same at 67. This is what will help you age comfortably, not some random new fitness trend. With all that, you need good form. Get a trainer, practice light over and over again, and only when it's comfortable should you start loading it up. Everyone's *good form* will look a bit different, e.g., my back looks rounder than some others', but this what is more comfortable than a straight back for me. Once you have that down, you'll have the best anti aging hack out there.

English
1
0
12
1.7K
Hugh retweetledi
Sam Peak
Sam Peak@SpeakSamuel·
This H-1B worker has lived in the US for nearly 20 years and built a family here. His mom was dying in India. To visit her, he would need to wait months to book a consular appointment--with the soonest one available likely being scheduled one year out. He made the difficult choice of not visiting his dying mom because leaving without an appointment would mean separation from his children, job, and his other obligations. Much of the commentary around immigration focuses on how such bureaucratic burdens undermine immigrants’ ability to contribute and innovate. But we must remember that this red tape also prevents these people from being fully engaged with their own lives and meaningfully present in the lives of others. This matters too, and these seemingly non-economic problems will eventually translate into economic costs. If America is no longer a place where people feel empowered to be the best versions of themselves as they celebrate, struggle, and grieve, it ceases not just being the land of opportunity, but also the land of dignity and purpose. linkedin.com/posts/gautam-d…
Sam Peak tweet media
English
2.3K
831
5K
2.1M
Hugh retweetledi
One Proud Bavarian
One Proud Bavarian@ProudBavaria·
Hungary had this incredibly charming show about their history/myths in the 1980s called Mondák A Magyar Tőrténelemből (Hungarian Folk Tales). I wish we all did more of this style of "edutainment" for kids! Below an excerpt showing the ERE and HRE vying for influence in Hungary.
English
20
139
1.5K
67.8K