@YeonpilPencil Thanks for correcting me. See, she’s a main vocal. Why are fans asking why she’s getting a lot of lines
English
HappyRogue
525 posts
@YeonpilPencil I did not mean “you” you btw… sorry for the confusion. Winter is the lead vocalist… she’s supposed to get more lines if we are basing by position. It should be N/W/then G or K. But since all of them can REALLY sing, parts can go to whoever. And that’s one thing I like abt them
English
@HappyRogueA i'm not saying it's unfair, i'm just saying i understand why they feel annoyed, and are surprised at other fans whose their bias even got everything but still protest as if she didn't get anything and instead accuse Winter of getting the most linedis 🥱
English
@bluuforkarina So, is Karina the most important member that she can’t sing the same words over and over again? Whose parts did you want her to take from?
English
And what are her parts ?! What is her screen time ? She’s repeating the same words over and over again.
And solo stans have done more for the group that actually MYs 😅 but ya’ll not ready for that conversation.
And no, I just want fair treatment, there are 4 members in that group, shouldn’t be hard for each to have equal amount of screen time or a DB. But I guess for you its ok for the 3 members to shine while Karina’s in the back with the dancers
Aeri Lee 🍋@kwangya001030
Lmao by that statement ur just proving the point being a solo Stan is a problem u will notice every single piece of Karina parts instead of music itself when she's literally in a group lmao what y'all really want actually producer to do? Make the 3 as her backup dancer ?lol
English
@krnacegf @ervSVTq44jIBHli It’s because the line distribution between the 4 of them is not that big of a gap. Giselle and her are only 3 secs apart. Is there any writing that Karina should get more parts than any of the girls?
English
She’s a sub vocalist, so of course she’ll sing, but not to the point of having the most lines lol. So accusing her of stealing the main vocal parts isn’t really valid
🦋@yizhuozone
yall mad at the member who got least lines in wda and second least lines in lemonade 😂 but y'all didn't have a problem with sub vocalists stealing ningning's vocal parts, go bitch to someone else
English
@BABYSONE7 You solo stans are the ones going to contribute to the downfall. So, are you saying that their success in charts depends only if Karina gets the most? She matters most than the rest of them? Is that your logic?
English
Until SM stops sidelining Karina , we're never getting that RAK 😭 at this point do they lowkey want the grps downfall? cause the way they keep holding her back clearly isnt helping the grp either ..Also aespa is more of a vocal group so why are they making them rap ++
aespa charts@aechartdata
"LEMONADE" by @aespa_official — 4PM KST: #6. Bugs (=) #60. Melon (+15) *new peak* #62. Genie (+10) *new peak*
English
@pantherinaz Yoona of SNSD also has rap dance and vocal positions and barely gets to do any of the 3……. Her fans never complained. Her being center of the group gets divided between her, Yuri and Taeyeon lol
English
@pantherinaz They don’t need a dance break. When was the last time they had a dance break? Spicy? Let me go back and watch. Karina got the parts that perfectly needed her deep singing voice. It was what made those repeated parts a chef’s kiss. Eargasm.
English
@aespalogist Well, aren’t you? I’d understand if Karina got less than 15 seconds of line distribution, or even one member’s line was astronomical. It wasn’t the case.
English
@HappyRogueA 'exaggerating' yeah that's all i need to know about you lol
English
@aespalogist Stop exaggerating things. There is no erasure whatsoever. With the way you are putting things out, you’re saying she deserves more than the rest of the girls. Again, the reason their songs do well is because of the entire group. Not bcz K is front & center and has the most lines
English
@HappyRogueA so tell me what position does karina hold beside being a leader everything is being erased idk if you realise or care to observe the obvious erasure of her positions since whiplash era 🙂 even in wda she's the only member that dont have any solo parts
English
@ppatthecat Hahahahahhahaha you solo stans are CRAZY 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 one thing about SM , if one member is not renewing, you bet your ass they’ll milk the hell out of them 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
English
mungkin pertanda karina gak renew kontrak, makanya tiap cb makin disingkirin. kan cinta sama grup gak mesti menetap diagensi yg sama. biasanya SM gitu, kalo yg gak renew kontrak ketara dari cara dia ngetreat artisnya pas cb
Karina♡@ujiminphoria
I really tried to stay positive and enjoy this comeback, I really did but this is getting too much atp. How long are loveyus supposed to pretend everything is okay and force ourselves to enjoy it just to not "ruin the vibe/fun"? Karina barely got proper solo choreo in WDA and now she barely has parts in Lemonade too while SM keeps pushing her to the back I’m still so proud of Karina and all the hard work she put into this cb and i hope people know that saying she deserves more doesn’t mean i don’t appreciate what she got, it just means things should be more fair. I love everything she showed us but I really hope she gets treated better in the future and that some fans stop turning a blind eye to it
Indonesia
@aespalogist The entire song is repetitive lyrics. From the start to the end. Even Hyoyeon who is arguably a better dancer than Karina, doesn’t always guarantee a solo part or dance break. They often give it to Yuri. And Yuri is also not the most famous member of GG. It goes to whoever fits
English
@HappyRogueA i wouldn't mind she getting less IF
1. her parts are not repetitive lyrics
OR
2. she got her own solo part/dance break
but guess what she got NONE 😂
English
@kgwn1217 The difference between a group with members who can ALL sing and a group who needs to do what their position is. Wonyoung is just the center and face of the group. So expect that she will get that treatment.
English
@EllaNotee @aespalogist Exactly. So let’s say a member is more famous than the main vocalist, but this famous member cannot do a high note, is she still supposed to do the part just because she is more famous than the rest of the group?
English
@HappyRogueA @aespalogist Literally Giselle had lesser lines since debut like it's not that deep. Also Karina shines either way
English
@aesPAKed As a fan of SNSD and f(x), you guys wouldn’t survive the line distribution during 2nd Gen…. Where we are so used to our biases being shoved in the back lol
English
everytime I speak for a member someone gotta yap in my ear saying why dont u speak up for XX like as if I don’t speak up at diff time? stanning sm gg means SM will fuck up but im not gonna be a negativity dumpster 24/7 & am trying to enjoy the girls’ effort so LEAVE ME ALONE
English
@bluuriverr So given your argument, is she supposed to sing half of the song and the rest of the girls just divide between themselves the other half? Stop victimizing Karina to your narratives
English
She gets marketing ads everywhere cuz she's in high demand, with such incredible popularity it is clear that many brands want her. The other members barely got anything outside the group maybe cuz they're not as popular and not as high in demand as Karina.
Hearts2Hearts@Tsadssdw2
Karina fans always complaining about everything when outside of group sm push her the most, she get ads marketing everywhere, while others member barely got anything.if you want her solo , maybe wait for her solo album. even wonyoung fans are not this toxic. ruin the vibe
English
@gayforkarina_ So Karina is more important than the rest of the girls? I don’t think she’ll agree to that….
English
karina, please start focusing on your solo career. aespa may be your priority right now, but it feels like you’re no longer being prioritized within it.
you’re slowly losing yourself as “aespa karina” when you could simply be karina that is your own artist and identity.
nv🥐@rinastwt
karina is it worth sacrificing your solo career for this shitty ass treatment
English
@rinablvu The difference between stanning a member vs stanning the whole group….
English
just bc karina is the most popular doesn’t mean she always has to be pushed to the side. she brought a lot of attention to aespa as the fotg, but sm rarely gives her credit for that. still, this is their best work, but let us point that out without it getting dismissed every time
Karina♡@ujiminphoria
I really tried to stay positive and enjoy this comeback, I really did but this is getting too much atp. How long are loveyus supposed to pretend everything is okay and force ourselves to enjoy it just to not "ruin the vibe/fun"? Karina barely got proper solo choreo in WDA and now she barely has parts in Lemonade too while SM keeps pushing her to the back I’m still so proud of Karina and all the hard work she put into this cb and i hope people know that saying she deserves more doesn’t mean i don’t appreciate what she got, it just means things should be more fair. I love everything she showed us but I really hope she gets treated better in the future and that some fans stop turning a blind eye to it
English
@yizhuozone Why does line distribution matter? The reason the song is good because the parts were perfectly distributed. Not even one part of the song sounded misaligned.
English
yall mad at the member who got least lines in wda and second least lines in lemonade 😂 but y'all didn't have a problem with sub vocalists stealing ningning's vocal parts, go bitch to someone else
rina | wyld ♡@bluuvyu
funny how mys suddenly went quiet when the main vocal steals the rap line from karina (the lead rapper!) they even cheered for that but if it happened the other way karina would’ve got called beggars by mys for stealing vocal line oh mys the double standard yall have is insane 🤧
English