Spartacus

2.5K posts

Spartacus banner
Spartacus

Spartacus

@Incictus_V

• He/Him , Il/Lui • Speak/Parle: English 🇬🇧 , Français 🇫🇷 Classics Enthusiast

Villa Diodati, Lac Léman Katılım Ekim 2022
538 Takip Edilen289 Takipçiler
Chaotic Confucius
Chaotic Confucius@merrrhhhh·
Name three 3️⃣ philosophers that aren’t greek, Freud, or Nietzsche.
English
43
1
14
3.1K
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
@wylfcen French looks better than English IMO it's probably cultural bias to Latinisation speaking but it does.
English
1
0
2
404
Wylfċen
Wylfċen@wylfcen·
>Hear “French is such a beautiful language” >Look up French >It’s gibberish. Can’t understand a word
English
18
9
351
9.7K
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
@asinwo_tbc @RealHellenist Hindi and Sanskrit aren't remotely the same though but I suppose you could argue that Greek wouldn't really come to resemble modern Greek till like the archaic stuff.
English
1
0
1
41
asi 👒
asi 👒@asinwo_tbc·
@RealHellenist with a list like this, nothing stops hindi being first at 2000 bce.
English
1
0
2
429
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
@PhiloCrocodile I feel like the obvious defence is simply that while Wilson is clearly biased literally every major "historic" translation like Pope or what not is clearly a reflection of the time as well. But I'm not so familiar with the Homeric scene so I won't step into it.
English
1
0
3
609
Ye Olde Philologer Cokedril
Ye Olde Philologer Cokedril@PhiloCrocodile·
I would be curious to read a defence of Wilson's translations by someone who clearly reads Greek well and is not obviously affiliated with her "side".
English
24
3
57
8.9K
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
@Viewble @punkinomenon It's the level of stupidity in denigrating the concept of reading words as "outdated."
English
2
0
154
815
View
View@Viewble·
@punkinomenon "my" it's an opinion guys, they're saying what they enjoy consuming the most, they're not making a definitive list of how good everything is
English
2
0
50
10.1K
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
The actual truth to this is both the racial character of later colonial justifications and the fact that people/descendants are still around to advocate. If some part of the Gauls had culturally survived romanisation we would be seeing complaints about Caesar certainly.
ShreddedNerd@o_sneedy

It seems that 1400 is the cut off date for colonialism. Anything before that was completely fine, just another part of history. Anything after that was pure evil with no upsides

English
0
0
0
25
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
I mean this might be true of like the West Ohio Baptist Church or whatever but I think Catholics, Orthodox, Judaism, mainline Islam, Buddhist schools, Hinduism all have a pretty long intellectual tradition even if the average believer doesn't know what they're doing.
Nina@NinaPanickssery

I just don’t get religion or religious people. I don’t understand why religious belief is treated with respect by atheists. The whole things strikes me as something between a stupid LARP and mass psychosis. And smart otherwise rational people get affected too. Unsettling.

English
0
0
4
58
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
Anti-intellectualism is a thing in every single SEA country even Singapore where it's dressed up better but still ultimately subordinate to a mentality based around "practicality" and "pragmatism."
Yves St. Nihil 🏭📕@NihilNothings

Anti-intellectualism runs deep in Indonesia. Just look at how Indonesians engage with media, arts, and politics. It’s a fucking shitshow and it’s a result of how people in power made sure that the masses remain uneducated and ignorant—jancok!

English
0
0
2
70
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
I think part of the problem is that a lot of unis are uncomfortable with placing primacy on certain authors but I have to admit I don't think it's so bad that a Western institution should prioritise works of great significance to Western literature and so on.
Liza Libes@pensandpoison

The fact that you can now graduate from many English programs without once studying Shakespeare, Milton, or Chaucer tells you everything you need to know about modern academia.

English
0
0
0
32
Spartacus
Spartacus@Incictus_V·
I'm not a chud who thinks all unis should RETVRN to worshipping the Canon but I do think it's pretty egregious to make people study critiques of things they've never read or that no common basis of reference exists anymore because that will be "privileging."
Liza Libes@pensandpoison

The fact that you can now graduate from many English programs without once studying Shakespeare, Milton, or Chaucer tells you everything you need to know about modern academia.

English
0
0
1
31