LeenvR 🇳🇱 1948 🙊 retweetledi
Nobody asks the most basic question about ADHD:
Why is this medical at all?
If there's no biological test, no measurable pathology, no objective finding — what exactly gives a doctor the authority to call a child's behavior a disease and prescribe Schedule II amphetamines?
I asked a Columbia psychiatrist this directly. His answer was appeals to training and expertise.
Expertise in what? Memorizing a checklist? Writing prescriptions? Mistaking subjective judgment for medical diagnosis?
Here's what actually gets labeled ADHD:
A traumatized child in hypervigilance. A sleep-deprived kid who can't sit still. A gifted child bored out of their mind. A kid younger than their classmates by 11 months — still developmentally behind peers — labeled disordered. A child reacting to family dysfunction. A malnourished kid washing down a stimulant with sugary cereal.
Every one of those children has a real problem. None of those problems is "ADHD." And none of them gets solved by amphetamines.
What actually gets solved? The inconvenience. The kid sits still. The classroom gets quieter. The parent stops getting calls from the school. The psychiatrist books three more 15-minute medication management appointments per hour.
We're not treating disease. We're suppressing behavior that makes adults uncomfortable — and calling it medicine.
The DSM disorders aren't discovered through research. They're created through committee votes. Literally. When homosexuality was in the DSM, it wasn't removed because of a biological discovery. They voted. That's the process. That's the authority.
Your child's diagnosis was born the same way.
This isn't a fringe position. The former head of NIMH called the DSM "scientifically meaningless." The man who chaired the DSM-IV task force now admits they created false epidemics. These are psychiatry's own leaders.
The question was never whether children struggle. Of course they do. The question is whether we should be diagnosing that struggle as a brain disease and drugging it into silence.
AWAKEN.
English
