王乔治
434 posts


overcooking
you've seen this: someone ships a dashboard that shows every number with a sparkline, every action has a confirmation modal, every empty state has an animated illustration and a tagline. individually each decision made sense to someone. together it feels like chaos. nothing is in focus.
that's overcooking. not one bad decision in isolation, but the accumulation of reasonable ones that no one said no to.
AI makes this worse as the cost of adding dropped to near zero. it can build a feature, even a whole new concept in minutes. so people do. and then they do it again. the thing that started with a clear purpose slowly becomes a collection of additions that are each justifiable but collectively incoherent.
the root problem is that most "new ideas" aren't new. they're repackaging of something that already exists at a more fundamental level. a new sticker on an old concept. it feels like progress because something changed, with a new word and skin – but the thinking didn't go deeper, it just duplicated itself into confusion.
the whole has a core. you feel it once you understand the whole system. everything in it are related and balanced. when you overload it, that gravity weakens. not because any one thing is wrong – but because attention is finite and you force it everywhere.
what we need aren't more tools that make more slop. it's seeing through the chaos, and returning to what the thing actually is, and cutting everything that doesn't serve that. that's harder now, not easier. because there's always something else you could add with one more prompt.
English

@kevinma_dev_zh 有 agent 后,软件的交互设计变得更复杂了。
因为你要考虑对 AI 和人类同时友好。
其实变成了一个新领域——
传递 token 的形式可能比 token 本身承载的信息更重要。
如果做不到这个,很难真正意义上称之为 AI native 应用。
中文

CLI 被 AI 圈吹得有点过了。其实很多用户根本不知道 CLI 是什么,他们在意的是产品好不好用、方不方便,至于是 CLI 还是 GUI,他们并不关心。知道 CLI 的基本就是开发者和极客。
这么多年以来,我发现身边的很多程序员,其实也不太喜欢用 CLI,他们也更习惯用图形界面。
所以 CLI 产品的用户群其实挺有限的。如果你的产品正好面向这部分人,那可以考虑这种形态。不然就继续再观望官网也不迟。
Sam崔@SamBCui
以前我也迷信 CLI 是未来唯一需要的交互形态,直到我做了用户访谈,发现还是有大多数的人其实根本没有 AI 技术。 对于他们来说,有没有 GUI 就是“能不能体验到你这个产品带来的便利”的区别。所以,还是要做 GUI。
中文










