James Nation

863 posts

James Nation banner
James Nation

James Nation

@NationJames

Managing Director at Forefront | Lecturer at Stanford | Ex Deputy Head of the Prime Minister's Policy Unit and Treasury Special Adviser to Rishi Sunak

London Katılım Ağustos 2011
4.8K Takip Edilen1.2K Takipçiler
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Both Rayner and Burnham agreeing on exploring a defence exc from the fiscal rules. Watch this. Just the increase above 2.5%? What about other cabinet ministers pushing for ‘defence related’ funding to count? Won’t happen under Reeves but significant for future Labour policy.
English
0
0
0
177
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Really interesting polling on trade offs and where the public are. Questions for me are whether the fiscal situation in the autumn means a new Chancellor/PM needs to make a bold call like this, and then whether they feel politically able to do so, given cost of living backdrop.
Luke Tryl@LukeTryl

One of the things that surprised me in this week’s episode is that certainly for a large minority the Triple Lock may not be quite as sacrosanct as assumed especially pitched against the need for higher defence spending. Take a listen ⬇️

English
0
0
1
168
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Should stress: this is what I thought pre latest Mandelson developments. I now just wonder whether there’s the political capital for the PM to try and get any difficult funding trade off through Cabinet and the PLP post May elections, given wider issues.
Whitehall Sources@whitehallsource

Expectation is defence spending will have to go up further, with pressure on the Treasury to find extra money beyond what’s currently planned. Is the government looking for ways to fund it without reopening major political battles? #UKPolitics #spending #Whitehall @StraightTie @NationJames @CalumAM

English
0
1
2
532
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Poor diplomacy, but the reality is - even with these efforts - there is no quick trick to boost defence investment without more allocated £ that counts under the fiscal rules. And it’s the difficulties of the political trade offs required to find that cash that means we’re stuck
Esther Webber@estwebber

EXCL: UK will sit on the sidelines of talks this week on a multilateral rearmament bank. Treasury accused of "dragging their feet" on the proposal, despite intensifying pressure to spend more on defense. politico.eu/article/keir-s…

English
0
0
1
401
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Interesting attempt at conditioning here. Whatever gets said, whoever comes next will still need to have a binding constraint. Moving off Reeves’s fiscal rules in the near term will be vv challenging. Hence all the initial focus on OBR reform from Lab figures.
Will Hazell@whazell

Haigh says that PLP is not “unruly and irresponsible” and says that things like the size of the national debt are “very real constraints” which “significantly limits the room for manoeuvre” and to claim otherwise is “deceitful”.

English
0
0
2
332
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Real prospect of stasis in gov now. 1) No political capital to make difficult choices; 2) political/civil service mistrust due to Robbins affair, making state reform tricky; 3) real risks of slowdown due to Thornberry insistence on publishing all minutes, FOI decision on AI etc
English
0
0
1
218
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Quite the hosting debut to react in live time to the Mandelson developments. But good to also give a view on what’s going on re the defence £ conundrum. Let us know what you think!
Whitehall Sources@whitehallsource

NEW: The Mandelson Appointment Saga continues. 💥We react in real time to the news that Lord Mandelson failed security vetting, but was appointed anyway. Stream now. 🎧 podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/whi… @StraightTie | @NationJames | @CalumAM

English
0
1
2
340
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
If support for energy intensive industries (the BICS) doesn’t come in until 2027, then this risks backfiring. Will be pressure to broaden other schemes e.g. the Supercharger in the meantime + will be noise from losers. Tomorrow might not be the boost with biz that the gov hopes.
English
0
0
0
153
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Added to that, you’ve already made a difficult political trade off to cut foreign aid (hard to see this replicated now). A path through here might involve some reprioritisation of capital £. Not good from a growth perspective, but other choices look too politically tricky for MPs
Simon French@Frencheconomics

I know it is popular to pile on the Treasury right now, but if you settle with a department (like the MoD) in SR25 and as part of that settlement you set your fiscal rules, tax plans, and other dept spending plans then to be given an additional £28bn (albeit multi-year) liability shortly after does call into question the faith/competence of the spending department's negotiations.

English
0
0
1
299
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
September a critical month for cost of living. Government would need to legislate pre summer recess to delay fuel duty increase. Then, might not be a full budget, but will need to be an ‘event’ confirming any fiscal support in time for the Q4 price cap.
English
0
0
0
159
James Nation
James Nation@NationJames·
Just on the narrow politics, it makes sense for team Miliband to build up Jackdaw (and maybe Rosebank) as a big decision/concession. The hope will be that any approval is enough for Treasury and the wider Labour Party, without being drawn into the broader debate on oil and gas.
English
0
0
1
281