Nave
28 posts


Giveaway Time 🎉
Win a Pokémon Journey Together Elite Trainer Box to celebrate the launch of Stock Checker's Android app!
How to enter:
• Like & Repost this post
• Comment a Journey Together card you'd want to pack, using #StockCheckerApp
Ends May 9. UK Only.

English
Nave retweetledi

@H3llaG4ySpiral @weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch I never said I take away all repercussions and I'd obviously monkey paw if I felt a wish was unreasonable. It's pretty obvious our dming style is different so let's leave it there.
English

@NaveB97 @weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch This is nearly a decade of experience in this type of game, because ny first DMs were 1e and 2e players, originally. A game where the DM takes away any repercussions sounds frankly boring to me, and has never been something any of my players were interested in
English

@H3llaG4ySpiral @weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch Teleporting home is an entirely reasonable things to do in dnd that a bunch of spells allow for and if a plane is warded against planar travel it's likely warded against the plane itself being shitted into the material plane too.
English

@H3llaG4ySpiral @weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch I just don't understand why there needs to be repercussions. Maybe the players didn't know plane shift existed? The whole point of wish is that it replicates a spell and these DM "lmao you destroyed everything" moments only need to happen if they do something unreasonable.
English

@weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch I think its reasonable to look at a wish and if it perfectly aligns with a spell then it just casts that spell. I agree with your second point though, i'm just not a fan of trying to screw players every time they try to use wish for a cheap gotcha moment.
English

@NaveB97 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch But they didn’t wish for plane shift. They just wished to go home. And with it being in such a spot, it’s possible a normal plane shift wouldn’t work.
English

@weasly65 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch Yeah bro but plane shift is a 7th level spell that teleports you and allies from one plane to a place you choose on another plane. 7 is less than 8 so it should just work with no monkey paw bullshit unless your DM is an asshole
English

@NaveB97 @Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch If you do anything that isn’t an 8th level or lower with wish has the chance of misinterpretation. You are trying to bend the literal force of the universe to your will. If you aren’t crystal clear with what you want… we’ll you tempted fate. And fate doesn’t play on easy mode.
English

@Gorbaducklas @FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch Wouldn't any reasonable DM just rule that as a use of the 7th level spell plane shift?
English

@FluffyKing1994 @DungeonGlitch Saying this as a player in a party that wished to return to our home city while stuck in a pocket layer of the Abyss, only to have that layer moved explosively into Waterdeep with us. Destroyed multiple wards and our bar/home.
English












