Paul W

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Yeah, I know. And for 1880-1920 only. Still waiting for your estimate of any timeframe.

What a beautiful church service held in rathcoole today for our fallen , so proud to be a part of a great community of people #WeWillRememberThem

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall So basically you're admitting that you're doing what you accuse others of: talking through your hole. But talking through your hole for Queen (or king) and country.

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall You're the self-proclaimed 'expert' on here, bud. Surely you can give us your best 'expert' estimate. You were scoffing at the estimates of others. What's yours?

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Every fucking gobdaw nutjob on the internet thinks that.

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Do you realise that reply was to someone else? Click on your post to me which I have copied for you, you arrogant stupid cunt. 😂

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Because Roy is a respected academic and you're a contrarian randomer on the fucking internet who has arrogant delusions that he should be taken seriously.

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Holy shit you stupid fucking ape. This is what you posted yourself before you tried your sleight og hand. Chalisa isn't on it! Guess I have to handhold you back through your own posts. x.com/Ifhfldidhdlsbd…

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall You going to keep posting your 'magnum opus', bud? I already said you just try to discredit academic work by attempting to discredit small parts of it and and actual serious academics like Tirthankar Roy have failed to discredit it.

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall No, you are trying the 'falsis in uno, falsis in omnibus' trick. Better than you have tried to discredit it and been put back in thier (better than your) box. jasonhickel.org/blog/2023/1/7/….

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall Firts you picked out the Great Bengal and Doja famines, then when shown they were under EIC you switched to Chalisa. You have not demonstrated how H&S "made up random bullshit" but only picked random parts of thier studies and tried to discredit it on basis of those random parts

@Ifhfldidhdlsbd @sammaquire @KellyMatshall You're shifting the goalposts now. EIC had a lot of effective if not formal control in that area before 19C. Even excluding Chalisa, the famine death tolls are astronomical. Even long before the period reviewed by Hickel and Sullivan. link.springer.com/chapter/10.105…