Donna OMeara@omeara51547
We’re Not Just Disagreeing Anymore—We’re Destroying Each Other Over Politics
Op-ed by Donna O’Meara
Something has seriously changed in this country—and you can feel it.
There have always been debates when politics are involved.
Now it’s deeply personal.
Uncomfortably emotional.
And more often than people want to admit, it has become hostile and violent.
You’ve probably seen it up close.
Friendships ending over one conversation.
Family members walking on eggshells—or not speaking at all.
People getting publicly shamed, blocked, or unfairly criticized just for saying what they think.
This isn’t rare anymore. It’s become the new normal.
And no—it’s not just “people being more passionate.”
There’s something deeper and darker going on.
Americans don’t just disagree anymore—they don’t even think the other side lives in reality.
According to the Pew Research Center, large majorities of both Republicans and Democrats now say people on the other side can’t even agree on basic facts. That’s not a political gap—that’s a reality gap.
And once you lose a shared sense of reality, disagreement stops being a debate.
It starts feeling like you’re dealing with someone who is either ignorant, irrational, out to get you or dangerous.
Not smarter arguments. Not better reasoning. More hostility. More attacks. More need to “win.” That’s when things escalate. Add personality into the mix and it’s like pouring gasoline onto a fire.
Research in psychology—including studies published in journals like Current Psychology and Political Behavior—has found that traits like entitlement, low empathy, and hypersensitivity to criticism (all tied to narcissism) are strongly linked to more aggressive political behavior.
Recent studies—and large-scale surveys like the American Family Survey—have uncovered some striking patterns.
Certain left-leaning groups, particularly younger folks who spend more time online, report higher levels of emotional distress tied to politics, and a greater willingness to cut people off, shame them, or justify aggressive tactics in the name of being “right.”
That doesn’t mean everyone on the left behaves this way.
But it does mean the pattern is showing up enough in the data that it can’t just be ignored.
Social media is also a powerful accelerant for political division.
A study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that simply exposing people to opposing political views online often increased polarization, rather than reducing it.
Think about that.
The thing we were told would make us more informed and open-minded… is, in many cases, doing the exact opposite.
And it makes sense when you look at how these social media platforms engage viewers.
Outrage spreads faster than nuance.
Anger gets rewarded.
Humiliation goes viral.
So people adapt. They get sharper. Meaner. More melodramatic and exhibitionistic, because that’s what gets likes, followers and attention.
Roll all of this together and it creates a perfect storm:
Disagreement feels like a threat.
Threat triggers emotion.
Emotion turns into attack.
And suddenly, we’re not arguing intellectual ideas—we’re viciously going after each other.
That shift in how we interact is doing real harm.
People are exhausted. According to Pew, a majority of Americans now say politics leaves them feeling drained. Not engaged. Not informed. Drained.
Relationships are failing.
More people are cutting ties with friends and loved ones over politics. “Honest conversations” are being avoided. One person attacks another publicly—without even allowing a response. People are ghosting each other just to keep the peace. And in the worst cases, people are facing outright hostility from those they used to trust.
If you have been a victim of this aggressive behavior it can leave lasting emotional scars and damage, and you are not alone.
It makes you not speak up.
It makes you question relationships.
And over time, victims have reported feeling isolated, lost, hurt and guilty.
So let’s be clear about something that doesn’t get said enough:
If someone attacks you personally because of your political views—that says more about them than it does about you.
If you’ve been on the receiving end of hateful attacks, bullying, or bashing remember you are not responsible for managing, fixing or controlling other people’s emotional actions or reactions to your core beliefs. Let go and allow others to 100% experience their own anger, discomfort, disbelief or anxiety. It has nothing to do with you.
You’re responsible for how you respond. That’s it.
And sometimes the smartest response is no response at all.
Set boundaries.
Step away from toxic conversations.
Stop trying to “win” arguments with people who aren’t interested in understanding you.
That’s not weakness. That’s control.
But there’s also a line you don’t want to cross.
Because the same system that’s pushing some people into outrage… will pull you in too if you let it.
It’s easy to start seeing the “other side” as crazy, lost, or beyond reason.
And sometimes—based on behavior—you might feel justified.
But the second you stop seeing people as people, you’re playing the same game that’s breaking everything in the first place.
Here’s the bottom line:
Disagreement is normal.
A free society depends on it.
But turning disagreement into personal destruction?
That’s a choice.
And right now, too many people are making the wrong choice.
~