Shual@0xShual
I think two things can be true at the same time:
1) "Crypto native" subculture is largely dead or dormant; people are not as active in crypto-centric chats and discord channels, debating the merits of one tech innovation over another, or problem-solving the next bottlenecks.
AI and tradfi stocks are in a raging bull run that provides both the gains and the volatility that crypto used to carry with it for years, without the toxic label, looming hack risks, or toxic trading venues.
Top-tier talent is migrating towards other industries like AI, cyber, biotech, and others.
The space remains plagued by scams, large (binance et al.) and small (predatory KOL grifts, among many others), while "experienced founders" who raised infinite capital continue to ship absolutely nothing of value but opine all day on twitter.
2) The regulatory landscape has never been better.
Crypto projects are gaining real market share with actual use cases (payments, price discovery onchain, privacy, infra rails), real teams, and real profitability.
Crypto is now a legitimate asset class with a wide range of products that are offered and traded in the world's largest financial markets.
In some ironic fashion, the exhaustion from the endless scams and lack of retail hype has acted as a forcing function, and now the smoke is clearing, the noise is slowly being filtered out, and the signal is starting to rise to the top (hyperliquid coded).
So, yeah... The idealistic, cypherpunk ethos that originally built this space has been completely replaced by institutional apathy and fatigue, and we are all too fucking jaded from top to bottom.
And the casual retail crowd and the mercenary capital have moved on to sexier, faster casinos. Most crypto traders as well, tbh. And it's true that what's left behind is an industry stripped of its hype, much of its volatility, a lot of its appeal, and is now forced to either justify its existence through actual tech/innovation or slowly fade into irrelevance sans the odd cyclical pump.
But in a sense, the culture (which was rather toxic for the most part) died, yet the industry is trying to actually survive. Maybe not as an underground cypherpunk movement, but rather more as a true rails/fintech industry. The 'boring but profitable' phase, I guess.