tilak doshi retweetledi

"The deepest tenet of environmentalism is that the original sin of modern civilisation is the Industrial Revolution."
This is correct.
When I was on the BBC's Moral Maze, it completely threw me when Matthew Taylor, Blair's ex-policy chief, attacked the Industrial Revolution. I wasn't really expecting it because for me it is a central achievement of Britain's contribution to the advancement of humanity and civilisation.
It marked the moment we broke free from subsistence, scarcity, and the brute constraints of nature. It gave us mass prosperity, longer lives, modern medicine, sanitation, and the material foundations of everything we have taken for granted.
But what that exchange revealed is a deeper divide. For some, the Industrial Revolution is the root of our problems. For others, it is the reason we have the capacity to solve them at all.
If you start from the premise that industrial civilisation is the problem, then policies that constrain hydrocarbons and limit growth begin to look virtuous. If you start from the opposite premise, that human flourishing depends on abundant, reliable, high-density energy, then those same policies look reckless.
That is the real argument. Everything else is downstream of it.
Great piece from @RupertDarwall
mol.im/a/15699301
English












