₿aoFlow retweetledi
Great question
When a bank issues a loan, it does not loan out deposits. It creates new money as a credit entry
You sign a loan agreement & it becomes an asset for the bank
Bank credits your account & the new deposit becomes new money in circulation
Banks are credit creators rather than intermediaries
Bank-created money is created with interest
Because the interest is not created in the money supply, the system requires perpetual growth, constant new debt or defaults
This is why the private credit system is inherently inflationary & extractive over time
Governments do not create new money to spend directly
They instead issue bonds purchased by banks, pension funds, foreign governments, or the central bank
This is government borrowing which is printing by selling promises
Government-issued money is also interest-bearing, which means it has the same inflationary dynamic as private bank credit creation
Tax serve 3 functions in a fiat system
1 Prevent inflation from excess government spending. If governments printed unlimited money, it would raise spending power without increasing production & create inflation. Taxes remove money from circulation, acting as a drain on the system
2 Give the currency value. If the government requires taxes to be paid in its currency, that alone creates demand
3 Redistribute and fund services. Funding services are not the main monetary reason, that’s the political justification. The monetary purpose is inflation control & currency demand
Governments spend money into the economy & taxes destroy part of that money to keep the system alive
This is the part people misunderstand the most
If new money is printed but does not create new goods, new services, new infrastructure or new real output, then you get more money chasing the same amount of goods, which raises prices
Examples:
Money printing for bailouts, war spending not tied to productive output, stimulus without corresponding output growth, interest-bearing credit expansion for consumption
This type of money requires taxation to remove excess money & prevent inflation
If new money is issued to create new productive output, the money supply increases in proportion to real wealth
Examples:
Building infrastructure, funding energy projects, paying workers to produce real goods & services or capital investments with measurable output
If production rises faster than money supply, no inflation occurs
In such cases, taxation is not required to offset the issuance, because real-world value backs the currency expansion
After the Weimar hyperinflation & Great Depression, Germany introduced Mefo Bills in 1934
It was a government-created promissory note issued to construction & industrial companies
They were not backed by gold, not borrowed from banks, backed by future labor & productive output & used to fund public work
Money was issued only when workers produced output
Idle labor was turned into productive labor
Factories, infrastructure & goods increased alongside the money supply
The credit carried no compounding interest & money was created only to mobilize productive capacity, not consumption or speculation
When money creation matches real productivity, inflation does not occur
Germany reduced unemployment from 30% to 0% in a few years without runaway inflation
Inflation problems emerged later only when issuance shifted to unproductive military expansion
Today’s system is a public–private hybrid
Banks create most money via credit, charge interest & expand the money supply
Governments issue bonds purchased by banks & central banks, borrow the currency they themselves issue & tax to control inflation created by both government & private banks
The government effectively outsourced money creation to private banks & then taxes you to stabilize the system for banks profit
They socialize the losses & privatize the gains.
It’s a ponzi scheme & you pay taxes to service the interest on banks debt.
The Short Way Up@TheShortWayUp
I have a question, might be the wrong questions, but I still have it. Q: if banks print money by using the credit system and governments print money by selling promises(basically same thing) but to other governments/institutions. Why do we pay taxes? What is the link BANK/GOV?
English
