alan manning

556 posts

alan manning

alan manning

@alanmanning4

Labour Market Economist at CEP and LSE. Personal Views Only. Currently posting mostly at @alanmanning4.bsky.social

Katılım Ağustos 2012
57 Takip Edilen2.5K Takipçiler
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
Some links to my recent 3-part Lionel Robbins Lectures on Immigration Policy: Why It is Hard and How To Do It Better. Lecture 1: youtube.com/watch?v=AQkBlG…
YouTube video
YouTube
English
1
0
2
332
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
@FraserNelson Though sometimes migration is disguised borrowing (money now but less in future) or disguised austerity (no govt has increased public investment enough as population rises). See my recent book for detailed explanation of this. So migration often not as helpful as it looks
English
0
0
2
150
Fraser Nelson
Fraser Nelson@FraserNelson·
If net migration really is collapsing - as looks likely - it has huge implications. One is on the public finances. Migration covers up economic problems - without it, ministers have to confront worklessness crisis. How to train, not import, skilled workers. And it will cost…
Steven Swinford@Steven_Swinford

Exclusive from @MaxKendix Rachel Reeves could be forced to raise taxes to make up for a shortfall of billions of pounds caused by a collapse in immigration numbers, experts have warned Net migration is collapsing. Forecasts show that net migration could reach as low as zero or even negative by the end of the year On one level that’s good news for the government. But on the other it could drastically hit tax revenues Charlie McCurdy, an economist at the Labour-linked Resolution Foundation think tank, said: “If predictions that net migration to the UK turns negative by next Christmas — with more people leaving the country than arriving — there would be serious consequences for the public finances “The OBR has previously estimated that a sustained 200,000 reduction in net migration could chip as much as £20 billion off the government’s budget by the end of the decade — even more costly to the Exchequer than cutting 2p from the basic rate of income tax. “If an unexpectedly sharp drop in migration does materialise, it would solve one political challenge for the government but create a new economic one.” Net migration stands at 204,000 for the year to June 2025, down from a peak of 944,000 in the year ending March 2023 In November, the OBR forecast that the figure would be 262,000 this year, but experts say it is far more likely to be substantially lower The predicted drop is partly down to lower numbers of work visas granted after the rules were tightened by the last government. The number of health and social care visas halved last year and visas for skilled workers dropped by a third But an increase in emigration could have a significant impact. One is the predicted impact of the stricter rules on indefinite leave to remain (ILR) announced by Shabana Mahmood, the Home Secretary thetimes.com/article/6763d0…

English
356
78
482
246.9K
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
In (quite possibly unlikely event) you want to know what I really think then you will have to read my book 'Why Immigration Policy is Hard and How To Make It Better' waterstones.com/book/why-immig…
English
0
0
1
218
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
I've heard all publicity is good publicity but this is terrible spin on my views. Yes, I think social care visa was a mistake but I wld not use term 'mass migration', don't think all migration fiscally negative in the long-run. Cld go on but no more words telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/…
English
1
2
2
686
alan manning retweetledi
Resolution Foundation
Resolution Foundation@resfoundation·
📢 Book launch this evening In his latest book, Professor Alan Manning makes the case that while immigration policy will never satisfy everyone, that doesn’t mean it can’t be done much better. Join Alan, Ruth Curtice and @stephenkb to discuss on Thursday. Register ➡️ buff.ly/0jtepcy
Resolution Foundation tweet media
English
1
2
3
1.2K
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
@ESchubart You are right that occupation and salary in skilled worker visa also likely has predictive power. More than nationality I suspect. I think Australia has done this better than other places treasury.gov.au/publication/p2….
English
0
0
2
33
Emma Schubart
Emma Schubart@ESchubart·
Particularly in the UK, visa type doesn’t tell us much about how migrants will contribute once they get here. 72% of skilled work visa holders were earning less than the UK mean salary in 2022-23. Unless visas types got really specific (i.e. basically mapped to country of origin) we’d likely lose significant explanatory power re the norms (e.g. savings, trust, family, redistribution, justice, collaboration) that migrants and their descendants bring with them. Of course this isn't to say that visa types shouldn't be considered at all, and all of this depends on what you're trying to maximise for in your immigration system anyway.
English
1
0
0
67
alan manning retweetledi
Ian Malcolm
Ian Malcolm@IanMalcolm10·
Out tomorrow, Alan Manning's Why Immigration Policy is Hard. People need to read [Manning's] work before immigration tears us apart. -Angus Deaton, Nobel laureate Fantastic, accessible & wittily written... It has challenged, sharpened & changed my thinking. -Stephen Bush, FT
Ian Malcolm tweet media
English
0
5
8
792
Ryan Shorthouse
Ryan Shorthouse@RyanShorthouse·
☑️ Really recommend new book by @alanmanning4, the Former Chair of the Migration Advisory Committee: ‘Why immigration policy is so hard.’ He forensically unearths and rationally explains the evidence on the impacts of immigration. A refreshing counter to the loudmouths on both sides of the debate who have exaggerated - for emotional or political reasons - both the positive and negative impacts. As I’ve written before, the social and economic impacts on UK citizens of mass immigration in the 2010s have been, overall, relatively modest: yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/opinion/c… Here’s two great examples of puncturing both utopian and dystopian advocates on mass immigration by Alan Manning:
Ryan Shorthouse tweet mediaRyan Shorthouse tweet media
English
1
1
2
580
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
I write on immigration but find it hard to answer this question because I don't think it is helpful as a way of framing migration policy. But perhaps I am the problem not the question
alan manning tweet media
English
1
0
8
812
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
@gavinantonyrice @rcolvile I think the reason might be that the government we had for 14 years until last year was largely uninterested in data
English
0
0
1
130
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
@sam_bidwell I find the casual cruelty of this proposal shocking. You would punish people who have simply used a visa for which they were eligible because the previous government was incompetent enough to not think through the possible consequences of the visa
English
0
0
4
314
alan manning
alan manning@alanmanning4·
@NeilDotObrien @charleshymas It has published prison population by detailed nationality since at least 2012! What specific extra data are you wanting
English
3
0
1
467