dya ⳩

711 posts

dya ⳩ banner
dya ⳩

dya ⳩

@assiselle2

isaiah 5:20.

🎪 Katılım Nisan 2026
65 Takip Edilen56 Takipçiler
dya ⳩ retweetledi
Murray Rundus
Murray Rundus@MurrayRundus·
Agiat and CT's points are true broadly speaking, because there is a clear progression from nominalism to subjectivism. Jay Dyer did well to use this sort of historical narrative. For people listening to Tucker Carlson with no prior philosophical experience, this should make people think about *reality* and wake them up from their slumber of modern subjectivism. But it's a bit complicated when dealing with the direct claim in question which is more academic. There is a need on a scholarly level for more careful analysis of Occam and Biel and there has been an excess in pointing to them as the sum of all that we consider to be "Nominalism" and then saying that they revolutionized everything. Father Copleston points this out in his History of Philosophy which should be seen as *the* standard for Catholics. Occam specifically regarding his view of universals, is not as revolutionary as we like to make him out to be, he doesn't get enough credit for his gifted logical abilities, and in modern pop-philosophy books no regard is given to his distinction between the spoken word, the written word and the concept (direct apprehension of a concept). Instead it is seen that Occam was some overly simplistic idiot who got rid of Thomism because of its later excesses. Biel is even more complicated, because it makes it difficult to connect him as "the nominalist" to Protestantism as Biel is one of the intellectual targets of Luther. (Oberman's book the Harvest of Medieval Theology is a starting place on how Realists can understand how there still is an influence despite this) I think the way we can start to understand this is to realize that Ideas *do* have consequences and lead to other ideas, especially if in opposition to or in correction of an excess they are used in an overly simplistic way to signify opposition. Historical philosophy is extremely important for establishing a narrative and way of understanding the world, but in order to not get lost in the weeds we should avoid oversimplifications while pursuing the question of "How can we show that things have stable essences and that there are truly universals right now?" Thomism I believe is the best way to establish this and to *live this* en masse
Agiat 🎈@countmaculad

Yes, not blaming “nominalism” is the pretentious midwit take

English
0
2
5
537
Agiat 🎈
Agiat 🎈@countmaculad·
There are some days at work I just can’t even stand to look at people Don’t talk to me, don’t look at me
English
5
0
39
604
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@terrenceloves1 i LOVE sweet potatoes, if i had to bring only one thing with me on a deserted island it would be an endless supply of sweet potatoes
English
1
0
1
52
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@IsaiahINRI thank you! and its alright, i might prefer just strength training at home anyway
English
0
0
1
26
Isaiah Pickard
Isaiah Pickard@IsaiahINRI·
@assiselle2 Aw, cute. And I'm glad that your Dad offered. Sorry you haven't had much luck finding an all woman's gym
English
1
0
1
34
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
guys really should not waste their time trying to get me to believe that i could find better. i have my heart completely set on marrying my boyfriend. he is entirely better and perfect. why would i trade this blessing of a man God has given me
English
3
1
12
362
dya ⳩ retweetledi
a✶
a✶@beatupchanels·
hate that i made you love me x the nightmare before christmas ♡
English
2
4
173
1.1K
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@countmaculad @IsaiahINRI its basically the same absurdities the friend i told you about would say, i believe ive mentioned it. and last night too i told you about the other one but she this time reacted more positively than the other 2
English
1
0
2
60
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@IsaiahINRI but i told my dad what happened today and he offered to buy me weight sets so i can just do them at home lol. i would've had to wait longer if not for my dad because ive been buying my boyfriend lots of gifts and saving up money for him
English
1
0
1
36
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@IsaiahINRI ive tried to look for an all-girls gym that's at a reasonable distance from me, but i haven't had luck. i usually do pilates, but i incorporated going to the gym for progressive overload +
English
1
0
1
40
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@IsaiahINRI i expect this type of behavior from girls more than guys though, so it was very strange
English
0
0
1
22
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
@IsaiahINRI it was this random guy at the gym lol, ive seen him before but he hadn't approached me in the past up until now, it was weird. i agree with you though! some of my friends ive definitely realized weren't very happy for me. and ive kept them at a distance since
English
3
0
1
71
dya ⳩ retweetledi
Traditional Catholic Weeb ッ
Complete word salad. Orthodox deny dogmas yet somehow they're in "closer communion" (whatever the hell that means) than SSPX? Puh-lease. Imagine if this was assessment read to Pius IX or Eugene IV... there would be censures up the arse
EWTN Vatican@EWTNVatican

A canon law analysis explains why the Vatican recognizes Orthodox marriages but deems SSPX ones invalid, citing differences between incomplete communion and a formal schism. ewtnvatican.com/articles/why-d…

English
16
9
141
5.7K
dya ⳩
dya ⳩@assiselle2·
creó que quedamos en que la verdadera crisis no es la tradición, sino la confusión. si la fidelidad a la fe de siempre acaba siendo más cuestionada que la propia confusión, quizá sea hora de replantearse dónde está realmente el problema.
✝️Mirella🇻🇦@KatalinaSie

Según Roma, la FSSPX está fuera de la Iglesia. Pero al mismo tiempo afirman que fuera de la Iglesia, si hay salvación y se promueve el diálogo con otras religiones como caminos hacia Dios. Entonces, ¿en qué quedamos?

Español
0
0
1
93
dya ⳩ retweetledi
✝️Mirella🇻🇦
✝️Mirella🇻🇦@KatalinaSie·
Según Roma, la FSSPX está fuera de la Iglesia. Pero al mismo tiempo afirman que fuera de la Iglesia, si hay salvación y se promueve el diálogo con otras religiones como caminos hacia Dios. Entonces, ¿en qué quedamos?
✝️Mirella🇻🇦 tweet media
Español
69
93
340
10K