Brethren of Purity

3.4K posts

Brethren of Purity banner
Brethren of Purity

Brethren of Purity

@brethrenfpurity

A group of Islamic philosophers committed to support mystical, philosophical, and historically grounded Islam and engage in informed interfaith discussions.

Katılım Ocak 2022
329 Takip Edilen8K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
Brethren of Purity: We're a collective of followers of various schools of Islamic Philosophy and Mysticism. We've all joined together for one common purpose - to promote The Eternal Wisdom (Hikmah) and to counter a destructive force that is overtaking Islam - Wahabism/Salafism...
English
21
23
203
0
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
No, they've not but the mystical philosophical school (Khomeini/Khamenei) are very much against Shirazis. They fundamentally share a very different conception of religion.
Atlas@CountAtlas

Daniel, I have a honest question for every Twelver Shia, including yourself: The Shirazi school of thought within Twelver Shi'ism openly curse, violate and takfir the wife of the Prophet ﷺ and his companions. Have Sistani, Khomeini or Khamenei ever made takfir of the Shirazis?

English
1
0
16
1.1K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
Wahhabi Delusion is thinking that Taymiyyan pantheism has anything over rationalist Islam. When you ask them for even basic content like their account of causation, you get mere non-replies or abuses. They think laughing makes up for a complete lack of argumentation.
Saifullah@Saifullah9001

@brethrenfpurity You thought you said something smart didn't you. 🤣🤣 who wants to follow a religion that made a fella like you completely forgo evidence from their holy book for philosophical garbage (which btw you also regularly get intellectually molested by muslims on clubhouse & tiktok)

English
0
0
5
216
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
A religion that is not revolutionary and just is no religion at all.
English
2
9
52
1.9K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
If the correct religion includes accepting exploitative hegemony of Imperialism and doing nothing because following the leader is a necessity, then it is 1000x times more spiritual and logical to be a communist atheist. Such a religion simply has no value. It really is opium.
Farid@Farid_0v

"Sadiq" was an atheist that posted back on the Ahlalhdeeth forum and Shiachat over a decade ago. He was trying to decide whether to be Sunni or Shia. He chose Shiasm because he found their wudhu convincing. Silly, yes? Some people convert to Shiasm because of modern politics.

English
5
19
168
8.3K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
@MrAdnanRashid That really doesn't prove much. At best, it shows that he was ecumenical, which everyone already knows he was. There's no official or testimonial record of him accepting Sunnism. Stop coping. For someone who claims to be a historian, this is pretty weak historical reasoning.
English
2
4
101
3.7K
Adnan Rashid
Adnan Rashid@MrAdnanRashid·
IMPORTANT CORRECTION. Shia preachers have been claiming Jinnah (RA) was a 12ver Shia, therefore 12vers made Pakistan. Jinnah (RA) DIED a Sunni Muslim. Evidence: He prayed publicly ONLY with Sunnis. His ONLY OFFICIAL Janaza prayers were led by Mufti Shabbir Ahmad Usmani.
Adnan Rashid tweet mediaAdnan Rashid tweet mediaAdnan Rashid tweet media
English
358
158
867
244.1K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
He has the remarkable capacity of making any conversation about Shī'ism. That too a certain variety of Malangi subcontinental folk Shī'ism which is not even sanctioned by rationalist mystical Qummi leadership which is highly nomian, in opposition to folk antinomianism.
English
0
0
20
668
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
Shaykh Yasir is a moderate Sunni, as many non-Wahhabi subcontinental scholars are. This is high time that decent people like him realize that there is no cure for people like Unc. Adnan. This is because unlike Sh. Yasir who actually cares about Muslims, Adnan is a mere hater.
Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi@YasirAlHanafi

Dead brother Adnan, Eid Mubarak. I understand your position, and even if it is conceded, do you honestly believe it is wise to bring this up now? In a time when the real enemy is not making any distinction between Sunni and Shia? Doesn’t this do us all harm? I am sincerely asking these questions because I believe you may not realise that the timing of your posts is unwise and counterproductive. Please note I have no malice towards you. I wish for you what I wish for myself. Please kindly reflect and introspect on the possibility that your posts may be doing more harm than good *at this current time*. JazakAllahu khairan.

English
4
3
35
1.5K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
the skeptical system is more complex. There is a traditional appraisal in Ilm al-ʿilal but that is somewhat limited. Critical techniques like ICMA can be more helpful in this regard. Even if one doesn't completely affirm them, their reactive skeptical value can't be denied.
English
0
1
8
282
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
Give that the system is bipartite, Ḥadīth and legal derivation, the attack can be too. The attack on derivation relates to the field of rational Uṣūl, a traditional science in which rationalist Ḥanafī Jurists would have the best attacks. For Ḥadīths themselves...
Română
1
1
9
301
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
Wahhabism is a movement that works on selective skepticism just like its imperial modernist counterpart. They are deeply skeptical of anything that opposes them and fairly quick to charge them with fabrications and forgeries.
Brethren of Purity tweet media
English
5
24
138
3.5K
The Muslim Theist
The Muslim Theist@TheMuslimTheist·
Farid thinks that when @Haqiqatjou calls him a "Hindu temple apologist," he's not mocking him for his silence on the UAE, but is claiming Farid actually thinks building Hindu temples is a good thing. He "can't take me seriously" because I pointed this out.
The Muslim Theist tweet media
English
7
1
29
1.5K
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
@lExpectedl @Haqiqatjou That is just the name used for the school generally. That doesn't mean the whole Qum has that tendency, or even the majority. It's associated with Qum because the influential Jurists of the mystical school were related to Qum.
English
0
0
0
75
-'''-
-'''-@lExpectedl·
@brethrenfpurity @Haqiqatjou The (School of Qum) is represented by the Jurists not by one or two individuals. Your mystical revelationary school is not the school of Qum
-'''- tweet media-'''- tweet media-'''- tweet media-'''- tweet media
English
1
0
0
65
Brethren of Purity
Brethren of Purity@brethrenfpurity·
To continue this line of intra-Islamic discussion, @Haqiqatjou, amongst other non-Wahhabi Sunnis, need to discuss with mystical revolutionary Shias (School of Qum), which can be rightly credited with the Iranian revolution.
Brethren of Purity tweet media
English
4
10
85
3.4K

Keşfet

@MrAdnanRashid @TheMuslimTheist @Haqiqatjou @lExpectedl @elonmusk @BarackObama @taylorswift13 @cristiano