Mex Asher@Thatnsukkaboy_
Dear Muslims, we have come with questions of our own, try not to be intellectually and theologically dishonest, we will be checking for your responses and addressing each one.
1. When the Qur’an tells Christians to follow “the Gospel,” what book is it referring to?
(5:47; 5:68)
2. When the Qur’an says the Torah is “guidance and light,” which Torah is that?
(5:43–44)
3. If the Bible was corrupted, why does the Qur’an affirm the Bible the Christians were reading in the 7th century?
4. If the Bible was lost or corrupted, why does Allah command Christians to judge by it?
5. Why does Allah tell Muhammad to consult Christians if he’s in doubt?
(10:94)
6. How can Allah say “no one can change My words” if the Bible — supposedly His word — was changed?
(6:115; 18:27)
7. Did Allah fail to protect previous revelations?
If yes → Allah is not all-powerful.
If no → the Bible is not corrupted.
8. Why does the Qur’an call Jesus “Word of Allah” but deny His divinity?
(4:171)
9. Is Allah’s Word eternal or created?
If eternal → Jesus is eternal.
If created → Allah’s Word is not God.
10. Why does Jesus create life from clay like Allah does?
(3:49; 5:110)
11. Why does the Qur’an say Jesus is “a Spirit from Allah”?
(4:171)
Why isn’t any other prophet called this?
12. Why does the Qur’an say Jesus is “faultless” and “pure,” but Muhammad is not?
(19:19)
13. Why is Jesus still alive and with Allah, but Muhammad is dead in Medina?
14. Why does Jesus return to judge the world, not Muhammad?
15. Why does Allah give Jesus miracles that no other prophet had — including breathing life?
These are divine attributes.
16. Why does Muhammad not know if he will enter Paradise?
(Sahih Bukhari 5:266)
17. Why does Allah never say “I love Muhammad” but repeatedly says He loves Jesus?
18. Why does Muhammad require forgiveness?
(47:19; 48:2)
19. Why did Muhammad say he feared a demon (jinn) when he first received revelation?
(Sirat Ibn Hisham)
20. Why did Muhammad attempt suicide multiple times after the first revelation?
(Sahih Bukhari, Vol. 9)
21. Why is Muhammad given no miracles in the Qur’an, but Muslims claim he performed many?
The Qur’an repeatedly says:
“We did not give him any sign.”
22. Why does the Qur’an deny Muhammad the power to intercede, but Hadith says he will intercede?
Qur’an: 2:48; 6:70; 82:19.
Hadith: Yes, he will intercede.
Contradiction
23. How can Allah be “the best deceiver”?
(3:54; 8:30)
Does deceit belong to God’s essence?
24. If Allah is unknowable and impersonal, how can you claim to know His will?
25. How can Allah have attributes of love, mercy, and justice but no relationship with anyone?
The Christian God is relational.
The Islamic God is solitary.
26. How can Allah be “nearer than your jugular vein” (50:16) but also “does not enter creation”?
Contradiction.
27. How can Allah have a literal throne, literal face, literal shin, and literal hands — yet claim to be “non-corporeal”?
(Sahih Muslim; Ibn Khuzaimah; Qur’an 48:10; 38:75)
28. Why does Islam have ZERO manuscripts of the Qur’an from Muhammad’s lifetime?
29. Why were earlier manuscripts burned by Uthman?
30. Why do Ibn Mas’ud’s and Ubayy’s Qur’ans differ from the modern Qur’an?
31. Why were 63 verses removed by Al-Hajjaj in the Umayyad period?
32. Why does Islamic tradition admit entire chapters were lost or eaten by animals?
(Sunan Ibn Majah; Musnad Ahmad)
If Allah preserves His Word, what happened?
33. If Jesus did not die, how can Allah be just and forgive sin without atonement?
34. If Jesus did not die, how did Allah deceive millions of Christians who believed He did — including the disciples?
Is Allah the author of deception?
35. If the Qur’an confirms the Gospel, but the Gospel contradicts the Qur’an, which one is false?
36. If Islam denies the Father–Son relationship, why does the Qur’an call Jesus “Word” and “Spirit” — both eternal attributes?
37. If Allah hates idolatry, why do Muslims bow toward a stone building?
38. If Islam is universal, why must prayer be done in Arabic — a human language?
39. If Muhammad is the final messenger, why does the Qur’an predict Jesus will return but not Muhammad?
40. If the Bible is true → Islam is false.
If the Bible is false → Islam is still false because the Qur’an affirms it.
So on which foundation will you build Islam?
41. How can you trust the Qur’an when the Qur’an depends on Scriptures that contradict it?
42. Why does the Qur’an command belief in the Gospel — a book every Muslim rejects?
43. If Allah gave previous Scripture but failed to preserve it, what stops Allah from failing again?
44. Why does Jesus do things only God can do — create, forgive sins, judge the world, raise the dead — but Muhammad cannot do any of them?
45. Why does Jesus return as Judge, but Muhammad does not? Who is greater?
46. Why is Jesus alive and Muhammad dead? Who has greater authority?
47. Who exactly visited the prophet in the cave? By what metric was his identity ascertained?
48. AIs there any basis for an angelic encounter that the angel actively tries to harm the person he is sent to at first contact?
49. If it is discovered that the entity who visited the prophet is not the Angel Gabriel, as there are no grounds to hold on to that claim and the being didn't claim to be Angel Gabriel either? What would be the fate of islam knowing that the identity of the angel is of paramount importance to the truth of Islam.?
