@SonRebell Here are the win rates by seat order over the last 6 months for all events with 30+ players, separated into Swiss and Top Cut.
English
Datatog
795 posts
What data is out there for the seating order winrate disparity in #cEDH?
English
@isoanakin Sure, but I’d recommend encouraging some Rog/Si players to register Splinter’s Technique this weekend, since I currently only have about 14 decks in my dataset that play it.
English
@KyleHar53119399 Here is the split between Sewers and Theater. While Theater’s win rate looks promising, the sample size is too small to draw any reliable conclusions.
English
@datatog How does undercity compare to raucous theater? Is it the presence of a surveil at all that matters or is UB specifically better?
English
Undercity Sewers so good you can even get away with playing Starting Town alongside it in Rog/Si 😜
Datatog@datatog
Undercity Sewers and Starting Town numbers in Rog/Si have further stabilized and Sewers stays on top."
English
Formidable Speaker’s only surefire home seems to be Rog/Thras. Every other deck shows very small statistical certainty regarding its inclusion.
Datatog@datatog
One last update on the win rates of Formidable Speaker before the cEDH meta potentially gets turned on its head today
English
Recently successful spice 🌶️
Malcolm Beckford went 3-2-1 on Sisay, Weatherlight Captain @ 'Marchesa Madness 5k cEDH tournament' on March 14th with these includes:
Collected Company
Argothian Elder
Kalain, Reclusive Painter
Sneak Attack
Gwenna, Eyes of Gaea
Quirion Ranger
English
Recently successful spice 🌶️
@Syreno1305 went 3-2-1 on Kinnan @ '2. TQ1 cEDH 2026 / Qualifier cEDH Nationals Germany' on March 14th with these includes:
Citanul Stalwart
Generous Patron
Thundertrap Trainer
Emerald Charm
Emrakul, the Promised End
Displacer Kitten
English
@ExcaliburMTG Very cool that you're trying this! I'm looking forward to player feedback. Maybe prepare a small survey to collect as much data as possible. Two technical questions: 1) How are byes or 3-player pods handled? 2) How is Opponent Win Rate calculated with variable max points?
English
Announcement from Excalibur Events!
We are testing out this new point structure at the Suuuper Scrubby Rebound Sunday CEDH event in Albuquerque, and hope that this test run improves the overall experience with Large-scale C/tEDH events in the future.
This will ONLY apply to the Rebound event.
Thank you to our friends at TopDeck.gg for making the software accommodate this test.
excaliburevents.net/events/albuque…
Bressler, PA 🇺🇸 English
@Scoop_Phase Dihada's results look like this. I did not include it because there were so few decks without Squelcher.
English
Hexing SquelchApocalypse might have lost in the March Meltdown, but at least the two Izzet decks of the format are in complete disagreement about the card.
The Maestro of Melt@ThrasiosPassios
Round 2 -
English
Since the B&R was basically a nothingburger, we thankfully can keep using all data since the release of Lorwyn for an update on Hexing Squelcher.
Datatog@datatog
One last update on the win rates of Hexing Squelcher before the cEDH meta potentially gets turned on its head today.
English
I NEED HELP FINDING cEDH PLAYABLES FROM THIS TURTLE SET!
Does anyone have a commander or card that seems like it could be good?
English
Undercity Sewers and Starting Town numbers in Rog/Si have further stabilized and Sewers stays on top."
Datatog@datatog
The four possible combinations of Starting Town and/or Undercity Sewers currently split Rog/Si decks into four somewhat similarly sized groups. Win rate–wise, the surveil lands seem to outperform the rainbow land.
English