@PlanetofFinks If you said “That Thing You Do” or “Music & Lyrics” (“Way Back…”) or “Josie & the Pussycats” (“Pretend to be Nice”) … that’s all Adam Schlesinger.
What are examples in any form of media where a "brilliant song/painting/play/etc" within the story is actually as good as the characters act like it is?
Note: NOT the same as just "I liked it". It needs to actually fully match its fictional reputation