Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Madamoiselle Heloïse 🇻🇦🤍✝️
4.5K posts

Madamoiselle Heloïse 🇻🇦🤍✝️
@HeloiseDePierre
Daughters of Jerusalem, I charge you: Do not arouse or awaken love until it wakes of its own accord. Song 8:4 https://t.co/niVqfbByCp
Katılım Şubat 2026
242 Takip Edilen722 Takipçiler

@HeloiseDePierre This has gone too far now. I'll pray for you
English

@iam_shwa @ChudNarodnik I mean, I don’t want trans people to die. I see transitioning as the lesser of two evils AT WORST.
English

They went as far as to argue I should be denied communion for defending transgenderism lol.
Madamoiselle Heloïse 🇻🇦🤍✝️@HeloiseDePierre
Things got scary after the Latin Mass today. We started talking about the Odyssey and one of the guys in the group mentioned Trent Horn saying that we shouldn't watch it because it has Elliot Page in it, then things spiraled into me defending transgenderism. It got very tense.
English

@iam_shwa @ChudNarodnik In this essay I comment on this, and argue that this conclusion is a misunderstanding of transgender persons.
sophiededompierre.substack.com/p/a-dignified-…
English

Not true
"Any sex-change intervention, as a rule, risks threatening the unique dignity the person has received from the moment of conception. "The human body shares in the dignity of the image of God. It is a gift... We are called to receive it and respect it in its natural meaning."
"We are not God. We are creatures... any attempt to make oneself God, to determine oneself apart from the truth of one's created nature, is contrary to human dignity
So any attempt to say I have a penis but I'm a girl is playing God and condemned
English

@ChudNarodnik @iam_shwa In a way the reactionary forces in the church and civil society NEED the trans issue to remain unfavorably treated so they can pretend they are riding roughshod over progressive nihilism or whatever
English

@iam_shwa @HeloiseDePierre Another 300000 years of kayfabe on the transgender question
English

@ChudNarodnik @iam_shwa This fact being true adds even more weight to the thesis that being trannsexual Catholic is harder than being a Jansenist or SSPX Catholic
English

@HeloiseDePierre @iam_shwa I mean it’s an easy issue insofar as transsexuals are a vast minority of Catholics so you would lose more Catholics than you would bring it if you rule favourably on them
English

@ChudNarodnik @iam_shwa I would add onto this point and go even further and say that the Church has unironically never addressed the ethicality of transitioning solely from an ethical standpoint of treating dysphoria, but has addressed an ideology fully separate from being trans.
English

@iam_shwa @HeloiseDePierre A lot of us do and sometimes dysphoria doesn’t care about church teaching
English

@ChudNarodnik @iam_shwa Blud thought this was gonna finally make me detransition and start torturing myself again
English

@kingofthehood89 @DazzlingMellie I love chads like that
English

Exceptions exist. I used to work with a trans man who was just such a man it was easy. Knew sports, was brutal at trash talk, super hard worker. That was the first time I ever realized that I may not actually know everything I thought about gender
But most are still sweetie pies lol and it’s hard to hide that
English

@kingofthehood89 @DazzlingMellie Real. Yeah I think a lot of trans masks just want to be not seen as women, not that they actually can stand being a man. UNLESS they pass.
English

@HeloiseDePierre @DazzlingMellie Not at all. The number one thing I think with trans men is feeling sad for them. Because they’re gorls, idc how much facial hair they have 🤷♂️
And I think they’d prefer that. No hormones can make you ready for an all male roast session or competitive masculinity
English

@keegan_122 The idea of curing someone of being a woman is very cruel to me, not to mention it simply never works save in the minute cases where they weren’t actually trans.
English

@HeloiseDePierre Suppose I accepted this premise. Then it would only follow that the “cure” would lie in the mind of the individual. But again, you advocate that this is a real change in sex and that others should accept this? How does this argument favor you?
English

@keegan_122 I will be off X for a while soon so just text me my dear godson
English

@HeloiseDePierre Although I suppose I should say I deny it falls under double effect, which I will later demonstrate
English


@keegan_122 I think sterilization is bad, but it is undeniably the lesser of two evils for trans people with clinically recognizable levels of psychological distress. Even the first canon of Nicea says that sterilization can be justified in certain cases.
English

@HeloiseDePierre It doesn’t need to address it from a point of psychological distress when it condemns it. It condemned it as intrinsically wrong. Additionally, arguing for it as the lesser of two evils doesn’t make sense here since you’ve previously argued it wasn’t an intrinsic wrong anyway
English









