Charlie Rose

47.2K posts

Charlie Rose banner
Charlie Rose

Charlie Rose

@hookinemgood

Texas grad, Texas Dad, Texas forever.

Georgetown, TX Katılım Haziran 2022
1.4K Takip Edilen1.4K Takipçiler
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@jkbjournalist His ratings are okay among the tiny population still watching tv. They sick when you consider production costs.
English
0
0
0
11
OldTimeHardball
OldTimeHardball@OleTimeHardball·
You hold the deciding vote in the Hall of Fame case of Barry Bonds. Does he get in? 162.8 WAR
OldTimeHardball tweet media
English
2.5K
96
1.5K
155.3K
🍃☘️🍀卂乙乙ㄩ尺尺卂🍀☘️🍃
This is Emily Wilson, who translated the Odyssey for "modern audience", focusing mainly on the "girl power", deleting the epic novel classicisms. Nolan's Odyssey is based on this (of course) desecration of the myth. It was enough to read the classic version by Homer, nothing to interpret, everything is in there, characters description, places, costumes, dialogues...but they preferred to insult and despise Greek culture and people intelligence.
🍃☘️🍀卂乙乙ㄩ尺尺卂🍀☘️🍃 tweet media
English
148
119
814
26.4K
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@hamiltonimaging @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 Reread my comment. Read her. She is unconvincing. Good for her for playing the game and getting her paper. Most average academics with nothing else in their life to do can manage that. It’s not a high bar.
English
1
0
0
31
Arnold Ham
Arnold Ham@hamiltonimaging·
@hookinemgood @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 False. Wilson is a classicist and professor whose work focused on ancient Greek and Roman literature. Dislike her translation choices all you like but claiming that she never studied Greek history is incorrect.
English
1
0
0
32
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@hamiltonimaging @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 Scholars disagree because ideology is the history of the academic world. It’s the history of the Church. It’s the history of philosophy. And yes, unsurprisingly, I dismiss scholarship I find unsatisfactory. That’s how literary study works.
English
0
0
0
10
Arnold Ham
Arnold Ham@hamiltonimaging·
@hookinemgood @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 “Scholars disagree because ideology” is just a lazy way to dismiss scholarship you dislike. Homer has been debated for centuries. That’s how literary study works.
English
1
0
0
13
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@chriskilroy @AzzurraS4 Obviously, this is my opinion as a reader and former academic, I just don’t buy the motivated reading to make it all gay.
English
0
0
0
9
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@chriskilroy @AzzurraS4 No, it has been around. It’s just a misread of the things men say in battle. I believe it much less of a stretch to say it is another example of the difficulty men face returning to the world after battle. Not wanting to leave their brothers.
English
1
0
1
16
Arnold Ham
Arnold Ham@hamiltonimaging·
@hookinemgood @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 This is proper literary argument buried under absurd certainty. Scholars genuinely debate whether Homer’s language sounded elevated or closer to accessible oral poetry for its audience. Pretending there’s one unquestionable answer is unserious. Ffs.
English
1
0
0
23
Arnold Ham
Arnold Ham@hamiltonimaging·
@hookinemgood @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 You’re trolling! “Absolutely anyone could translate the Odyssey” immediately followed by “the hard part is understanding grown men and warriors” is incredible. Apparently years of studying ancient Greek matters less than being male and vibing aggressively enough. Deary me.
English
1
0
0
17
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@butleriano The claim is based on a misunderstanding of the warrior’s bond. It’s dumb.
English
0
0
2
300
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@hamiltonimaging @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 And that’s without discussing the history. She claimed the diction wouldn’t sound elevated to Homer’s audience. That’s not true. Religious poetry would use elevated diction. She just doesn’t care about the reality of the actual work.
English
1
0
0
22
Charlie Rose
Charlie Rose@hookinemgood·
@hamiltonimaging @4thSpoliaOpima @AzzurraS4 She has no idea what she’s doing and that’s evident from her own preface and statements. Absolutely anyone could translate the Odyssey. It just takes a little time. K12 kids do parts of it. The hard part is understanding the world of grown men and warriors and faith.
English
2
0
0
28
Arnold Ham
Arnold Ham@hamiltonimaging·
@4thSpoliaOpima @hookinemgood @AzzurraS4 Acknowledging that older translators sometimes inserted sexist assumptions is not “literally woke.” It’s basic literary scholarship. Translators have debated bias, tone and interpretation for centuries ffs.
English
2
0
0
19