Michael Dinitz

2K posts

Michael Dinitz

Michael Dinitz

@mdinitz

Associate Professor, Department of Computer Science, Johns Hopkins University

Baltimore, MD Katılım Nisan 2007
396 Takip Edilen747 Takipçiler
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ I would argue that a random watching YouTube in 2 years should understand the context of wha they’re watching before deciding whether it’s offensive. And, especially as academics, we should model that behavior.
English
0
0
1
23
𝖬𝖺𝗁𝖽𝗂 𝖢𝗁. (bluesky:@mahdi.ch)
@mdinitz By your own style, in the age of AI, it's important to make a joke in a way that when some rando watches it on YouTube 2 years later, they don't find it problematic. I'm not interested in continuing this interaction.
English
1
0
0
19
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ You're free to have a take which includes "jokes at the oscars cannot be assumed to be about the oscars, and we should assume instead that they're offensive". I would argue that that's a crazier take than "you should understand the context of a joke before criticizing it"
English
1
0
1
26
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ It is now incredibly easy to either make up things or find true things but lift them out of context. So it is more important than ever that we closely interrogate everything that we talk about or have an opinion on.
English
0
0
1
15
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ You're certainly free to find the joke bad or unfunny, but saying that it's bad or unfunny without knowing the context is just bad (and in my opinion irresponsible) criticism.
English
0
0
0
16
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ Everything has context. Jokes included. Nothing is informative, funny, or anything else without context. That's why our papers have related work sections.
English
2
0
0
24
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ So while I am sure that you are well-intentioned, opining about a joke and calling it offensive without understanding the context of it was, in my opinion, irresponsible.
English
1
0
1
20
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ I certainly did not want to be insulting. But I think it's incredibly important, particularly in an age of AI, that everyone fully understands context before opining about anything. And I think that's particularly important for academics.
English
2
0
1
41
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ It's not exactly a leap to think that a joke at the Oscars might be about a movie at the Oscars. "Chain-of-thought" is too much to expect, but maybe we should expect that people will be able to understand basic context. At least one would hope so for an educated populace.
English
1
0
1
57
𝖬𝖺𝗁𝖽𝗂 𝖢𝗁. (bluesky:@mahdi.ch)
@mdinitz Whoever made the joke needs to realize that the joke will be interpreted out of context, including by people who don't have their chain-of-thought. As a standalone joke, the reference is quite natural. Different assumptions are how most controversial jokes end up being such.
English
1
0
0
48
Michael Dinitz
Michael Dinitz@mdinitz·
@mahdi_tcs_ In the movie it's a group of white supremacists who do the gassing, so I don't see how it's offensive. And it's not a Holocaust joke - it's a joke about a movie (and one which unlike Schindler's List does not have much to do with the Holocaust). Your take seems crazy to me.
English
1
0
2
63
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
NIL 𝘯𝘰𝘵 NLI
NIL 𝘯𝘰𝘵 NLI@NILnotNLI·
30 years ago today, Princeton upset defending National Champions UCLA
English
42
164
1.2K
152K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
Alex Kontorovich
Alex Kontorovich@AlexKontorovich·
Very sad indeed. When I moved from Princeton to Columbia for grad school, I was *shocked* when I was told that I actually had to proctor my calc exams, and just not trust their "honor code". At Princeton, the honor code genuinely meant something. In the first week of freshman year, we had to write an essay explaining in detail what the consequences of cheating were, why it didn't serve our long term interests, and how even if we weren't the ones cheating, if we knew that others were and didn't report it, we would be just as guilty. (I remember vividly, because my first attempt at such an essay was rejected as insufficiently detailed! I had to write a much longer version.) As a result, people really didn't cheat (as far as I knew; every year there was ~1 student kicked out of school for cheating). It was something really special, it turned out; that's not how it works elsewhere. Sad to see further deterioration of the culture at Princeton.
Steve McGuire@sfmcguire79

Exams at Princeton have been unproctored under an Honor Code since 1893. “Students pledge both to refrain from infractions of academic dishonesty and to report any breaches of the Constitution they witness.” But AI has led to an increase in academic dishonesty cases, so:

English
40
50
1.4K
507.5K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
alex rubinsteyn
alex rubinsteyn@iskander·
Probably lost at least a year of academic productivity to having kids and actually spending time with them. Only started going to academic events out of town after they turn 3. No regrets at all!
Alex Kontorovich@AlexKontorovich

I talk to a lot of younger faculty who struggle balancing work and childcare, and sometimes pass on important professional opportunities as a result. When my first son was about to be born, I had a life-changing conversation with Peter Sarnak. I was living in NYC and teaching at Yale, commuting a few days a week. Unprompted, he said: “I’m going to give you some unsolicited advice. Take your entire salary and spend it on childcare. The cost of childcare won’t go up much, but if you prove good theorems, your salary will.” I was a young assistant professor making ~$90K. My wife was finishing a postdoc and about to start a cardiology fellowship. It had never even occurred to me that we could afford a full-time nanny. But I knew better than to ignore Peter’s advice. So we “splurged.” The nanny arrived at 8am. I handed her the baby and went to “work” (Starbucks), and worked as hard as I could until 6pm, when I went home to relieve her. It was a real cost at the time. But, as Peter predicted, it paid off. Even though someone else cared for our son (eventually, sons) most of the day, we still had real evenings and weekends together — feeding, reading, bathing, playing. As the oldest is now getting ready for high school, I don’t feel like we missed out on any bonding in those early years. And I indeed suffered many fewer professional losses than I would have otherwise. (That sabbatical in Paris will have to wait until they're in college...) I’m not as good as Peter at forcing advice on people. So I’ll just leave this here, in case it helps someone else as much as it helped me.

English
3
2
40
5.3K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
Johns Hopkins University
Johns Hopkins University@JohnsHopkins·
Happy Birthday, Hopkins! Johns Hopkins turns 150 today. Here are just a few milestones that helped shape the university since 1876. Explore more: 150.jhu.edu
Johns Hopkins University tweet mediaJohns Hopkins University tweet mediaJohns Hopkins University tweet mediaJohns Hopkins University tweet media
English
9
48
247
10.3K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
Seth Lazar
Seth Lazar@sethlazar·
As someone very closely involved with some of the history here (through my work with AIES and then FAccT conference from 2021-25), this all strikes me as precisely on point. Very much worth reading: transformernews.ai/p/the-left-is-…
Shakeel@ShakeelHashim

A couple of months ago, @jachiam0 noted that "the left has completely abdicated their role in [the AI] discussion." For @readtransformer today, the superb @kagankans diagnoses the full problem in depth — explaining exactly what people like Cory Doctorow, Emily Bender and Tyler Austin Harper get wrong — and why their sloppy thinking on this could lead to huge problems.

English
1
9
40
7K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
Boaz Barak
Boaz Barak@boazbaraktcs·
Good read. Some part of the left are treating AI like some parts of the right treat climate change. They are just as wrong, but given AI's timescale, will be proven so much faster. transformernews.ai/p/the-left-is-…
Boaz Barak tweet media
English
0
7
74
3.4K
Michael Dinitz retweetledi
Thatchaphol Saranurak
I just gave a tutorial on Design Templates for Dynamic Graph Algorithms at IISc in Bangalore. The kindest words I received were "best tutorial I have listened to in the last 10 years." Hope it interests you. Video: youtube.com/live/L8ev24gBy… Slides: tinyurl.com/yetx3vxu
YouTube video
YouTube
English
1
5
20
1.1K