Mitoma13

Spain hasn’t registered a single shot on target against France, yet they are gifted an 80% xG penalty out of absolutely nothing. It is deciding the game on a non-scoring situation, not to mention a clear handball by Yamal during the buildup to gain control. This is exactly why football rules are broken. It’s too binary. We need a Graded Penalty System: 1️⃣ Standard Penalty (11m): ONLY if a foul denies a direct, active goal-scoring opportunity (attacker facing goal, in motion to shoot). 2️⃣ Distant Penalty (14-15m): For borderline/reckless fouls that don't deny a 100% clear chance. Gives the GK a fighting chance. 3️⃣ Edge-of-Box Free Kick: For soft fouls or back-to-goal situations. No more free gifts. And the ultimate balancer: The player fouled must take the kick. Stop deciding massive tournaments on technicalities. Let the players play!!! To be clear: Under my proposal, Spain's incident today is a clear Option 3 (Edge-of-Box Free Kick). Furthermore, we must fix the absurd handball rule—any contact that advances an attacker's advantage, even if accidental or close-body, should be penalized. The current binary penalty rule is completely illogical and should have been scrapped years ago. Just look at other sports: In basketball, if you foul a player in the paint, they get 2 free throws to potentially score 2 points. It’s proportional. They don’t get awarded 20 free throws just because the foul happened inside the key. Yet in football, a minor, zero-threat trip at the edge of the box is rewarded with a penalty kick—turning a 3% scoring chance into an 80% free gift. It’s the equivalent of giving a basketball team 15 free throws for a common foul. The punishment is completely disconnected from the crime. It’s time to bring mathematical proportion and logic back to football

Spain hasn’t registered a single shot on target against France, yet they are gifted an 80% xG penalty out of absolutely nothing. It is deciding the game on a non-scoring situation, not to mention a clear handball by Yamal during the buildup to gain control. This is exactly why football rules are broken. It’s too binary. We need a Graded Penalty System: 1️⃣ Standard Penalty (11m): ONLY if a foul denies a direct, active goal-scoring opportunity (attacker facing goal, in motion to shoot). 2️⃣ Distant Penalty (14-15m): For borderline/reckless fouls that don't deny a 100% clear chance. Gives the GK a fighting chance. 3️⃣ Edge-of-Box Free Kick: For soft fouls or back-to-goal situations. No more free gifts. And the ultimate balancer: The player fouled must take the kick. Stop deciding massive tournaments on technicalities. Let the players play!!! To be clear: Under my proposal, Spain's incident today is a clear Option 3 (Edge-of-Box Free Kick). Furthermore, we must fix the absurd handball rule—any contact that advances an attacker's advantage, even if accidental or close-body, should be penalized. The current binary penalty rule is completely illogical and should have been scrapped years ago. Just look at other sports: In basketball, if you foul a player in the paint, they get 2 free throws to potentially score 2 points. It’s proportional. They don’t get awarded 20 free throws just because the foul happened inside the key. Yet in football, a minor, zero-threat trip at the edge of the box is rewarded with a penalty kick—turning a 3% scoring chance into an 80% free gift. It’s the equivalent of giving a basketball team 15 free throws for a common foul. The punishment is completely disconnected from the crime. It’s time to bring mathematical proportion and logic back to football

C’était penalty sur Doué

Vraiment pas pour ce genre de situation qu'une sanction aussi lourde que le penalty devrait être possible. Yamal ne vient jamais jouer le ballon. Il court tout droit pour le contact. On est totalement excentré. Il ne peut jamais récupérer la balle.