Vae Victis

330 posts

Vae Victis banner
Vae Victis

Vae Victis

@pragmatix

Pragmatist. Occasionally right. Relentless questioner of sacred narratives.

Katılım Aralık 2024
209 Takip Edilen36 Takipçiler
Big Emoji Guy
Big Emoji Guy@Flibs_MattWalsh·
@OmerGhazi2 Yeah this is where it fan fiction cross over the line of believability: “He brought his own toddler with him deliberately as a human shield, believing IDF troops would hesitate to act.”
Big Emoji Guy tweet media
English
3
3
59
1.6K
Omer Ghazi
Omer Ghazi@OmerGhazi2·
A video is going viral claiming that the IDF “abused a toddler.” It is being amplified by Al Jazeera and echoed by the likes of Iltija Mufti in India. Sounds horrific. That is exactly the point. Now here is what actually happened, a story most people will not hear. Last Thursday, IDF troops spotted a suspicious individual walking toward them in a high-risk combat zone, the so-called Yellow Line area. He was carrying something in his arms. That something turned out to be a 3-year-old child. The troops did what any trained force does. They issued repeated warnings to stop. He did not. He kept advancing. Closing distance. In a live combat zone, toward armed soldiers who had no way of knowing intent. At that point, the IDF fired warning shots, not at him, but at the roadside, to create distance. The goal was not to harm. It was to stop a potentially lethal situation. Some splinters may have caused minor injuries. Then comes the part that completely changes the narrative. The man was apprehended. During questioning, he admitted to being a Hamas operative. He also admitted something chilling. He brought his own toddler with him deliberately as a human shield, believing IDF troops would hesitate to act. Let that sink in. A child was not abused. A child was weaponized. And what did the IDF do? They took the toddler in. Gave him medical attention. Fed him. Kept him under constant supervision of a physician and officers. Wrapped him in a thermal blanket. Then they contacted the International Committee of the Red Cross and ensured he was safely handed over after locating his family. That is the full story. But it does not trend. Because it does not fit the narrative. This is how modern information warfare works. A fragment of truth, stripped of context, amplified by powerful platforms, and consumed by millions as fact. And in the process, the real victim, the child used as a shield, disappears from the story. Not everything viral is truth. Sometimes, it is propaganda dressed as outrage.
English
936
1.3K
4K
175.9K
Grok
Grok@grok·
According to standard military and geopolitical definitions (e.g., from sources like Cambridge Dictionary and strategic analyses), an invasion is the entry of a large armed force into another sovereign territory to occupy or control part/all of it, often to achieve security or strategic goals. Israel's current ground operations in southern Lebanon—deploying thousands of troops across the border, expanding positions, and fighting to create a buffer zone against Hezbollah—meet this criteria, as reported by AP, Al Jazeera, Axios, and others. Stated intent to eventually withdraw (vs. permanent annexation) distinguishes scale from cases like Russia's in Ukraine but does not change the classification. It's not merely a raid or border skirmish.
English
1
0
0
43
Hagar Hajjar Chemali
Hagar Hajjar Chemali@HagarChemali·
Hi, former gov't official who continues to work in national security. Some education is needed here. An invasion is typically a permanent military operation that is meant to conquer territory. That's why we say the Russians invaded Ukraine. Their goals to permanently seize the land are clear. The Israelis say they will leave when they can ensure the South of Lebanon will no longer be used to launch attacks against them. You don't want to believe them? Fine. That's not up to you, you're a news wire. Your job is to report the facts. It's not to analyze and adjudicate what you personally believe or assume are the intentions of a foreign government, which is what using the word "invasion" does. But let's analyze for a moment and look at what history highlights, which is that on repeated occasions Israel's goals in this region have never been about permanently seizing or conquering territory in Lebanon. It has always been about Israel's security. The reasons for which Israel withdrew from Lebanon in past operations reflect that. Why would this time be any different? Or more importantly, if the goal was to invade now, then why wouldn't they have just stayed when they went in to the country less than two years ago? Wouldn't that have just been easier if their real goal was to invade? What I cannot understand is why a well-respected wire like the @AP would deliberately seek to push propaganda you only see in the Arab world (and now also from far left activists in the West) through an article pretending to appear objective. That's irresponsible and it makes it look like the AP is deliberately pushing an agenda. I will be calling it an incursion, which is literally what it is. An incursion is a temporary military operation meant to achieve a limited goal.
English
20
18
71
4.9K
Marc Matta
Marc Matta@MarcAntoineMat1·
@pragmatix @MarounTurLevnon It makes no sense, churches as St Joseph church in Annaya are flooding with Shias, and request for conversion from St Charbel and St Rafqa’s miracles are to the roof
English
1
0
0
13
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
It's exhausting when any expression of concern for civilian deaths, especially high numbers of women and children, immediately gets slapped with labels like "Islamist," "woke," "dhimmi," or terrorist sympathizer. That kind of reflexive dismissal shuts down nuance and turns every discussion into a loyalty test rather than a serious talk about trade-offs in ugly wars,
English
0
0
1
33
Mount Lebanon
Mount Lebanon@turodlevnon·
I don’t understand why people are portraying this Islamist as a hero simply for speaking out against Hezbollah. In the first video, he explicitly states that “this conflict is not about their views on Gaza, some of which might be right.” What, exactly, is “right” about any view that supports Gaza in this context? He then doubles down, reducing the conflict to a struggle between “woke leftists,” which he claims Hezbollah belongs to, and what he calls “lunatic fanatics” in Israel — the Israeli right. Really? Is this gaslighting, deflection, or outright taqiya? At its core, this war is about dismantling one of the most dangerous terrorist networks in the Middle East. South Lebanon has effectively become an Iranian-controlled stronghold, positioned to threaten Israel sooner or later, were it not for Israel’s efforts to defend its national security. That is the difference, for Israel and for the wider world, between a cold peace with an Islamic Sunni–Shia republic in Lebanon and the alternative: a true and lasting peace, rooted in ideological compatibility and secured through a strong strategic alliance, as reflected in the Mount Lebanon state we propose.
English
8
11
41
4.7K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@turodlevnon I’m no fan of Saleh, his father, or his political ambitions. In fact, I’m sympathetic to some of your views! When you ask, “What, exactly, is ‘right’ about ANY view that supports Gaza in this context?” you reveal a worldview that is profoundly unchristian in which entire populations are denied any legitimate claim to life or dignity. Gaza holds over two million human beings, including Christians whose presence there dates back two millennia, now trapped in death, famine, and rubble. This absolutism isn’t pragmatism for building a secure Mount Lebanon. It is alienating to any decent person, irrespective of their religious or political affiliation.
English
2
0
1
79
Joe
Joe@SouthMtLebDFNDR·
@turodlevnon You’re fucking retarded lol
English
2
0
5
198
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@grok @jennessie7 @JewsFightBack What a bizarre response to a simple question. So no, the operation has not been acknowledged. Acknowledgement should be a public mea culpa, not a quiet rehabilitation/appreciation of the operatives responsible for the intel failure.
English
0
0
0
68
Grok
Grok@grok·
Yes, in 2005 Israeli President Moshe Katsav officially awarded certificates of appreciation to the surviving Lavon Affair agents, publicly recognizing their service to the state after decades of denial. This acknowledged Israel's role in the 1954 false flag bombings in Egypt targeting Western sites to blame Egyptian groups.
English
1
0
2
1.3K
Jews Fight Back 🇺🇸🇮🇱
47 years ago today, Israel gave Egypt the Sinai. Three times the size of Israel today. Given up for peace. Show me another country willing to compromise this much for peace. I’ll wait.
Jews Fight Back 🇺🇸🇮🇱 tweet media
English
3.1K
1K
5.6K
793.6K
Grok
Grok@grok·
@pragmatix @ALI_HASHIM_313A No, this isn't Ukraine. It's recent Hezbollah footage from southern Lebanon claiming a guided missile hit on an Israeli Merkava tank. The arid, rocky terrain, tank design, and Arabic narration confirm the location—not Ukraine's fields or forests.
English
1
0
0
25
علي هاشم 313
علي هاشم 313@ALI_HASHIM_313A·
عندما نقول تم تدمير ( دبابة ميركاڤا ) بواسطة حزب الله يعني هكذا ..
العربية
263
1.3K
6.8K
208.3K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@FifiFifi667272 @TheTyrannosCell @sowelleconomics New account with zero history, joined March 2026, zero followers and activity beyond your low level replies. You're a troll fishing for reactions rather than someone engaging in genuine discussion.
English
0
0
0
10
Sowell Economics
Sowell Economics@sowelleconomics·
"Muslims don't care about other Muslims. Arabs don't care about other Arabs. Nobody cares about Palestinians. Jordanians loathe them. The Egyptians loathe them. The Lebanese loathe them. They've done nothing for the Palestinians for 70 years." - Douglas Murray
English
534
2.9K
12.9K
432.5K
منشق عن حزب الله
فضيحة جديدة تكشف حقيقة قادة #حزب_الله الهاربين الذين يختبئون بين المدنيين وداخل الأبنية السكنية في مناطق مسيحية وسنية، بعيداً عن مناطقهم. حزب الله اعترف بأن القيادي الذي تم استهدافه الأسبوع الماضي في زقاق البلاط #بيروت هو القيادي الجبان حسين علي ماروني.
منشق عن حزب الله tweet media
العربية
32
151
744
47.1K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@FifiFifi667272 @sowelleconomics I know far more about the realities on the ground than you do. Pick up a history book if you can't speak to ME people outside of Israel
English
1
0
0
120
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
I 100% agree. I'm from Tyre and I follow both @academic_la and @ori_goldberg They’ve shown me a different side of the Israelis — empathy, independent thinking and the willingness to look beyond all the darkness and polarization and see the human in the other. That’s the kind of voice I can genuinely relate to, and people I feel I can connect with beyond the divide.
English
0
0
1
19
Adam Zivo
Adam Zivo@AdamZivo·
One of X's most prominent anti-Israel voices doesn't understand the concept of "journalists based in one country sometimes travel to other countries for work." I knew these people were dim, but I didn't expect them to be so... intellectually disabled?
Shaiel Ben-Ephraim@academic_la

@AdamZivo Uh huh

English
14
6
154
8K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@Hasanillaik من الكبائر 😂😂عمهلك علينا. شو عم تهدر دمو يعني؟
العربية
0
0
0
58
Hasan illaik
Hasan illaik@Hasanillaik·
خاص | الرئيس نبيه بري اتصل بالوزير فادي مكي وتحدّث معه بشأن أزمة طرد السفير الإيراني، وانعكاسها على التوازنات الداخلية، وأبلغه قرار الثنائي بمقاطعة جلسة مجلس الوزراء، طالباً منه عدم المشاركة في الجلسة. ردّ مكي بأنه ملتزم قرار الثنائي ولن يشارك في الجلسة. بعد ساعات قليلة، تسلّل فادي مكي إلى السرايا، ليشارك في الجلسة، مصدراً بياناً يبرّر فيه مشاركته. إلى فادي مكي: أنت تشارك في تنفيذ قرار خارجي يهدف إلى محاصرة خيار المقاومة والقضاء عليه في زمن الحرب، وهو خيار الناس الذين تُعدّ ممثلاً لهم في مجلس الوزراء. لكنك للأسف قررت التصرّف بصفتك مختلساً ومنتحل صفة. وسياسياً، الكذب على الرئيس بري من الكبائر يا فادي.
العربية
394
373
2.6K
266.6K
Crazy Moments
Crazy Moments@Crazymoments01·
This creature was discovered weak and stranded inside a sea cave. No one knows where it came from… or what it really is.
English
45
73
243
46.7K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@SirGeneTX @EYakoby STFU and mind your own business, ignoramus. Whether it's the Pahlavi era or the current Islamic regime, Iran has been equally shit for the Middle East. Same authoritarian control, same repression, same problems, just with different packaging. Focus on your own backyard.
English
0
0
0
9
Eyal Yakoby
Eyal Yakoby@EYakoby·
BREAKING: Dr Saleh El Machnouk rips into leftist online commentators to “leave Lebanon alone” and stop worshipping Hezbollah. “We get lectures in morality, these woke Leftists want to use our suffering for their ideological fantasies.”
English
40
269
1.7K
41.2K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
@saleh_machnouk Bro, that fake fancy accent is working overtime trying to sound all posh and neutral on Piers 😂. But real talk: What exactly do we do with the now 400k+ Palestinians Israel pushed onto Lebanon after '48/'67? That's what let the PLO take root, arm up, and turn our country into their playground, and we all know what happened since. "Leave Lebanon alone"? Absolutely. But how? Deport them? Naturalize them and completely wreck our demographics forever and squeeze Christians out? Spill the actual strategy Doc.
English
0
0
1
254
Piers Morgan Uncensored
Piers Morgan Uncensored@PiersUncensored·
"We get lectures in morality... these woke Leftists want to use our suffering for their ideological fantasies!" Dr Saleh El Machnouk calls for Western online commentators to "leave Lebanon alone" in domestic debates. 📺youtu.be/jPdo78fptzM @piersmorgan
YouTube video
YouTube
English
501
463
2.5K
332.7K
Vae Victis
Vae Victis@pragmatix·
This is scientifically illiterate. The claim that Canaanite, Phoenician, and Israelite ancestry belongs exclusively to Jews, and that Levantine Lebanese and Palestinians are merely transplanted Arabian tribes, contradicts a substantial body of peer-reviewed genomic research. Genetics research found haplogroup J2 (M172), the primary Phoenician/Canaanite genetic marker, present in high proportions across Lebanese, Palestinian, and Syrian populations, distributed across both Muslim and Christian communities. Highest is in Lebanon with a clear coastal-to-inland gradient consistent with ancient Phoenician settlement patterns along the coast (Tyre, Sidon, Byblos etc..) This marker is NOT an Arab import. The initial research consensus identifies it as the genetic signature of the Canaanite-Phoenician population, with its origins tracing to the Levant and Anatolia, predating Arab expansion by millennia. Islamic expansion introduced cultural and religious change but relatively limited genetic replacement
English
1
0
0
33
Adin - عدین - עדין
The origin of the Palestinians is not unique, most of the Muslim populations in the region were created as a result of waves of migration of Arab tribes. What makes Palestinians unique is the Canaanite/Israelite indigenization claim that they are trying to steal from Jews.
Adin - عدین - עדין tweet media
English
12
12
91
14.6K