Colt816

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess It isn't just Arnold dying Fazbear entertainment never gets the blueprints of the mimic in the games You cant even say that they got it off screen considering there's no confirmation about it Unlike in Tales where they did got the blueprints

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess why does it matter if arnold isn't in tales? what point are you even trying to make here and again, arnold literally dies at the end of SOTM which clearly would have to take place before tales anyways

"Its funny because people say "oH, CaSiDdY iS bEtTer wRitTeN tHaN aNdReW" MOTHERHELLA, CASSIDY IS NOT EVEN WRITTEN"

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess The game expects us to use the books to assist us with the lore not putting it completely together with the games

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess frights and tales do not hold up on their own if you exclude the games because they are taking after that story. likewise the games clearly expect you to read the books for some story reasons too

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess The games protagonists we have is just Arnold, Jeremy, Michael Afton, Vanessa, Gregory, and Casey's dad They're not one off protagonist considering majority of them are dead

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess also even then, arnold is a one off protagonist, which fnaf has many of that never show up again

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Again with the examples you listed here Being directly still doesn't mean 100% mainline canon

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess yeah as in, some stories are directly related to the story of the games and some aren't. WWF, Prankster and TMIR1280 for example are stories that directly relate to the games in one way or form

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Arnold is not in Tales because he's simply not in the tales continuity Having Fiona dying during childbirth compared to mainline Fiona dying in fallfest is already enough to seperate SOTM and Tales SOTM itself is a reimagining of the original backstory

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess arnold is probably not in tales because he died before they took place lol also again, these major events have no effect on most stories. and also i almost forgot but SOTM references the mimic tales story and it's version of events... in the same game that contradicts it

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess If*

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess It tales and frights novels reimagine the games that makes them drastically different then they're not canon to the mainline games It's just simple as that

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess The same logic can also be applied to Frights/tales books It says it takes place in the Fnaf universe Not the games The post also says that SOME are connet directly to the games and some not

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess which he said about the novels only as frights and tales didn't exist at the time he did however state frights was *directly connected to the games* as opposed to the novels where he made a clear separation from them

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Like I'm not against the idea of game mechanics not translating in universe lore but the building looks so different that you really have to sell me on that Like you would have to argue Fnaf 1 was wrong about being the 85 Location despite the it having the saferoom

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess i also already said earlier that fnaf 1's location probably wouldn't work that well for the games format so I don't think it's lore related for why they changed the layout and again, fnaf is never consistent with it's layout designs

@_MichaelSimp_ @bunnyrevived @FNAFtwtconfess Hardmode wouldn't be as relevant Those endoskeletons aren't just there as background props We seen this in the 4th closet where william melts down the 4 animatronics for remnant, along with the 4th closet describing Molten Freddy

@bunnyrevived @FancyColt816 @FNAFtwtconfess I think he's referring to the Endoskeletons that appear in the Hard Mode inside a furnace It would be convincing if it weren't for the random things in Hard Mode, like Springtrap, Mangle, Nightmare Fredbear, etc, so the Endoskeletons don't really mean anything

"MoltenMCI is a horrible plot point that completely undermines the entire purpose of FNaF 3’s ending just so it has a cheap excuse to rehash said ending with voice acting and visuals. It’s an overrated ending that gets too much praise because of the speech."

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess With how SOTM having major events changed compared to the original story along with Arnold not being in Tales of the pizzaplex Talesgames can't coexist with the mainline continuity Recommend checking out unwithered truths timeline breaking video

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess i agree but sotm does not decanonize every single story

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Did you even played SOTM Both henry and William are name dropped in the emails & messages

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess bonus to secret of the mimic for continuing to not namedrop william and henry even though it's been 10 years and there's no mystery as to who they are

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Like I said they weren't a concept back then + Scott steam post

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess no we absolutely CAN and SHOULD blame scott for not name dropping them when all these characters are explicitly shown or referenced in a mainline title lol

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Because all the media around fnaf revolves around the games None of the books cant retcon or change any major aspects of the games themselves Think of the series as a higharchy Like this games > extended material > non canon

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess and frankly, most franchises including fnaf just have flexible canon. which is just bound to happen when you're someone like scott who doesn't take continuity as priority and also how is fnaf at it's core a game series? it's been multimedia longer than it's been a game series

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Like I said Remember what scott said on his steam post "The books are canon, just as the games are. That doesn't mean that they're intended to fit together like 2 puzzle pieces."

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess and how does it in any way help with lore if it can't be accepted based on what the games say? if the games "disprove" it then it's unreliable but if the games support it, it's only because the games have it and not because of the books

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Adding on to this There's also the minigame that feature Vanny and william but was replaced with frights characters, the safe room recreation

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess You ever thought that Scott adapted into the pit twice because it's most likely his favorite story? Megacat had tons off content that were removed With specifically how jeffs office was originally the fnaf 3 officr, the cams in 1985 used to show the ITP looking like fnaf 1

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Tales of the Pizzaplex are Fazbear Frights are the same continuity

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess tell me where fiona ever shows up in frights

@Roxziry @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess Like if we accepted that the silver trilogy as it's own thing that can assist us fill up the gaps without being 100% canon We can do the same with Frights and Tales

@FancyColt816 @MischiefMakerr @sinister169 @Williamafton__5 @FNAFtwtconfess games never even so much as say henry's name or charlie's name or even fucking cassidy's name it has still never dove into agony or remnant when its literally the explanation for how the supernatural works in fnaf why does it need to take priority for lore when it has less lore