Starvecrow

4.4K posts

Starvecrow

Starvecrow

@Starvecrowfeast

เข้าร่วม Ocak 2025
436 กำลังติดตาม131 ผู้ติดตาม
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
And we all know this! No politician in the country pretends the Boriswave was a conscious act of gov policy. But now we see Labour types insisting they receive ILR. Is this due to economic policy? Of course not - it simply rationalises a mistake.
English
1
0
0
6
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
A thing I notice more and more - so many people, as below, talk as if immigration is result of balanced decisions by the state. But eg the Boriswave was just accidental! And the scale of chain migration is accidental! This guys whole thread is a post facto rationalisation.
David Blagden@blagden_david

P.P.S. While all politicians know this, it afflicts them to different extents. Centre-chasing Labour and the Conservatives have had the hardest balancing act (the median voter wants low immigration *and* cheap labour). Easier for those just seeking to galvanise one of the poles.

English
1
0
1
14
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@blagden_david David, if you think our immigration system is defined by our politicians trying to manage this alleged ‘balancing act’, then why are they so reluctant to, eg, obtain the data that would enable them to do so, such as how many immigrants are in the country?
English
1
0
0
4
David Blagden
David Blagden@blagden_david·
Trouble is, public preferences on immigration are contradictory. They don’t want all the cultural change, overcrowding, upward pressure on house prices,* etc. But they also need lots of cheap labour, in lieu of the babies Britons no longer have, to sustain living standards… 1/2
Arthur Spirling@arthur_spirling

Party systems don't die very often and I don't think it's time for obituaries quite yet. Still, when the history of this period is written, the fecklessness of Labour and Tory elites and their bizarre inability to deal with voter preferences around immigration will loom large.

English
17
3
59
16.4K
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@LairdSummerisle @Danjsalt I recall some chap called Andy Burnham from the Blair years ago- he was quite good, Starmer should find out what he’s doing now and get him back into Parliament.
English
0
0
0
21
Dan Salt
Dan Salt@Danjsalt·
I see Starmer is down to randomly appointing old Blairites in a desperate effort to prove he's doing something
English
5
2
77
746
Starvecrow รีทวีตแล้ว
Gerry
Gerry@GerryKeogh_·
This is not democracy at work it’s a complete erosion of national sovereignty and accountability. I genuinely thought it was a joke at first. A guy who only arrived in the country in 2021, on a temporary student/graduate visa, with no long-term commitment to Scotland , no roots here, and apparently fundraising for his next visa just to stay… has now been elected as an MSP for the Scottish Greens in Edinburgh & Lothians East. He can now help shape laws, spending, and policy that affect Scottish taxpayers, communities, housing, services, and culture for years while his own right to be here could be temporary. This isn’t “diversity” or “inclusion.” This is fucking lunacy.
Scottish Greens@scottishgreens

🟢 @q_ueering elected to represent Edinburgh & Lothians East region! Q is one of four Scottish Green MSPs elected in Edinburgh & Lothians East today, taking our total across Scotland to seven - so far!

English
284
2.1K
11.5K
631.3K
Starvecrow รีทวีตแล้ว
Ben
Ben@BWoodzy99·
This guy is here on a temporary three year student visa. He just won a 5 year term in the Scottish Parliament. He is currently crowdfunding for another temporary visa Mental. Absolutely mental
Scottish Greens@scottishgreens

🟢 @q_ueering elected to represent Edinburgh & Lothians East region! Q is one of four Scottish Green MSPs elected in Edinburgh & Lothians East today, taking our total across Scotland to seven - so far!

English
547
3.2K
18.2K
894.3K
Starvecrow รีทวีตแล้ว
JRF
JRF@JRFBoy·
I’m sure there’s an incredibly sophisticated economic argument for why we need to import our supermarket security guards from Africa but I have to confess I’m yet to hear it.
English
21
53
481
38.4K
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@JAHeale I just don’t understand how she can sensibly head the next GE campaign if her own seat is at risk. Will be interesting to watch.
English
0
0
0
52
James Heale
James Heale@JAHeale·
Yep. The risk for Badenoch is that, much like our former monarch, she becomes the adored Queen Kemi, respected and admired by many – but ends her reign ruling over much less territory than with which she began.
Jessica Elgot@jessicaelgot

Without minimising the dire results for Labour, it’s extraordinary how chipper the Tories are. They’ve lost 500 seats from a low watermark, lost major councils to Lib Dems and Reform, show no signs of recovery in the esp LD areas they need to win.

English
28
7
195
46.5K
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@ariaclast Suspect a lot of them know (maybe subconsciously) they have no answers to the pressing issues, so they are just resigned to it. A Labour gov with no money to spend and facing anger over immigration is just a tortoise on its back.
English
0
0
1
12
ariaclast
ariaclast@ariaclast·
“Oh but we can’t do it before the King’s speech”. “Oh but the measures in the King’s speech are good we need to see how they play out”. They are constitutionally incapable of doing what needs to be done.
English
1
0
2
87
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@LeeDavidEvansUK Yes that’s true, but we only knew it with our heads - only when the results come rolling in do we start to know it in our bones, and even then many immediately start to find ways to block it out (not referring to you here!) Good podcast btw.
English
1
0
1
25
Lee David Evans
Lee David Evans@LeeDavidEvansUK·
@Starvecrowfeast Of course it’s valuable when understanding how politics has changed over the last 4 years. But we already knew a lot about that and how dramatic it has been: opinion polling, last year’s local elections, etc.
English
2
0
2
63
Lee David Evans
Lee David Evans@LeeDavidEvansUK·
Why I think the media’s focus on the net gains/losses of Councillors is less helpful than it might seem… Hypothetically, if there was a party that didn’t exist four years ago but won a quarter of the vote on Thursday, they would make enormous gains. On the other hand, a party that was on 50% four years ago that dropped down to a quarter of the vote today, would suffer enormous losses. Their net positions would disguise the fact that they are basically tied today. Obviously, that’s just a hypothetical, but I think it shows how the net results do not necessarily show us the whole picture of where politics is today - but instead compare it with where it was four years ago. So in addition to net results, projected vote share, actual number of Councillors won etc are all important. To be clear: this isn’t to denigrate Reform. They had a good set of elections and topped the table on all those metrics. But to properly understand what happened, there are lots of other angles beyond net gains/losses which bring nuance to the results.
English
2
2
17
1.8K
Starvecrow
Starvecrow@Starvecrowfeast·
@LeeDavidEvansUK All depends on what you’re evaluating. IMO the relevant info we want is: how is the electoral map going to shake out between Reform and Tories? Last year one might have said, R gets midlands and north, Ts get south. Now R getting swathes of south too. Picture gets worse for T!
English
0
1
0
50
Lee David Evans
Lee David Evans@LeeDavidEvansUK·
The interpretation of these results for the Conservatives depends almost entirely on if you’re comparing with 2021/22 (effectively pre-Reform) or 2025. Obviously these are worse for the Tories than before the right was split. But they’re much better than the 2025 results.
English
2
5
22
1.6K
Starvecrow รีทวีตแล้ว
Reform UK Scotland
Reform UK Scotland@ReformUKScot·
Congratulations to our new MSPs for West of Scotland, Malcolm Offord and David Smith 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
Reform UK Scotland tweet mediaReform UK Scotland tweet media
English
193
545
4K
74.3K
Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer@Keir_Starmer·
We must respond to the message that voters have sent us and break with the status quo once and for all. We must confront the big challenges the public face with real answers. That is how we will deliver the change that people are desperate for and build a stronger and fairer country. theguardian.com/commentisfree/…
English
13.7K
470
2.1K
1.6M