Bad Faith Detector

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF There's still the glaring problem that you never addressed, which is that even if humans do have an innate sense of empathy, it is clearly not expressed in the same way universally. For example, most people have preferred family over stranger, nation/tribe/clan over foreigner.

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF The descriptive part, in terms of evolution, would not be found in some contrived, vague, feel-good word definition of "humanity" that people come up with. It would be found in actual human behavior and history, which does not conform to your moral sensibilities.

they’re unironically telling this guy “just don’t be a right-winger” lmfao yeah bro just stop resisting, just step back in line, just obey

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Preservation of civilization can be considered a moral value. The moral rules and values that human beings come up with are not constrained by your moral sensibilities. That is a fact, and I'm pretty sure any "scholar" or meta-ethicist would agree with me on that.

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF I think most people would agree that forcing women into child birth has nothing to do with morality. At best it can be categorized as preservation of civilization. But you could also say that about wars and there is nothing moral about them

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Also, there is a contradiction going on here. You're claiming that morality is based on empathy alone, but also claiming that the huge number of right wingers around the world lack empathy to the point where they are inhuman. Isn't strange that so many humans lack "humanity"?

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF Most of them probably do. But what does that have to do with me? I never claimed to speak for them

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF It is not a fact that all morality is based on empathy, because we can find many instances where that is not the case. For example, people who believe that women ought to have children, even by force if necessary. There are many moral beliefs like this.

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF I'm not making an Is-Ought statement. Empathy IS in humans because of evolution and it IS a fact that all morality is based on empathy. Nothing about this is normative. Now it's my own idea that we OUGHT to act on empathy at all times because that would be the MORAL thing to do

@Femboy_0ccult @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF The best we can do is harm the global south by extracting their most talented people to serve a Capitalistic, Imperialistic empire that you despise?

@IntentChecker11 @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF I'm glad you agree that we should make diplomatic relations with the third world and send them billions as reperations. unfortunately that is an impossible task in today's politics so best we can do this take the immigrant we created

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Do those same scholars agree with your political and moral beliefs, that you think necessarily follow from having "humanity"? Even if I were to accept this definition of humanity, the way "empathy" is expressed is obviously widely variable.

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF I've given you a definition on which most scholars agree on. What do you want from me. You were against me making my own definitions just a tweet ago but now it seems you are creating your own because you hate the reality

@Femboy_0ccult @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF Something being complicated is not the same thing as being ridiculous and contradictory. If you want to help the global south, you would not support the emigration of capable people from those countries to join the US empire (or wherever) that you probably despise.

@IntentChecker11 @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF Politics can be complicated yeah. If you want the simplest explanation, when you cause the instability and immigration of another nation it should be basic dignity to take them, because it's THE MORAL THING TO DO

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF That there might be an innate sense of empathy towards others does not mean we ought to accept your version of that empathy (Hume's Is-Ought Gap). After all, how this "innate empathy" is expressed varies extremely widely.

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF That there is no objective moral codes doesn't mean there's not an innate sense of empathy toward others. Read evolutionary ethics and you'll find the answer to why people are capable of genocides

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Hume was a moral skeptic, he identified the Is-Ought Gap. Meaning, you can describe instances of morality that are "empathetic", but that is completely different from prescribing morality to everyone as "empathy" and not accepting disagreement.

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Read J.L. Mackie and you'll find out that because humans can disagree on even the most basic moral questions, even doing so on a societal scale (e.g. Mongols being ok with massacring tens of millions), it means there are no moral truths innate to human beings.

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Do you look at human history and think "wow, human beings sure are kind and compassionate"?

@IntentChecker11 @Okabe_Rintar0IF Well I dunno about what most people think it is, so here's the academic definition which makes me 100% correct as always. Cope and seethe

@Femboy_0ccult @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF "Brain drain is bad for them so let's make things worse by allowing their most capable people to come here, because that is our punishment for bombing them. But, it's not actually a punishment for bombing them because immigration is good (???)" Is that about right?

@IntentChecker11 @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF Not a solution but can cushen the economic crash before we find real solution. Yeah brain draining is bad, maybe we shouldn't bomb their countries and cause coups and instability so that they don't feel the need to immigrate to Europe or north america

@Femboy_0ccult @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF I don't believe that you genuinely care about low birth rates. But for the sake of argument, immigration is not a solution to low birth rates. They are declining rapidly, globally. And how about the "ethical" concern of brain draining developing countries in the Global South?

@IntentChecker11 @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF Then they are the only economic entity that understands how bsd low birth rate can get for a nation. They are the only ethical billionaires

@onceinfiume @thefreespi65329 @like_tidy @takasiraVT I don't expect an explanation from you, since Moral Error Theory is correct. I'm just here to tell you that you're a moron.

@IntentChecker11 @thefreespi65329 @like_tidy @takasiraVT No I just feel no need to explain why to you. You are not worth my effort or time.

Life of an right winged vtuber >tries to commission artist Artist says I don’t support your ideas and drops you >uses ai for art People cry about you using ai and wishes death on you for not commissioning artists

@onceinfiume @thefreespi65329 @like_tidy @takasiraVT Almost as retarded as someone bleating out his moral views as if they are objectively true without being able to explain why. Couldn't be me!

@IntentChecker11 @thefreespi65329 @like_tidy @takasiraVT Because each of these takes a unique and deeply profound form of retardation to achieve.

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF "Large" is actually an understatement by me. Try >99% of people that have ever lived.

@Femboy_0ccult @Okabe_Rintar0IF Since a large number of people do not share your moral sensibilities, then it must be incorrect that the meaning of humanity is "empathy", whether or not its your definition of the word.

@Femboy_0ccult @KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF He's talking about the pro-immigration part. BlackRock is not anti-immigration or anti-DEI, if you haven't noticed. In fact, they have made massive efforts to promote both of those things.

@KokumajutsushiX @Okabe_Rintar0IF I promise you that marxism is older than BlackRock buddy. Also are all modern ideas created by corpos or just the leftist one's because oh boy let me tell you something about the pro-life movement

@like_tidy @onceinfiume @thefreespi65329 @takasiraVT If you can't show why your moral beliefs are correct, you might as well be telling me that dinosaurs lived with Adam and Eve.

@IntentChecker11 @onceinfiume @thefreespi65329 @takasiraVT He spitting tho