
Christian Caryl
27.9K posts

Christian Caryl
@ccaryl
Columnist @ForeignPolicy. Insomniac, naturalist, frequenter of diners. Ex-WaPo, ex-Newsweek. Own worst enemy.


In Hungary, a striking scene: during Viktor Orbán’s campaign stop in Szombathely, citizens gathered not in applause but in protest, chanting “Russians go home”. It’s more than a moment of dissent—it reflects a deeper European divide between those who stand for democratic sovereignty and those who flirt with authoritarian influence. Europe must remain firm: our future cannot be shaped by fear, nor by those who look East for inspiration instead of forward for progress.

Ari gets the best of this argument. I say this as a longtime admirer of @JonahDispatch.




Sorry Jonah. I actually sat in the room for the first half of the movie. For 24 polite years, Presidents Clinton, Bush and Obama diplomatically asked NATO members to increase defense spending. For 24 years, it was one excuse after another, all focused in Western Europe on how they wish they could spend more, but their social welfare spending priorities wouldn’t let them. In other words, you the US will spend on defense and protect us. Along comes rude Donald Trump. Finally, someone made clear that if Europe kept freeloading the US was done. It took a bill in the China shop to move Europe. Diplomacy failed. Trump prevailed. That’s reality whether you or I like it. NATO self-withered after 75 years. If Spain, England, Italy and France won’t spend what’s necessary to have a real military, it’s time for something new.

When this is over, the western part of NATO will never be the same. Spain, England, France and Italy have sold us out, as they too often have a history of doing. Eastern European nations are the heart of NATO. They spend money on defense, know how to fight and love the US. France particularly deserves fault and blame. From supporting China and Russia at the UN to denying Americans overflight rights, they’re doing what they’ve always done - showing weakness, while cutting deals with terrorists. (The reason the US has a Marine Corps and Navy is unlike France, we refused to pay a ransom to the Barbary Pirates. France is always happy to cut a deal.) Wars have unintended consequences as nations show their true colors. NATO will never be the same, and Western European weakness and acquiescence is the cause.

Iranian President Pezeshkian's close ally Zarif reveals Iranian proposal to end the war: - IRAN STEPS FOLLOWING THE END OF THE HOSTILITIES 1- Commit never to seek nuclear weapons 2- Down-blend enriched uranium to below 3.67 percent 3- Ratify the IAEA Additional Protocol for permanent monitoring 4- Ensure safe commercial passage through the Strait of Hormuz, with Oman 5- Sign a permanent nonaggression pact with the United States 6- Participate in a regional security framework 7- Transfer enriched uranium and related equipment to a regional enrichment consortium 8- Remove terrorism-related designations on the United States 9- Restore diplomatic/consular channels 10- Remove travel restrictions on U.S. citizens 11- Invite oil companies, including American ones, to help facilitate exports 12- China, Russia, and possibly regional states may serve as guarantors of the agreement. - THE US STEPS: 1-Remove unilateral U.S. sanctions on Iran 2-Allow Iran to export oil freely and repatriate the proceeds 3- Accept that Iran will retain some non-weapons-level nuclear program rather than demand zero enrichment 4- Terminate UN Security Council resolutions against Iran 5- Allow Iran to participate normally in global supply chains 6- Sign a permanent nonaggression pact with Iran 6- Finance reconstruction in Iran 7- Compensate Iranian civilians for losses 8- Participate in a regional security framework 9- Help create the regional enrichment consortium 10- Remove terrorism-related designations on Iran 11-- Restore diplomatic/consular channels with Iran 12- Remove travel restrictions on Iranian citizens 13- Cooperate on trade, energy, and technology projects read the full article here: foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/ho…



Back to the Stone Age.



Gideon Rachman: “Iran could emerge from the war stronger and more dangerous” via @FT @gideonrachman ft.com/content/04f6c5…



