Christian Caryl

27.9K posts

Christian Caryl banner
Christian Caryl

Christian Caryl

@ccaryl

Columnist @ForeignPolicy. Insomniac, naturalist, frequenter of diners. Ex-WaPo, ex-Newsweek. Own worst enemy.

Washington, DC Tham gia Ocak 2011
2.3K Đang theo dõi8.5K Người theo dõi
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Rusudan Djakeli 🇬🇪🇺🇦
Day 493 of daily, uninterrupted, nationwide protests in Georgia.
Rusudan Djakeli 🇬🇪🇺🇦 tweet media
English
70
1.5K
5.5K
51.7K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Проект «Хочу жить»
Российский офицер честно о том, во что превратилась современная российская армия. 57-летний Олег Миллер служил еще в 90-х. В 2024 черт дернул его пойти в военкомат и подписать контракт, о чем он теперь жалеет. Вернувшись спустя почти 30 лет, он был шокирован, насколько деградировала армия. Олег попал в 27-ю гвардейскую мотострелковую дивизию в медицинский батальон. Какое-то время исполнял обязанности начальника госпиталя на оккупированной территории Луганской области. Через него прошло множество новобранцев и “тертых калачей”, о которых капитан отзывается отнюдь не лестно: “Сброд… Алкоголики, наркоманы, преступники… Лица, обделенные интеллектом, и по ним видно, что ребята злоупотребляют алкоголем. Нормальные у нас закончились, наверное, в 23-24 году. У нас в 23-м году шли лучшие из худших. А сейчас уже идут даже не худшие из худших, а кто остался из худших” По словам Миллера, подавляющее большинство находятся в российской армии из-за денег. Воюют за идею единицы. В связи с этим жажда наживы перевешивает все остальное. Контрактников-новобранцев, например, командование принимается “обдирать” сразу после попадания в армию: “капнули” выплаты за подписание контракта – делись. Не хочешь – “обнуление”. “В нашей дивизии – не помню, в каком полку – офицеры просто застреливали рядовых. Их посадили, правда. Стреляли просто… Пин-код не говорил – он его пристрелил” Бизнес в прогнившей насквозь российской армии пытаются делать на всем: неотправка на штурм, справки о ранениях, отправка на лечение в тыл, торговля наркотиками и алкоголем, и прочее. Показательно, что какой-то момент люди, идущие на “СВО”, ради заработка, готовы отдать любые деньги, чтобы вырваться из этого ада. 🎥 Полный рассказ капитана Миллера о фирменном скотстве “второй армии мира” смотрите здесь: youtu.be/Y9-2tQHUy_g ➡️ Сохранить себе жизнь и сдаться в плен: t.me/kak_sdatsya_bot 📲 Связаться с нами через Telegram или WhatsApp: +38 095 688 68 88 +38 093 688 68 88 +38 097 688 66 88
YouTube video
YouTube
Русский
13
292
812
66.9K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Kelly Grieco
Kelly Grieco@ka_grieco·
US sending nearly all JASSM-ER cruise missiles to CENTCOM, leaving "only about 425 JASSM-ER out of a prewar inventory of 2,300" for other contingencies. When does the US lose conventional deterrence against China? We're edging dangerously close. bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
English
115
334
1K
403.7K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Jonah Goldberg
Jonah Goldberg@JonahDispatch·
Sorry, Ari. I just saw your response. I think it is hilarious that rather than actually respond to my point, you simply opted to double down on your practice of carrying water for Trump like a modern-day Gunga Din. I think it's great that NATO is spending more on defense. I think Trump can be commended for encouraging it (though the turd-polishing of some folks on this front is often embarrassing. He primarily didn't do it to "save" NATO or even to make it stronger). But all of this is irrelevant to the point you dodged. If you think Trump has handled the transatlantic alliance well since being elected to his second term, say so. Own it. Don't deflect. But if that is your position, that's pure idiocy or dishonest spin. Our NATO allies *should* step up. It would be in their interest. But Trump has made the politics of that near-impossible by threatening Greenland, claiming that our allies didn't really fight in Afghanistan and Iraq, (not Vance's Munich performance, dicking around with Ukraine) etc. Even the far right (outside of Hungary) parties hate Trump now. Then, when Trump launched this war on Iran he said he didn't need any of their help because we already won. Now, he's asking for help, but he can't concede error or even ask nicely. So he implies their all cowards who need to muster "delayed courage." Defend that Ari. Hell simply acknowledge it.
Ari Fleischer@AriFleischer

Sorry Jonah. I actually sat in the room for the first half of the movie. For 24 polite years, Presidents Clinton, Bush and Obama diplomatically asked NATO members to increase defense spending. For 24 years, it was one excuse after another, all focused in Western Europe on how they wish they could spend more, but their social welfare spending priorities wouldn’t let them. In other words, you the US will spend on defense and protect us. Along comes rude Donald Trump. Finally, someone made clear that if Europe kept freeloading the US was done. It took a bill in the China shop to move Europe. Diplomacy failed. Trump prevailed. That’s reality whether you or I like it. NATO self-withered after 75 years. If Spain, England, Italy and France won’t spend what’s necessary to have a real military, it’s time for something new.

English
309
425
3.3K
604.5K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Edward Luce
Edward Luce@EdwardGLuce·
This site’s awash with idiots who cheerled the Iraq war, didn’t learn a thing from that fiasco, and are now squaring their idiocy by doing the same with Trump and Iran. Thought about expressing this more politely but there’s no point in euphemism. America is deservedly alone.
English
110
574
2.6K
195.8K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Christian Caryl
Christian Caryl@ccaryl·
Sounds intriguing. Can’t imagine IRGC signing up for it. Pezeshkian and Zarif appear to have little say in Tehran these days
Ragıp Soylu@ragipsoylu

Iranian President Pezeshkian's close ally Zarif reveals Iranian proposal to end the war: - IRAN STEPS FOLLOWING THE END OF THE HOSTILITIES 1- Commit never to seek nuclear weapons 2- Down-blend enriched uranium to below 3.67 percent 3- Ratify the IAEA Additional Protocol for permanent monitoring 4- Ensure safe commercial passage through the Strait of Hormuz, with Oman 5- Sign a permanent nonaggression pact with the United States 6- Participate in a regional security framework 7- Transfer enriched uranium and related equipment to a regional enrichment consortium 8- Remove terrorism-related designations on the United States 9- Restore diplomatic/consular channels 10- Remove travel restrictions on U.S. citizens 11- Invite oil companies, including American ones, to help facilitate exports 12- China, Russia, and possibly regional states may serve as guarantors of the agreement. - THE US STEPS: 1-Remove unilateral U.S. sanctions on Iran 2-Allow Iran to export oil freely and repatriate the proceeds 3- Accept that Iran will retain some non-weapons-level nuclear program rather than demand zero enrichment 4- Terminate UN Security Council resolutions against Iran 5- Allow Iran to participate normally in global supply chains 6- Sign a permanent nonaggression pact with Iran 6- Finance reconstruction in Iran 7- Compensate Iranian civilians for losses 8- Participate in a regional security framework 9- Help create the regional enrichment consortium 10- Remove terrorism-related designations on Iran 11-- Restore diplomatic/consular channels with Iran 12- Remove travel restrictions on Iranian citizens 13- Cooperate on trade, energy, and technology projects read the full article here: foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/ho…

English
0
0
0
159
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Edward Luce
Edward Luce@EdwardGLuce·
@marcthiessen Marc, Nato's purpose is not hard to understand; mutual self-defence. That obviously doesn't cover reckless wars of choice on which other members haven't been consulted & would never have advised.
English
35
108
1.2K
42.5K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Edward Luce
Edward Luce@EdwardGLuce·
People say Trump’s presidency is dying in Iran but we’re less than a third of the way through. Chances of major power conflict before 2029?
English
26
33
174
20.1K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Nazanin Boniadi
Nazanin Boniadi@NazaninBoniadi·
The brave Iranian people have risked everything to rid themselves—and the world—of the blight of the Islamic Republic. Threats to send Iran “back to the Stone Age” are inhumane. This regime shows no regard for the destruction of Iran—in fact, it has driven it.
Pete Hegseth@PeteHegseth

Back to the Stone Age.

English
1
506
2.1K
305.8K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Foreign Policy
Foreign Policy@ForeignPolicy·
It is hard to escape the sense that many Americans—not only government officials and high-ranking military officers—simply do not grasp the geopolitical implications of new war technologies, writes columnist @ccaryl. foreignpolicy.com/2026/03/31/dro…
English
3
15
30
4K
Christian Caryl đã retweet
Edward Luce
Edward Luce@EdwardGLuce·
"energy shocks unfold sequentially NOT simultaneously"
Andrew Neil@afneil

We have yet to feel the full force of oil and gas price spikes and energy shortages.  But they’ve started in Asia, the destination for most oil and gas that went through the Strait of Hormuz. They’re now coming our way, arriving by the middle of April at the latest, as they roll west across the globe.  Just because it hasn’t happened yet doesn’t mean it isn’t going to. Energy shocks unfold sequentially NOT simultaneously.  People and politicians haven’t yet woken up to this. Yesterday on this show we spoke to Greg Newman, an experienced energy trader. He warned of major problems coming down the pike. He’s right. It was a wake up call we’d do well to heed.  What’s already happening in Asia is a harbinger of what’s in store for us. Huge rises in the price of oil and gas. Growing shortages in diesel and jet fuel. Knock on effects on everything from fertilisers for the spring growing season to microchip production.  About a third of the world’s fertilisers, needed for food production, and a third of the world’s helium, needed for chip production, are produced by the Gulf’s petrochemical industries and come through the Strait of Hormuz. No longer.  Western governments need to wake up to the economic tsunami coming their way. The Starmer government in particular needs to get a grip.  The PM and his ministers are dangerously insouciant in the face of what’s about to hit them. They speak in generalities, with no sense of urgency, complacently out of their depth. I fear they have no idea what’s in store.  They talk about average household energy bills falling by over £100 from tomorrow. What they never add is that they will rise by almost £300 come July.  Soon the price of everything from petrol at the pump to food at the check out counter will soar. Central banks will panic at the sight of inflation reignited — and jack up interest rates.  Remember this — every major energy shock in the past has led to recession. Not because energy prices went through the roof but because central banks pushed up interest rates in their wake, killing consumer spending, the property market and business investment in the process. AND ushering in recession.  There is every chance history is about to repeat itself. Especially since we’re now run by people who are wholly ignorant of that history.  Of course, peace could soon break out and, after a rough spring and summer, normality could beckon before winter is again upon us.  But if the Strait of Hormuz is still closed in a month’s time we will all be paying a steep price for a war — Trump’s War — we did not start and did not ask for. And having to deal with an increasingly deranged White House.  2/2

English
3
55
227
36.6K