Lali

43.4K posts

Lali banner
Lali

Lali

@ReaderLals

Love reading, watching podcasts , interviews, documentaries ,humanity. Review books. Retweets and likes are not always endorsements.

加入时间 Ağustos 2009
1.8K 关注1K 粉丝
.
.@coldbrewtonic·
@fozzywrites because when they give their opinions/feedback/review, you wild andh bhakts wont be able to digest the fact. You will start abusing them + start threatening their families. Its safer for them to remain silent.
English
2
0
55
4.2K
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@PratimDGupta 2/2 He seems to beat himself up all the time. He was good as the senior Chaddha of LSC, but he has not stopped berating himself for LSC, still. He was terrific in Dangal, IMO. But I remember reading one R Desai terming his Dangal perf as studied, not free.😏
English
0
0
0
7
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@PratimDGupta IMO Aamir was all right as Arun. A star appearing in a non-starry set up, an arty film,gets scrutinised more, is virtually seen as an outsider daring to step into a hallowed space. And Aamir calling up to say, yes, I was bad, you are right…typical.:)1/2
English
1
0
0
50
Pratim Dasgupta
Pratim Dasgupta@PratimDGupta·
I have a favourite Aamir Khan story that should have absolutely been the crown jewel of my Bollywood book, if I ever get around to writing one. And given that I spent 12 years in the trenches as a Hindi film journalist and critic for The Telegraph, believe me, I have quite a few stories. But this one. This one is different. Dhobi Ghat had just released. I reviewed it for t2, the entertainment supplement of The Telegraph. I wrote that while Monica Dogra, Prateik Babbar, and Kriti Malhotra slipped into their characters like second skin — effortlessly, organically, exactly what Kiran Rao's debut needed — Aamir Khan stuck out like a sore thumb. He hadn't found the sur of the film. He was, in my honest critical opinion, miscast. The review ran on Saturday. Monday evening. Late. My phone buzzes with a text from an unknown number. "Hi Pratim, when can I call? Aamir." I went cold. I knew what film people do when you don't align with them creatively. They get vengeful. They get vindictive. They have long memories and longer grudges. And this wasn't just any film person. This was Aamir Khan. The perfectionist. The man who doesn't do anything without a reason. With slightly unsteady fingers, I typed back: "Hi Aamir, we can speak now." He called immediately. In that inimitable style of his — measured, unhurried, punctuated with those trademark pauses that make you hang on every single word — he said he had read my review. I braced myself. He said he completely agreed with me. I'm sorry — what? Aamir Khan had called me, a film critic, to say I was right about his performance being off. I couldn't process it. Here was one of the biggest stars in Indian cinema, a man with nothing to prove to anyone, voluntarily picking up the phone to validate a critic's assessment of his own shortcomings. The silence on my end must have been deafening. And then he said it. The line I will never forget: "I was the worst of the four." He ended the call with four words that have stayed with me ever since: "Keep writing what you feel." Years later, when I heard that he had auditioned for Kiran Rao's second film — Lapataa Ladies, which he was producing — and that she had ultimately gone with Ravi Kishen for the role instead, something clicked into place quietly inside me. No ego. No entitlement. Just a man who understood his own limitations well enough to let go. Nothing had changed. He was still that guy.
Pratim Dasgupta tweet media
English
83
339
2.5K
140.2K
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@oila2015 He was all right as Arun. I think stars have it harder when they appear with non-stars in an arty film. Critics dissect a star’s performance while doing a non-commercial ‘different’ film. A sort of reverse snobbery where the commercial star is the outsider.
English
0
0
1
11
Aleksandra
Aleksandra@oila2015·
Good story about Aamir Khan and his self awareness and self criticism as an actor. But I liked Aamir's performance in Dhobi Ghat because it was different from his other parts. Some stiffness didn't bother me, it had some appeal.
Aleksandra tweet mediaAleksandra tweet mediaAleksandra tweet mediaAleksandra tweet media
Pratim Dasgupta@PratimDGupta

I have a favourite Aamir Khan story that should have absolutely been the crown jewel of my Bollywood book, if I ever get around to writing one. And given that I spent 12 years in the trenches as a Hindi film journalist and critic for The Telegraph, believe me, I have quite a few stories. But this one. This one is different. Dhobi Ghat had just released. I reviewed it for t2, the entertainment supplement of The Telegraph. I wrote that while Monica Dogra, Prateik Babbar, and Kriti Malhotra slipped into their characters like second skin — effortlessly, organically, exactly what Kiran Rao's debut needed — Aamir Khan stuck out like a sore thumb. He hadn't found the sur of the film. He was, in my honest critical opinion, miscast. The review ran on Saturday. Monday evening. Late. My phone buzzes with a text from an unknown number. "Hi Pratim, when can I call? Aamir." I went cold. I knew what film people do when you don't align with them creatively. They get vengeful. They get vindictive. They have long memories and longer grudges. And this wasn't just any film person. This was Aamir Khan. The perfectionist. The man who doesn't do anything without a reason. With slightly unsteady fingers, I typed back: "Hi Aamir, we can speak now." He called immediately. In that inimitable style of his — measured, unhurried, punctuated with those trademark pauses that make you hang on every single word — he said he had read my review. I braced myself. He said he completely agreed with me. I'm sorry — what? Aamir Khan had called me, a film critic, to say I was right about his performance being off. I couldn't process it. Here was one of the biggest stars in Indian cinema, a man with nothing to prove to anyone, voluntarily picking up the phone to validate a critic's assessment of his own shortcomings. The silence on my end must have been deafening. And then he said it. The line I will never forget: "I was the worst of the four." He ended the call with four words that have stayed with me ever since: "Keep writing what you feel." Years later, when I heard that he had auditioned for Kiran Rao's second film — Lapataa Ladies, which he was producing — and that she had ultimately gone with Ravi Kishen for the role instead, something clicked into place quietly inside me. No ego. No entitlement. Just a man who understood his own limitations well enough to let go. Nothing had changed. He was still that guy.

English
2
5
20
824
Aleksandra
Aleksandra@oila2015·
@ReaderLals @PratimDGupta It always astonishes me how little it takes to bash Aamir... And, like in this recent case, for things that should be universally known, especially by industry people...
English
1
0
1
23
NJ🏹
NJ🏹@Nilzrav·
A man of vision, integrity, introspection and uncompromising artistic intellect, Aamir Khan❤️
Pratim Dasgupta@PratimDGupta

I have a favourite Aamir Khan story that should have absolutely been the crown jewel of my Bollywood book, if I ever get around to writing one. And given that I spent 12 years in the trenches as a Hindi film journalist and critic for The Telegraph, believe me, I have quite a few stories. But this one. This one is different. Dhobi Ghat had just released. I reviewed it for t2, the entertainment supplement of The Telegraph. I wrote that while Monica Dogra, Prateik Babbar, and Kriti Malhotra slipped into their characters like second skin — effortlessly, organically, exactly what Kiran Rao's debut needed — Aamir Khan stuck out like a sore thumb. He hadn't found the sur of the film. He was, in my honest critical opinion, miscast. The review ran on Saturday. Monday evening. Late. My phone buzzes with a text from an unknown number. "Hi Pratim, when can I call? Aamir." I went cold. I knew what film people do when you don't align with them creatively. They get vengeful. They get vindictive. They have long memories and longer grudges. And this wasn't just any film person. This was Aamir Khan. The perfectionist. The man who doesn't do anything without a reason. With slightly unsteady fingers, I typed back: "Hi Aamir, we can speak now." He called immediately. In that inimitable style of his — measured, unhurried, punctuated with those trademark pauses that make you hang on every single word — he said he had read my review. I braced myself. He said he completely agreed with me. I'm sorry — what? Aamir Khan had called me, a film critic, to say I was right about his performance being off. I couldn't process it. Here was one of the biggest stars in Indian cinema, a man with nothing to prove to anyone, voluntarily picking up the phone to validate a critic's assessment of his own shortcomings. The silence on my end must have been deafening. And then he said it. The line I will never forget: "I was the worst of the four." He ended the call with four words that have stayed with me ever since: "Keep writing what you feel." Years later, when I heard that he had auditioned for Kiran Rao's second film — Lapataa Ladies, which he was producing — and that she had ultimately gone with Ravi Kishen for the role instead, something clicked into place quietly inside me. No ego. No entitlement. Just a man who understood his own limitations well enough to let go. Nothing had changed. He was still that guy.

English
3
17
70
2.8K
Adi
Adi@arandomguyposts·
@SriniR_2025 Took me a coupe of watches to understand why Mukesh Rishi was that disillusioned with the system and it was probably the first time as you said The way Aamir didn’t give up after suffering so much, equation between Aamir and him slowly changing were written well
English
1
1
1
56
Adi
Adi@arandomguyposts·
Don’t care about these fights Will always have a special admiration for sarfarosh First watched it when I was 11 years old on tv which gave me a perspective I’m glad I was exposed to at an early age Mainly from the character played by Mukesh Rishi who was excellent👏🏻👏🏻
ⒶⓀ@fanofaamir_

Calm down.. Sarfarosh is BAAP of Dhurandhar

English
2
6
18
809
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@rodstork @PratimDGupta I have actually read, Naseer being complimentary to Aamir. Aamir aced some films — Ghulam, JJWS, Rangeela, 1947 Earth, Mangal Pandey, Fanaa…right up to Dangal ; liked his merry rogue act in TOH. Was fine in SZP. Sometimes he misses, but he is all right.
English
0
0
6
243
Harshvardhan
Harshvardhan@rodstork·
@PratimDGupta Naseer Saab rightly said post Peepli Live that Aamir is a great producer, but he shouldn’t insist on acting on all the movies he produces. The context was he wanted to play Nattha’s role in Peepli Live. Naseer has never been a fan of Aamir the actor.
English
6
0
21
2.8K
Nishant Kaushik
Nishant Kaushik@nofreecopies·
People are hating on Aamir Khan because he said he has not watched Dhurandhar 2. Patriotism is at stakes, patriots. Either ensure you have the money and time to watch it, or at least don't hold your honesty so close to your chest. Sheeeeee.
English
2
0
0
214
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@fanofaamir_ Absolutely. Every piece of dialogue, characters, cinematography, music, direction, performances — and all without inducing hate in the audience.
English
0
0
1
25
ⒶⓀ
ⒶⓀ@fanofaamir_·
@ReaderLals An underrated masterpiece. It was way ahead of its time.
English
1
0
1
31
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@Bij_uji Political backing is a given. Plus regular viewers and the push power of social media.
English
0
0
1
38
𝕭𝖎𝖏𝖚⚜️
I haven’t met a single person in real life who has watched Dhurandhar in theatres. No celebrations, no houseful shows, not even genuine positive reviews,most people are calling it propaganda. So my simple question is from where is this massive box office collection coming from? How much of it is corporate booking? And is there any political backing behind this “success”? 🤔
English
57
41
104
6.4K
Rants&Roasts
Rants&Roasts@Sydusm·
Dhurandhar should be our next entry for the Oscars. The world ought to know what sh!t we make.
English
57
60
998
17.6K
Lali 已转推
M
M@BjornQuixote·
Everyone today is an expert on #SatyajitRay. Great but no one has either seen him or met him😂 so all discussions in the air. He was a regular at our house either in #Uttarpara or at Golpark or at Bimal Chatterjee's house at Philips Entally. Bimal Chatterjee was my uncle.. to 1/2
M tweet mediaM tweet mediaM tweet media
English
8
13
147
7.6K
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@ShivamVahia Is everyone bound to like Dhurandhar, watch it? What sort of bullying is this by social media armies?😑
English
0
0
1
174
Lali
Lali@ReaderLals·
@akarshhyy Pondicherry has this lovely quaint air…. Beautiful.
English
0
0
7
629